Hey there!
This certainly had a very poetic style to it, for sure. You mentioned something about trying to put someone's poem into a more... prose form? I haven't read the poem before if that's the case but I think you probably did a decent job, from what I can tell.
I wasn't a fan of the main simile. I honestly don't really get what a sunset and "spread legs" have in common- and although yeah, I can sort of see it, it's still pretty far off in my opinion. Plus I just found that it left a bad taste in my mouth because the man seems to have a pretty dirty mind... and I just can never relate to the "awe" people have of sexual things like that. To me it's kind of off putting when people are that interested in reproductive organs that they see it in the most vaguest places- I'm not trying to be mean, I just think you can really do better than this simile. Also the waves were like breasts? I don't see it.
As a reviewer mentioned below, it's hard to tell what's going on in this story. At first I thought it was just the man on the pier, admiring the sunset and the ocean. But then it was like an actual women was there and I found it really confusing because I couldn't tell if this was the women that had been originally talked about (the sky/ocean/etc) or a new women who just had suddenly taken on a more concrete form. Or maybe she was the waves? I think you can clear this up if you just take a little extra time to explain the scene a bit better- if you're trying to get across that she's more human-like in the second half of the story, use something more real in the way you talk about her- maybe she touches his face? That might be enough to let us know that she's actually there- or maybe she speaks to him? And if you were aiming for her to be the same as the sky; a personification of something, you might want to still be a little more specific to what's happening. Maybe make her more un-human by saying things like she glided over the entire ocean- things like that. If that makes sense. Just some clarifications would be nice.
The last paragraph I found especially confusing. There's soldiers now? And it seems that there's been a war? But your imagery gets a little odd here:
he bodies are only bodies and will only be bodies and they crowd the young man's view.
What makes these bodies different from other bodies that you need to state they are only bodies several times? Are there bodies in this story that aren't only bodies? I wasn't sure what you were trying to say here.
He had never been blunt and so what he thought and felt hardened inside him.
I also don't know what you're trying to say here. How does never being blunt cause him to harden within himself? Are you saying that because he didn't express himself, his feelings ate away at him from the inside? I could see that, but it's not very clear at first glance.
So I don't get the ending, either. You're probably fed-up with me not getting things by now.

Anyway, I did really think you had great flow- especially in the first paragraph; I really thought you captured the beauty of a poem. And in many ways this did feel like a very large text of poetry, and it was really nice. I hope you keep it up! If you have any questions about what I said, let me know!
-Socks
Points: 5757
Reviews: 494
Donate