Penelope

13 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 7241
Reviews 721
This is for Caligula's Stolen Dialogue Contest. NOTE: I haven't written in past for a while, and though I combed very carefully, I'm afraid there might be a few slips...
-------------------

Penelope

Tiny snow flakes lilted towards the icy ground, covering the lawn with a dusting of sugar. The smooth glass was cool against my cheek and my steamy breath was melting the crystals that stuck to the window. A tree-lined path led from my office building off to the rest of the campus, through a pristine white lawn, speckled with glittering tufts of ice-covered grass. The holidays had shaved the campus of the usual hustle of students, and all I could hear besides my own slow breathing were the ticks of the old-fashioned heaters.

The grounds looked so innocent, like a canvas world waiting to be painted.

Face still pressed against the windowpane, I reached absently to my desk and retrieved a mug of steaming coffee. The smooth ceramic warmed my hands as I placed it on the windowsill. I did not sip it (I can’t stand the taste of coffee) but instead rested my chin on the rim, letting the steam fill me with its rich, velvety scent. I relaxed, closing my eyes; the smell of coffee has always had that effect on me.

A loud creak interrupted the silence.

Startled, I turned around, jostling the mug and splashing a few scalding drops on my brown corduroy pant leg.

“Oh, sir!” a whining, childish voice exclaimed sharply. “Have I engendered pandemonium? I do not intend to intrude upon your cogitation.”

I looked up. There, in the dark doorway, stood Penelope. She was a stout young woman with short, unremarkable brown hair. Her round, pleading green eyes were crowned with short lashes and arching eyebrows that were in constant shock. Though she was not large, her pastel sweaters and pants seemed tight and awkward, like she had recently outgrown them. She was a literature major and didn’t seem to think it possible to say one sentence without words that would send any sane person running to the dictionary. Under her right arm, she held a large cardboard crate.

“I had not fostered the potentiality that—”

“No, no, no,” I cut in, wiping my leg with a napkin. “I’m fine… why have you come?”

Clearing her throat, Penelope strode importantly towards me, her heavy steps muffled by the plush maroon carpet. She plopped the crate on my desk. With infinite care, she pulled from the crate a bundle of newspaper and bubble wrap. I leaned back in my cushioned chair to watch the show.

“Is it your effigy?” I asked. She nodded. Over the holidays, all the students of my sculptures class were supposed to make a painted plaster effigy of a type of food. “Why not wait until—?”

But I was cut short; Penelope had ripped off the last of the wrapping.

There, on my ebony desk, stood the most revolting thing I had ever seen. A circular plywood base painted bright pink sported a thick blue wire. Out of the wire sprouted the Art: a large misshapen lump of a deathly white and moldy-green. The lump must have been ten inches tall and seven wide, in a lopsided mass that was speckled slightly as if it was made of millions of maggot-sized pieces. Though I was disgusted, I had to admit that it was quite well-crafted.

“What is it?” I asked without thinking.

“It's an interpretation,” Penelope said.

“Of what?”

“Oatmeal,” she replied simply.

“Listen, Penelope,” I said, trying not to look at the towering monument. “Your effigy was supposed to be realistic. This is very well-made, but I’ve never seen oatmeal stand up like that… and the color…”

“Do you disagree that my art is a representation of my own inner sentiments on the subject which I have chosen to portray, sir?” She asked, leaning menacingly on the desk, her short hair falling into her face. Little beads of sweat were appearing on her upper lip.

“No,” I said, wheeling my chair back a little. “I agree that in art you are supposed to show your feelings, but that wasn’t the assignment. You will have to make another one—I asked you to be realistic.”

“I did not matriculate in your class to make impeccable reiterations of objects that already exist.” Her pale, round face was slowly reddening.

“Penelope,” I said, in a way I hoped to be reassuring. “This piece is very—erm—well-made, but,” I paused, and then said all in one breath, “What we've got here is failure to communicate.” She stood up and put her hands on her hips, her astonished eyebrows arching cynically. I hurried on, “Can you make a more realistic effigy?”

“I do not aspire to become a—”

“Just answer me simply,” I said, my piles of papers beckoning. “I don’t have a dictionary handy.”

