z
  • Home

Young Writers Society


16+ Violence

Birthdays Lost

by redcarnation


Warning: This work has been rated 16+ for violence.

You grasped open my mother’s womb with your bony fingers,

bringing me into a world where I was the prey.

You laced onto my pale-yellow reflection, claw-sharp and ugly.

You covered my peripheral with wolf-toothed hatred,

as expansive as the Pacific,

and my childhood dreams got lost somewhere in the smoke.

I awoke to the chlorine smell of war gas and birthday balloons.

You burnt rubber and human blood like garbage in an incinerator.

Jaws snap snapping, loudly perceptible when I came into a life reversed

on its axis.

my blood, popularized in the morning papers

carcasses lined the streets like discarded animal faeces,

and when I die, the world will see.


Is this a review?


  

Comments



User avatar
55 Reviews

Points: 5547
Reviews: 55

Donate
Stickied -- Tue Oct 08, 2024 2:34 pm
redcarnation says...



This is a poem I wrote for a school competition. It's not the final draft and I would love some critical feedback so I can improve it before I send the final version. Thank you!!!




User avatar


Points: 0
Reviews: 0

Donate
Fri Oct 11, 2024 12:51 am
View Likes
theobserverauthor says...



Incredible, this poem.




User avatar
8 Reviews

Points: 779
Reviews: 8

Donate
Tue Oct 08, 2024 11:55 pm
View Likes
dovehearted wrote a review...



thank you for sharing such a raw piece of your soul with us. from the very first line, your words carried me into a stark, harrowing world; a place where innocence and darkness blend into one. it's a stark one for sure. bitter.

the imagery you’ve painted of being born into predation sets a chilling tone that resonates with me deeply. it’s as though life itself is an ambush, and the starkness of this realization is as vivid as it is unsettling. that's hard to capture with just a few words, but you've managed very well. this feels both personal and universal. it’s as if the reflections we grow up with are separated from the outset, scratched by the harsh realities we cannot escape. war being one of those, absolutely.

your poem is very much so an apocalyptic vision, in my opinion, which is a disturbing reflection on dehumanization and desensitization. it’s as though i am walking through this devastated landscape with you, witnessing the remnants of humanity strewn aside carelessly. again, a good statement piece when it comes to the horrors of war. it is not easy to stomach at all. death and suffering come at a cost.

to offer some thought, perhaps you could write more of those moments of contrast; those quiet, almost serene snapshots amid the chaos. for instance, you could explore the dichotomy between the "chlorine smell" and "birthday balloons" mentioned. it would underscore the surreal feeling of living through turmoil, surviving tough battles. that's what the poem is about after all, so it wouldn't hurt.

what a poem! ^v^ a haunting resonance. a compelling narrative. it puts things into perspective and challenged me to consider the evils of today.

with light,
dove




redcarnation says...


Thank youu <333 i love your interpretation of it!!



User avatar
75 Reviews

Points: 9493
Reviews: 75

Donate
Tue Oct 08, 2024 6:15 pm
View Likes
candyhearts wrote a review...



Hai :3

This poem is absolutely incredible!! Right from the start, it's so visceral! This not only sets a tone of violence but also suggests a forceful entry into a world where safety is compromised from the very beginning. It really conjures a vivid image of something once pure now tainted and twisted!! It creates this eerie tone that carries throughout the poem, painting a world where everything feels predatory and hostile. I've never thought about that before, but I get it!! That's so captivating to me!!

You laced onto my pale-yellow reflection, claw-sharp and ugly.
You covered my peripheral with wolf-toothed hatred,
as expansive as the Pacific


I love this imagery!! It's really dehumanized, but that works. The depictions as "pale-yellow" and marred by "claw-sharp and ugly" attachments shows a corruption or staining of the soul. This isn't just physical but touches on deeper, psychological scars!! It combines animalistic danger with the raw emotion of hate. I think the animal metaphor is perfect for this ~~ It's feral and savage, which works very well with the context of war!! It's like the world is eager to destroy innocence and beauty.

^^^ While the imagery is vivid, the metaphors and descriptions can feel overwhelming or ambiguous. For example, the quote above!! I think that you could mention what exactly the reflection represents and how it ties into the broader themes of the poem. It's definitely something to do with violence and war, but I can't make the connection on my own!! I think you could focus more on the narrator’s emotional journey for something like that. How do they feel on a deeper level?

I awoke to the chlorine smell of war gas and birthday balloons


!!! This is stunning!!

It’s like you’re showing how innocence is overshadowed by violence, blending childhood with the harsh realities of conflict in a way that’s both beautiful and deeply disturbing. I love the juxtaposition ~~ Like, chlorine gas, a weapon of war, against the innocent joy represented by birthday balloons. That's such a dissonance!! It paints a bleak picture of a childhood where war and violence are constants. That is so bitter to me, but it's beautiful!! It's hard to face the truth, but it's needed.

my blood, popularized in the morning papers
carcasses lined the streets like discarded animal faeces,
and when I die, the world will see.


This is such a powerful ending!! It’s like a final, defiant cry that echoes beyond the poem, challenging people to witness and acknowledge the horrors laid out before them. It almost implicates the reader as a witness, creating a complicit urgency. I love that!! It's not something that is passively read, but instead, it's felt. War and destruction are very real things, so I love how this integrates real life issues with a poetic narrative. That's masterful and it's done respectfully!!

^^^ I wish these themes were a little more developed!! You have a lot of them going on (violence / identity / visibility), but they don't have time to shine on their own. For example, you could explore the implications of recognition in the end!! It ends the poem, but it doesn't offer any thematic closure to the real storyline. The narrator's story may be over, but what about everyone else? I doubt there is a happy ending, but maybe you could say that somewhere in the poem!!

This was such an experience though!! It’s so raw and packed with emotion in every word. It's amazing to read more of your poetry as well!! Keep up the good work; your voice is powerful and it needs to be heard!! <3

- Payton




redcarnation says...


Thank you soo much!! Your reviews are always so helpful and encouraging <333




I think Amelia Earhart wants you to get some ice cream.
— SilverNight