The Tempest at Leurs (Part I)

17 posts1, 2
User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 39
Thanks for your comments, Rieda.

The story is actually at about, or just past, its midpoint. Half the reason that I introduced Perecos was for the sake of putting action in--there was a lot of dialogue beforehand.

I'm not really committed enough at this point to attempt a novel, so I'm just doing short stories like this. But I might do more stories concerning Saigot in the future.




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1618
Reviews 155
I thought this was good, overall. But I feel it had one distracting problem. Keep in mind, fantasy is not my thing.

Overall, the houses of Leurs covered a square mile, with the greenbelt of paddocks and fields radiating outward. They were constructed mostly by oak hauled down from the Gigatta forest, or in rarer cases (such as Sasburas', the mayor) from quarried stone. Mostly they were humble and compact, providing only what space was necessary, enclosed by roofs of thatch or wooden shingles. Only two real roads existed, intersecting near the town’s middle: one slithering north to south and the other east to west. Beside the east-west highway stood what was simply called “the workshop”: an amalgam of blacksmith, fletcher, and carpenter. Neighbouring this was a tiny chapel with flaking white paint, crowned by a wooden statue of the demigod Tifurien. Further along was the town common; a wide square of well-kept lawn framed by a flower garden, in which grew a myriad of blooms ranging from roses to theracorums, with their gold-specked indigo petals. Adjoining the


Woah, woah, woah. What makes you even think I would want to know all that? :p Kidding, kidding. Seriously though, overload of information. Some people like the heavy description; I'm not one of them. Perhaps, if you will be having characters travel through this town in the future, you could sprinkle the description of the village around in those passages. And, if characters won't be spending a great deal of time here, then what's the point of this chunk of description? It almost seems a bit like an infodump.

So I guess that sums up my main problem with this: liberal description. Sometimes I don't want to know what the character's face looks like when he says a certain phrase... Make the words invoke a certain expression in the reader's mind.

I did like the "'what is your trade?' 'Death.'" line. That set the mood. I also feel that you are building a solid foundation for a captivating plot in the future chapters.

I thought this was quite good, but my combined distaste for fantasy and your writing style stops me from liking it. If someone asked me if this was good and if they should read it, I'd say yes, they should. But it's simply not for me. :)

Hope you found this helpful!

Prokaryote



I'm all in favor of keeping dangerous weapons out of the hands of fools. Let's start with typewriters.
— Solomon Short