She took a few disgusted steps backwards, her chin sinking into her neck. “Are you insinuating that my verbal utterances are unduly complex? Whilst freely admitting a leaning towards loquaciousness, I must nevertheless protest.”

“No,” I sighed; I had a lot of work to do. “Never mind. This one will do; wrap it back up and leave it here in my office.”

Grudgingly, and throwing me appalled sidelong glances, she wrapped up the monstrosity and put it in its crate, then placed the crate on a chair and strutted from my office. I hid my face in my hands, my wiry whiskers scratching my palms—and laughed.

I swiveled and looked out the window. A small pastel form marched proudly down the white lane, feet leaving tousled snow in their wake and straight hair swishing defiantly.

-----------------------------------
:smt100
Last edited by Azila on Mon Aug 25, 2008 12:53 am, edited 5 times in total.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1395
Reviews 565
No replies yet? Shame, I say!

The story made me laugh, and the quotes were well-done. I'd give it an A+.
"The one thing you can't trade for your heart's desire is your heart."
Miles Vorkosigan

"You can be an author if you learn to paint pictures with words."
Brian Jacques




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1618
Reviews 155
Deleted words indicated by strike-outs; added/modified parts in bold; my commentary in red.

Tiny snow flakes lilted towards the icy ground, covering the lawn with a dusting of sugar. The smooth glass was cool against my cheek and my steamy breath was melting the little crystals that stuck to the window. A winding, tree-lined path lead from my office building off to the rest of the campus, through a lawn that was a pristine white blanket, speckled with glittering tufts of ice-covered grass. The holidays had shaved the campus of the usual hustle of students, and all I could hear besides my own slow breathing were the ticks of the old-fashioned heater. [Meh, I don't really like this opening paragraph. Seems purple to me and doesn't exactly pull me in. Second part of the last sentence is nice atmosphere.]

The grounds looked so innocent, like a canvas world waiting to be painted.

Face still pressed against the windowpane, I reached absently to my desk and retrieved the mug of steaming coffee. The smooth ceramic warmed my hands as I place it on the windowsill. I did not sip it (I can’t stand the taste of coffee) [Seems like a waste of good coffee. :p] but instead rested my chin on the rim, letting the steam fill me with its rich, velvety scent. I relaxed, closing my eyes; the smell of coffee has always had that effect on me.

A loud creak interrupted the silence.

Startled, I turned around, jostling the mug and splashing a few scolding drops on my pant leg.

“Oh, sir!” a whining, childish voice said sharply. “Have I engendered pandemonium? I do not intend to intrude on your cogitation.”

I looked up. There, in the dark doorway, stood Penelope. She was a stout young woman with short, unremarkable brown hair and round, pleading green eyes crowned with short lashes and arching eyebrows that were constantly in shock. [Woah, split that sentence up.] Though she was not large, her pastel sweaters and pants gave the impression of being too small, like a little young girl [Young would imply little... I'd probably hack out "little," but it's up to you.] who has outgrown her clothes. She was a writing major and didn’t seem to think it possible to go one sentence without words that would send any sane person running to the dictionary. Under her right arm, she held a large cardboard crate.

“I had not fostered the potentiality that—” [This girl is the definition of a toolbox.]

“No, no, no,” I cut in, wiping my leg with a napkin. “I’m fine… why have you come?”

Clearing her throat, Penelope strode importantly towards me, her heavy steps muffled by the plush maroon carpet, and plopped the crate on my desk. With infinite care, she pulled from the crate a bundle of newspaper and bubble wrap. I leaned back in my cushioned chair to watch the show.

“Is it your effigy?” I asked. She nodded. Over the holidays, all the students of my sculptures class were supposed to make a painted plaster effigy of a type of food. “Why not wait until—?”

But I was cut short; Penelope had ripped off the last of the wrapping.

