Scall's Magic

41 posts1, 2, 3
User avatar
Gender Male
Points 9907
Reviews 506
Derren
/3


‘The lizards that crawled into the crypt would have devoured fresh bones away, he hoped Varzin was wise enough to know that because the skeleton was supposed to be him.’

- The term ‘devoured’ confused me, as that seems to imply that the lizards would have eaten all of the bones, in which case nothing would be left for Varzin to mistake for Derren.


‘Pleased with himself, he sat in the depression and began to pile dirt onto himself until only his head was visible. He then filled the remaining hole up, leaving a tiny crack for air.’

- If only his head was left uncovered, how did he cover it with the dirt? After all, his arms are covered.


‘Surely, Varzin would want to see him so the next time he came he would allow Varzin to believe him dead and then wait for him to leave.’

- I think your comma is in the wrong place. I’d have placed it the first ‘him’.
- ie. ‘Surely Varzin would want to see him, so the next time he came he would allow Varzin to believe him dead and then wait for him to leave.’


‘It was when he obeyed these laws he was most scary, He would rise and become taller, making himself unquestionable.’

- ‘He’ = ‘he’.
- I also feel that ‘scary’ is too weak a word here. ‘Terrifying’ sounds (in my opinion) more appropriate.


‘Another man spoke in a broad southern accent,’

&

‘“We are not familiar with that game in the south preacher.’

- As the South is a location, I believe it should be capitalised.
- Also, in the second quote, you could do with a comma after ‘south’, to separate ‘preacher’ (to make it clear he’s addressing Derren, rather than the game not being known in the ‘South Preacher’).


‘he scriptures contained further instructions and they had been burned.’

- ‘and’ - ‘but’.


‘If either of us guesses his hand then I go free completely.’

- ‘guess’ would read smoother.



Rosin
/1


‘He quietly observed the bored faces of his fellow doctors of the Library below.’

&

‘Rosin went red, he wanted to slap her. He felt the eyes of all the doctors burning into his face.’

&

‘It was empty: the doctors of the Great Library must be still in the lecture theatre on a different topic.’

- Everywhere else you have capitalised ‘Doctors’.


‘Rosin read over the paper again and again. His services had never been questioned before.’

- I don’t think ‘questioned’ is the right word here; it gives the wrong impression.


‘who believed in the empire absolutely. Rosin was different; he didn’t care for the empire although he was obliged to serve it.’

- ‘empire’ = ‘Empire’ (it’s a place).


‘He glanced around, they enjoyed there livelihood.’

- ‘there’ = ‘their’.


‘They were particularly powerful because they were strong, and they had a lot of stamina to use up in the form of magic.’

- I didn’t realise you meant physically strong at first (I thought you meant magically strong) - I think that should be make clear.


^_^
I wrote the above just for you.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1106
Reviews 614
Thankyou for the critique, Ill correct and post the edited versions later.

More critques are welcome.
Previously known as "Phorcys"
Witherwings Harry Potter RPG




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1106
Reviews 614
Part 2, 3 and 4 of Rosins story have been added.

General comments, indepth critiques, feedback on parts of the story are ALL welcome. I welcome any kind of review.

Thankyou.

Gosh - Ive hit 8k now, 2 k more and my beginning will be done.

Rosin 4 takes you into the main conflict by the way.

Then I can start to think about my end and the middle. Fun fun fun.
Previously known as "Phorcys"
Witherwings Harry Potter RPG




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 9907
Reviews 506
Yo again 8).

Rosin
/2


‘The sage, emotionless, limped towards him’

- Everywhere else you’ve capitalised ‘Sage’.


‘Rosin smiled again, nothing like a Sage, it was in their blood.’

- This sentence confuses me. I’m assuming the middle part is talking about Rosin (he smiled, not at all like a Sage), and the final part is about Sages. The sudden switch threw me off, and I had to read this sentence a couple of times before I could work out what you meant. I suggest you make ‘it was in their blood’ a new sentence, and make it clearer what ‘it’ is.


‘They were made viscous for fighting, and then the ones with magical abilities were trained up into Sages in the lands of Nask.’

- ‘viscous’ = ‘vicious’.

- This is a confusing sentence, as you’re saying basically saying. ‘[Sages] were made viscous for fighting, and then the ones with magical abilities were trained up into Sages in the lands of Nask.’ Make it clearer that ‘they’ is actually the people of Nask.


‘One apprentice bit her lip seductively and held out her hand, “Kali.”

- Comma should be a full-stop. You would only use a comma if the sentence ended with ‘she said’ or ‘held out her hand, saying’ (or something similar). As it’s a separate action, it ends with a full-stop.


‘“Kali, and you are…” he regarded the other one, she was less pretty than the first but may prove exciting on the journey.’

- ‘he’ = ‘He’. This is a new sentence, separate from the speech, and so starts with a capital letter.

- The final part (‘she was less pretty than the first but may prove exciting on the journey’) feels as though it’s missing a word; something like ‘nevertheless’.


