Hey there, Stella here! I couldn't find Chapter One to review- if it exists, send me a link but as it is I'll start here!
Okay so first of all there's a few grammatical errors to be corrected- just things like capital letters at the beginning of sentences. I know, I know, it's boring, but it's the mechanics of writing. You can't drive a Ferrari if there's something wrong with the engine, you can't write a story if the grammar isn't working. So punctuation=important. Plus, once it's all correct, your piece looks way more polished and professional, and it's actually easier to read!
Secondly, I was at first a bit confused because of the whole star thing. But as I realised it wasn't a metaphor I got interested in the story you were telling. It was really surreal, but I love sky images, especially stars (hey, the name's Stella after all) so I really enjoyed it from that angle. You have a lot of lovely imagery here- but there was something I noticed that I think would make your imagery stand out better. It's something a YWSer once pointed out to me when I was a new-ish member- my sentences were all the same structure. Lots of your sentences here start "He" or "The man", they all follow the same structure. Now, that's a really useful trick when you're trying to strip back language, make it bare and minimalistic- but you're not. You have all this fabulous imagery that is getting overlooked because reading such similar sentences over and over makes it a bit boring. But your work isn't actually boring at all!
So to let that beautiful imagery stand out, try and change your sentences around. Like look at this:
"He thought about how interesting such object could be; the dust must hold great knowledge. The man was aware of the stars and how they stand vigil for great times."
Now with a little tweaking:
"The stars stood vigil for great times, he was aware of this, and the dust must have held great knowledge. He realised how interesting such an object could be."
You see? By putting the imagery at the start, you immediately drag us in, you open up the story to more possibilities.
Overall I thought this was very intriguing and extremely unique, and I'm off to read Chapter Three!
Hope I helped, drop me a note if you need anything!
-Stella x
Points: 53415
Reviews: 1125
Donate