There, [If you insist on using a comma there, use one after "desk" as well. Otherwise scrap it.] on my ebony desk stood the most revolting thing I had ever seen. [Two sentences in a row starting with "there" = bad.]There was a circular plywood base painted bright pink from which sprouted a thick wire. The wire supported the Art: a large misshapen lump of a deathly white and moldy-green. The lump must have been ten inches tall and seven wide, in a lopsided mass that was speckled slightly as if it was made of millions of ladybug-sized pieces. Though I was disgusted, I had to admit that it was quite well-crafted.

“What is it?” I asked without thinking.

“It's an interpretation,” Penelope said.

“Of what?”

“Oatmeal,she replied simply.

“Listen Penelope,” I said, trying not to look at the towering monument. “Your effigy was supposed to be realistic. This is very well-made, but I’ve never seen oatmeal stand up like that… and the color…”

“Do you disagree that my art is a representation of my own inner sentiments on the subject which I have chosen to portray, sir?” She asked, leaning menacingly on the desk, her short hair falling into her face.

“No,” I said, wheeling my chair back a little. “I agree that in art you are supposed to show your feelings, but that wasn’t the assignment. You will have to make another one—I asked you to be realistic.”

“I did not matriculate in your class to make impeccable reiterations of objects that already subsist.” Her pale round face was slowly reddening.

“Penelope,” I said, in a way I hoped to be reassuring. “This piece is very—erm—well-made, but,” I paused, and then said all in one breath, “What we've got here is failure to communicate.” [LOL.] She stood up and put her hands on her hips, her astonished eyebrows arching cynically. I hurried on, [Not sure I like that "hurried on."]Can you make a more realistic effigy?”

“I do not aspire to become a—”

“Just answer me simply,” I said, my piles of papers beckoning. “I don’t have a dictionary handy.”

She took a few disgusted steps backwards, her chin sinking into her neck. “Are you insinuating that my verbal utterances are unduly complex? Whilst freely admitting a leaning towards loquaciousness, I must nevertheless protest.”

“No,” I sighed; I had a lot of work to do. “Never mind. This one will do; wrap it back up and leave it here in my office.”

Grudgingly, and throwing me appalled sidelong glances, she wrapped up the monstrosity and put it in its crate, then placed the crate on a chair and strutted [s]weightily[/s] [Watch out for ugly adverbs like this one.] from my office. I hid my face in my hands, my wiry whiskers scratching my palms—and laughed. Though Penelope was an annoyance, she was amusing.

I swiveled and looked out the window. A small pastel form tread proudly down the white lane, feet leaving tousled snow in their wake and straight hair swishing defiantly.


Pretty good, Azila. I like the dialogue -- Penelope is someone I can easily hate; you did her character well.

Remember, though...

NO: "Hello." he said.
YES: "Hello," he said.
YES: "Hello."

Hope I helped! =)

Prokaryote




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 7241
Reviews 721
Thanks to you both!

Prokaryote wrote:[Seems like a waste of good coffee. :p]

Lol! This is modeled after myself, actually. I hate the taste but love the smell. :D

Oh, and what's a "toolbox"? :oops: Besides a box to store tools in, that is. :roll:

Thanks again! I will go and edit it now to incorporate your corrections.
~Azila~




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1618
Reviews 155
In this case, someone who tries way too hard and is a moron. XD

Prokaryote




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 7241
Reviews 721
Hm... I kind of get the feeling she doesn't have to try. :P

~Azila~




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 370
Heya! I said I'd get to it:

through a lawn that was a pristine white blanket


This description is great, but this particular part seems a bit awkward. How about 'through the pristine white lawn'. It relieves unnecessary words.

I liked the opening paragraph, I thought it desribed the setting really well, but others make disagree.

Though she was not large, her pastel sweaters and pants gave the impression of being too small, like a little young girl


Pick one, together they don't really fit.

Don't forget the commas at the end of dialogue, its a common error.

Thisis really great to be honest. I liked it and couldn't find fault. I wish there was more to say, but there isn't, just_

Keep Writing!

~D'Aedomir~
We are all Sociopaths: The Prologue

Sociopath: So • ci • o • path noun
1. Someone who believes their behaviour is right.
2. Human.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 7715
Reviews 522
AKKK!! six replies already! Urggh!