‘Rosin looked her up and down, “It is common for magic to pass through blood,’

- Comma should be a full-stop.


‘She fiddled with her skirt, Kali began to laugh.’

- You suddenly switch from Winfrey to Kali here, and the transition doesn’t feel natural. You could change your punctuation (changing the comma to a semi-colon) or add in a conjunction, such as ‘whilst’ (‘She fiddled with her skirt, [whilst] Kali began to laugh’).


‘Rosin was about to speak but the sage interrupted, “I am Sage Granik. Now introductions are over, lets go before our bones decay.”’

- ‘sage’ = ‘Sage’.

- ‘lets’ = ‘let’s’ (as it is ‘let us’).


‘“No but lighting the furnace like that will kill us all.”’

- I think this could do with a comma after ‘No’.


‘“Oh,” He felt stupid,’

- Comma = full-stop.


‘The sage didn’t answer,’

- ‘sage’ = ‘Sage’.



I love the way your trains move - it’s such an imaginative way :).

I’ll have to do Rosin /3 and /4 at a later date.
I wrote the above just for you.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 55
'Ello, Phorcys!
Well, as promised, here's a critique of the first part. Don't take my comments too seriously-- I'm tired tonight and my fingers run away from me sometimes... (Now THAT'S an odd mental image!)


Phorcys wrote:The girl gasped heavily, her breath melting on the bronze dagger at her neck. Derren held it there for many moments, waiting, waiting.

This first sentence stopped me, first with the adverb (heavily), then the image of breath "melting." At first it appears to be from the girl's point of view, then we're jerked over to Derren's. Confusing!

“Why do you cry, girl?” He spoke and forced the knife a fraction further so she pushed against the wall. She was silent.

You can take out "spoke and" for a tighter read.

“Hush now,” he whispered to her and kissed her softly on the forehead. He bit her skin delicately, drawing a droplet of blood. She screamed for only a moment before Derren forced the knife through her throat.

Ach. Creepy. Unexpected. Makes me want to read more.

Power.

Ah yes... very good. One word says it all.

He went to throw it but it did not leave his hand.

You should probably put a comma after "throw it." Also, "did not" seems a little formal.

“Scall, great demon” he whispered before kneeling on the floor.

There should be a comma after "demon."

“You have begun your path to greatness,” Scall hissed. “The divine art of murder has been fulfilled.”

Try to hiss that sentence. I mean, seriously. (Sorry-- it's a pet peeve of mine. :) )

“Master, I thought the scriptures had lied after I killed her, I thought that I had been fooled into a crime and that I was an imbecile for following your words.”

Oh, I should just shut up. But when I hear "imbecile," I think of the Three Stooges. I doubt anyone else will, though. *Smacks head* Shut up, Shafter!

Derren stood. “Then you shall give me my power,” his confidence had grown, a delightful passion in his eyes.

Period after "power."

The pain halted and he closed his eyes and felt a brewing power inside of himself.

The writing would be tighter if you took out "of himself."

[/quote]It gurgled and pulsed, trying to break out. [/quote]
Pulsed-- good. Gurgled-- not. Your stomach gurgles when you're hungry.

His hands looked at him and he looked back at them with respect.

I get this weird image of eyes suddenly appearing on his hands and staring at him... perhaps another word image would be better?

“Master, I thank you for this magic.” Still using his power to hold the girl in the air, he used more to rip the pendant from his body but a clear mental barrier had stopped the magical whim. Battling to get rid of his burden, he tried again, still blocked by a mightier force. Magic brought it back to dangle around his neck. Some things could not be disposed of so easily. His delight became dented for a few moments before the tingling in his hands raised his spirits once more.

I like it that he can't get rid of the pendant. I'm sure that'll be important later...
You say "magic" a lot. Can you replace some of them?

He caressed the girl’s knife wound with his hands and kissed her once again, this time on the lips. He suckled them, his way of saying ‘thanks’.

Yeesh! *Shudders*

A moment passed, his eyes gleamed with disgust. “Shoot him.”

Whose eyes gleamed? Who spoke?

“You are a murderer!” The wigged judge saw no reason.

No reason for what?

[/quote]“Life is but a trifle, it is in death we are most powerful.” [/quote]
*Cue villianous theme music* ;) I like that line.

He was once again the old, quiet priest – powerless.

Wait a minute-- he's old? :blush: Oops.

The last thing he heard before a flintlock was pointed in his face was the sound of rain bleating in pools of blood.

You've got a great rhythm going here, but rain doesn't "bleat." Sheep do. ;)

And that is all I have time for! This is off to a good start; I'm interested to see where you take it. I'll be back for more later.

Cheers! ~Shafter
Got YWS?

Over 18? Join The Writers Society today!
http://www.thewriterssociety.com




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1106
Reviews 614
Thank you surreal and Shafter.
Previously known as "Phorcys"
Witherwings Harry Potter RPG




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1106
Reviews 614
Ok - everyone who has read the story so far. Now I want story comments:

What do you think of the story and where it is leading?

Are you interested in the characters and there paths?

Who is your favourite character and why? (prefereabley out of Rosin and Derren, maybe Scall)

Is my world clear enough? What do you think of the world created?

Any other comments?

Thanks
Previously known as "Phorcys"
Witherwings Harry Potter RPG




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 55
Well, I just skimmed the whole thing. I'll be back for more specific critiques later...

Phorcys wrote:What do you think of the story and where it is leading?

After the first scene, the story loses momentum. I think one of the main problems is that we have very little reason to care about Derren. I know that sounds harsh, but if your main character is going to stab someone through the throat in scene one, you'd better start planting some seeds of sympathy. What has he been through? What drove him to this? Is his desire for power routed in some sort of tramatic childhood? You won't want to answer the questions right away, but hinting at something that will make us feel sympathetic toward him would be nice.
Interesting setup with Rosin and the mages and everything. I definitely think the story has potential to be "unclichéd." :)

Are you interested in the characters and there paths?

Well, I pretty much answered about Derren. Regarding Rosin: A little more characterization would be nice; details about how he views the world.

Who is your favourite character and why? (prefereabley out of Rosin and Derren, maybe Scall)

Rosin. I think he has potential to be a really great, complex character.

Is my world clear enough? What do you think of the world created?

You don't say much about the world, but details throughout the story help give me a feel for it. You say just enough to satisfy the reader without dumping a long description on them. I think worldbuilding is one of your strengths.

Any other comments?

Passing along some advice my dad gave me when I was first editing my novel: Don't settle for less. Don't rush the story along when there's a chance to make a really rich story for the reader. Bring out the interesting elements of your story, and don't settle for an easy answer when there's a more complex one.

So there. Hope that helps. I'm sorry I criticized your characters (I HATE it when people do that to me!), but it takes a lot for me to like anti-heroes. You can do it, though. ;)

Cheers! ~Shafter
Got YWS?

Over 18? Join The Writers Society today!
http://www.thewriterssociety.com




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1106
Reviews 614
Thank you. I know what you mean about Derren - hes sort of trapped in a crypt sulking bitterly. Maybe I could add sympathy their, OR add a flashback/past chapter about how he was bullied into solitary prayer, I have a few ideas about his past. I think its time to write them up.

Rosin does have his cardboard moments, Im aiming for him to have a backstory of hatred for the Empire, thats why he so willingly joins the Sages. I think his son might have been killed in the early days of magical acceptance. Im still toying with the idea.


Thanks, your feedback was most helpful. More feedback welcomed from others.
Previously known as "Phorcys"
Witherwings Harry Potter RPG




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1106
Reviews 614
Ok - thanks everyone again for help with this story. I dont think I will post anymore, I have enough feedback to continue on my own. So Ill go and get the novel done.

(Mods, keep the thread so others can reply if they want and I can review feedback)
Previously known as "Phorcys"
Witherwings Harry Potter RPG




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 9022
Reviews 647
That was sweet!!! A priest who turns to the dark side and he is freakin sadistic! I love it. I totally get the characters and everything. I've only read the first part of Derren but I'll more later and give a proper crit.

Just wanted to tell you that this is very very awesome!
"Maybe Senpai ate Yuka-tan's last bon-bon?"
----Stupei, Ace Defective




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1106
Reviews 614
Thanks for the comment Adam, much appreciated.
Previously known as "Phorcys"
Witherwings Harry Potter RPG




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 32885
Reviews 2058
Derren
/3

Sorry It took me a while to get back into this!

It was a crude yet simple.
a what? A plan?

“We are not familiar with that game in the south preacher.”
I think you should put a comma before preacher and capitalize Preacher. This also happens in one other spot, lower on.

Either way, when he got there no one could make him spill his secrets anyway.
Use one, or the other, because they both have the same meaning and with one on each end it sounds weird.

This was a two edged sword, no side sharper than the other.
two edged? I'm so used to hear double edged that that sounds strange to me... oh well.

Always enjoyable to read! I like your style. I wasn't as in to this chapter as the others, possibly because the action wasn't as high, and because I read it with more time in between from reading 2. Either way, it was good! I have no complaints! I'll read the others soon.
“It's necessary to have wished for death in order to know how good it is to live.”
― Alexandre Dumas, The Count of Monte Cristo




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1106
Reviews 614
Thank you Claudette for your insightful points.
Previously known as "Phorcys"
Witherwings Harry Potter RPG




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 14170
Reviews 571
Okay, I started to read the Rosin part, it really took me in but got to go for now. Just wanted to paste the mistakes I found so far, because later I'll probably skip what I read.

Quote:
He looked out into the lecture theatre to meet only silence. His smile was static.
A connection between these two sentences? I would seriously cut off the last sentence or change ‘was’ to ‘became’. -But that's only my opinion.

Quote:
“Excuse me, but where is this amazing discovery.”
Question mark.

-elein



Spend your days thinking about things that are good and true and beautiful and noble, and you will become good and true and beautiful and noble.
— Matthew Kelly