Anyway, Happy Birthday!!!!!!!!!!!! Hope you have fun. :)


About this post: I really like it! I'd like to have a little more description, if that's possible. I want to know what the room smells like, and stuff like that. (By the way, I really like the part with the coffe. I can definitely see how you feel. ^___^)I noticed that the writing is very solid, and other than the stuff that has already been pointed out, I only had one comment:

There, on my ebony desk, stood the most revolting thing I had ever seen. A circular plywood base painted bright pink sported a thick blue wire. Out of the wire sprouted the Art: a large misshapen lump of a deathly white and moldy-green. The lump must have been ten inches tall and seven wide, in a lopsided mass that was speckled slightly as if it was made of millions of ladybug-sized pieces. Though I was disgusted, I had to admit that it was quite well-crafted.


This made me laugh. ^_^ Maybe find a different word than 'thing' in the first sentence?



Oh, and OATMEAL!? hehe..... There were a bunch of other things I found, but I can't seem to see them anymore.. ;) Anyways, if I see them, I'll redo this lame review.



Overall, This is very well written. Well done!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 17580
Reviews 798
Very cute story, Azila! Nice to see you're putting in some good competition for Cal's contest. :D

Some thoughts/suggestions:

Tiny snowflakes lilted toward the icy ground, covering the lawn with a dusting of sugar.

Lilted is a weird word. It caught my attention, but not in a good way.

A winding, tree-lined path lead from my office building off to the rest of the campus, through a pristine white lawn, speckled with glittering tufts of ice-covered grass.

"Lead" ought to be "led."

Startled, I turned around, jostling the mug and splashing a few scolding drops on my pant leg.

I think you mean "scalding," not "scolding." ;)

“What is it?” I asked without thinking.

“It's an interpretation,” Penelope said.

“Of what?”

“Oatmeal,” she replied simply.

SO. FUNNY. I love this type of humor.

A small pastel form tread proudly down the white lane, feet leaving tousled snow in their wake and straight hair swishing defiantly.

I don't think "tread" worked here. Why not let her strut or swagger or bounce or march instead?

I agree with you about the coffee, by the way. Smells way better than it tastes. :P Anyway, good work and good luck with the contest!
Got YWS?

"Most of us have far more courage than we ever dreamed we possessed."
- Dale Carnegie




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1609
Reviews 602
Hey Azila! :D

Just so you know, I started this critique a while ago and so I might repeat some things -- my apologies if I do...

Tiny snow flakes lilted towards the icy ground, covering the lawn with a dusting of sugar. The smooth glass was cool against my cheek and my steamy breath was melting the little crystals that stuck to the window. A winding, tree-lined path lead from my office building off to the rest of the campus, through a pristine white lawn, speckled with glittering tufts of ice-covered grass. The holidays had shaved the campus of the usual hustle of students, and all I could hear besides my own slow breathing were the ticks of the old-fashioned heater.


The first thing I noticed is that this paragraph is kind of adjective-heavy. Take the second sentence as an example: the glass is smooth, it was was cool against his cheek, his breath was steamy, and the crystals were little. You might want to cut down a bit on the adjectives, but otherwise it's a beautiful paragraph. :)

Also, I don't think the comma after 'lawn' is necessary, but it's probably just personal preference.

The smooth ceramic warmed my hands as I place it on the windowsill.


Should be 'placed'. :wink:

I did not sip it (I can’t stand the taste of coffee) but instead rested my chin on the rim, letting the steam fill me with its rich, velvety scent. I relaxed, closing my eyes; the smell of coffee has always had that effect on me.


Ditto! I used to like lattés, but not any more. Coffee smells so good, though.

Startled, I turned around, jostling the mug and splashing a few scolding drops on my pant leg.


I'm not sure, but did you mean to say 'scalding' instead of 'scolding'?

I looked up. There, in the dark doorway, stood Penelope. She was a stout young woman with short, unremarkable brown hair. Her round, pleading green eyes were crowned with short lashes and arching eyebrows that were in constant shock. Though she was not large, her pastel sweaters and pants gave the impression of being too small, like a young girl who has outgrown her clothes. She was a literature major and didn’t seem to think it possible to go one sentence without words that would send any sane person running to the dictionary. Under her right arm, she held a large cardboard crate.


- Point One: This description of her is well-written, but it seems more like telling than showing...
- Point Two: (underlined) It might sound better if you said 'and arching eyebrows that gave her the impression of constant shock' but then again, you said 'gave her the impression' in the next sentence. *scratches head* Just a nit-pick, though.
- Point Three: (bold) If she looks like a girl who's outgrown her clothes, then why does she have teh impression of being too small? Dd you mean too large?

“Listen Penelope,” I said, trying not to look at the towering monument.


I'm not completely sure, but I think there should be a comma after 'listen'.

Her pale round face was slowly reddening.


Comma after 'pale'? :wink:

“Penelope.” I said, in a way I hoped to be reassuring.


The period after 'Penelope' should be a comma.

“No.” I sighed; I had a lot of work to do.


Comma after 'No'?

--------------------------------

This is really good, Zills!

As always, your descriptions are beautiful, and your prose is very eloquent. I didn't notice a single place where there were more than four sentences in a row with or without a comma. So kudos on that. :)

However, I would like to know what the narrator looks like. Here is a place where you could sneak in a little character description:

Startled, I turned around, jostling the mug and splashing a few scolding drops on my pant leg.


You could say what kind of pants he's wearing. Even a small detail like this could delve deeper into his character.


Anyways. I love Penelope! She is so funny. Your characterization is thorough with her, I'm glad to say. The story itself is very cute. =]

So yeah. Not much room for improvement, as per usual.

Good luck in the contest! :D

- Camille
everything i loved
became everything i lost.


Would you like a review?
http://www.youngwriterssociety.com/topic73903.html




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 7241
Reviews 721
Thanks you all so much for your awesome crits!

I haven't had time to edit this yet, but hopefully I will get one later in the week.

Thanks again!
~Azila~




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 441
ello Zilly
here is my promised crit.

The smooth glass was cool against my cheek and my steamy breath was melting the crystals that stuck to the window.

I would take out the 'was' before melting. It sounds a lot better :)

speckled with glittering tufts of ice-covered grass.

You've already mentioned that there was snow on the ground, I don't think it is necessary to mention it twice, in the same paragraph.

The grounds looked so innocent, like a canvas world waiting to be painted.

Again you are mentioning the snow, I know its pretty and might have to do with your character but instead of describing in different ways every once and a while you should put them together, as a feeling. Try to avoid an info dump, otherwise don't keep telling us what the snow looks like.

I looked up. There, in the dark doorway, stood Penelope. She was a stout young woman with short, unremarkable brown hair. Her round, pleading green eyes were crowned with short lashes and arching eyebrows that were in constant shock. Though she was not large, her pastel sweaters and pants gave the impression of being too small, like a young girl who has outgrown her clothes. She was a literature major and didn’t seem to think it possible to go one sentence without words that would send any sane person running to the dictionary. Under her right arm, she held a large cardboard crate.

This is a bit of an info dump, maybe you could spread out how she looks in the course of her time in the office. I like your descriptions but they don't leave us with anything to think about, you have filled all the holes and have left none for wonder.

Clearing her throat, Penelope strode importantly towards me, her heavy steps muffled by the plush maroon carpet, and plopped the crate on my desk.

I think a semicolon would work after 'towards me'

“Oatmeal,” she replied simply.

That brings out a lot of her character, very nice. Its funny too.



That was very nice, I really like Penelope's character, she stands up for herself and has a reason to.
You are a very talented write, good work.
One thing I noticed, is that you did not explain any of the man's thoughts, that might help develop more of his character, thus giving us some way to connect.

Keep Going,
Gwen




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 8846
Reviews 531
Hey, look what I found, a Penelope review.

:P

Image
Image
Image

DONE GOOD

I loved the relationship of teacher and student that you portrayed here.

:P

Ta,
Cal.
Fraser: Stop stealing the blanket.
[Diefenbaker whines]
Fraser: You're an Arctic Wolf, for God's sake.
(Due South)

Hatter: Do I need a reason to help a pretty girl in a very wet dress? (Alice)

Got YWS?



There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy.
— William Shakespeare