Hey! I really need some help editing this essay I wrote for my English class, based on The Glass Menagerie. My writing prompt was to continue the story 10 years later.
Honestly, anything to help make this piece better would be appreciated. Rip this thing apart is you must.
Thank you! ily
~ Stella
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
The woman, crumpled in a dirty heap against the wall of the dark alley, allowed a rattling sigh to leave her lips. She hugged the scrap of material, a poor excuse for a blanket, to shield herself from the bitter wind. Her stomach was knotting and twisting like a garden snake, her mouth drawn into a tight purse from hunger pains. Thin strands of gray hair hung from the woman's scalp. The hollows of her cheeks were enunciated, and her skin was an ill, sagging yellow. Amanda Wingfield had wasted away into a shriveled husk of what she had once been.
Soon after Tom's departure, Amanda and Laura had been forced to sell any of their belongings that held any value. They rationed the amount of food they consumed and amount of electricity they used. Opting to be plunged into darkness rather than pay a large bill, or starve one night but eat a bit the next morning, they survived. Barely. They went on like this for a while, until Amanda secured her daughter a job, working as a maid for a family in the upper part of town. Fast forward to a week later, and Laura was promptly fired, due to incompetence. No more than three days later, Laura was killed by a passing truck when she crossed the road.
Amanda had then sold each glass figurine that made up Laura’s beloved menagerie, and that damned phonograph that seemed to haunt the room, just by looking at it. She sold all her daughter’s clothes, and even managed to sell her bed frame. She sold the stuffing of Laura’s pillow and mattress to a manufacturing company, and used the excess cloth to made blankets for herself, since affording coal or firewood to warm herself was far from being an option.
So she lived like that, alone, placing all her time and energy into selling magazine subscriptions and books over the telephone. She became a ruthless merchant, using a range of tactics until each person purchased the item in question, or hung up with an air of finality. She was able to survive off of this meager source of income, saving money in a bank account, but no matter how hard she worked, she soon wasn’t able to pay bills, and drained her savings account quicker than she had ever thought possible.
A sharp knock knock! on her apartment door almost two years ago, and the words, “You're evicted, Miss,” was the beginning of her homeless state. She had survived off of food she had brought with her when she left, making it through the first winter by shielding herself in the doorframe of an elderly woman who took pity and allowed her to stay on her doorstep, occasionally giving her a bowl of porridge for breakfast or the odd baked sweet. As soon as Spring arrived, she was forced out once more. Since then, she had stolen and been stolen from, a self-taught master in sleight of hand. At this point she was a mere rodent, mousy and hardened and timid, cowering when stared at. Now that it was winter once more, the open-air farmers’ markets had since closed. Her diet was now rainwater and tidbits of food left on the plates of restaurant diners.
Amanda’s eyes were shut, but a shower of white light illuminated the darkness from behind the lids of her eyes. In her mind’s eye, an almost translucent, glistening horse - no, a unicorn! - trotted towards her, and astride it rode a young woman, who graced her with a smile.
The sickly woman managed to croak out her daughter’s name, a question, to which the woman nodded. She offered her hand to Amanda, who grasped it and effortlessly swung herself onto the shimmering beast. As she wrapped her arms around her daughter’s waist, the unicorn began to gallop as she became enveloped in white once more. The skies had opened up, and the rain fell in heavy sheets, turning everything it touched slick. A couple waltzed under the rain, silhouetted below the yellow, flickering light of a streetlamp. Their laughs floated down the street, reaching Amanda’s ears, and her mouth curled up into a smile as she rode away atop the glass unicorn.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
hi!
first off, the scene you painted was really vivid. I really liked that you had it in your head and it was like you were describing something that was right in front of you. That's something all writers should be able to achieve. The main flaw that I saw in your writing was that the sentence structure, or rhythm, if you will, was all the same. let's compare- try reading some of these sentences aloud to yourself. It makes you aware of the flow.
and
So, you see here, alone, these are virtually flawless, gorgeous sentences. But the structure of them is the same. like, sentence 1 and 2 both have three commas to separate the different parts of the line. Also, if you removed the pieces of the sentence in between commas, you would still have complete sentences. This is how they would look:
and
[quote]She hugged the scrap of material to shield herself from the bitter wind.[quote]
This is an easy fix to give variability to your sentences. You could take out the meat of one of your comma sandwiches, and leave the other sentence intact.
I now will point out that mentioning that the scrap of metal was a poor blanket is unnecessary, because everyone knows that the best kind of blanket is a blanket, and everything besides a blanket is a poor excuse for one.
so, yay!
your sentences are beautiful. Just vary the structure a little more, and you'll be fine.
futhermore:
I want to know more abut the eviction. Eviction is a big deal. It's a HUGE turning point in your MC's life. And the person that tells her she's evicted is probably burned into her memory- the voice of him/her. Being homeless probably sucks, and she'd probably been dreading it.
I love the ending...it reminds me of the character of 'the grey lady' from the Graveyard Book [by Neil Gaiman. If you haven't read it, read it.]. It's sad... But why a unicorn? what is the significance of the horn on this beast's head? why? Unicorns aren't one of those mythical beasts that are generally associated with death. rather, healing and life.
also, I'd like that bit expanded.... this is Amanda's death, is it not? Pretty big deal. It's like the eviction.
so, in conclusion-
. Vary your sentence structure
. expand eviction
. expand death scene
yep, that's it for me! hope this helps!
So, I haven't read the original work, but I can honestly say that I love this. The language you write with is really entrancing; it attracts in the reader really easily, and you obviously have a way with words for this to happen. Similarly, the way you describe is also really in depth and can paint a very nice picture.
As for improvements, I would say that you might want to place the 'Laura was killed...' later on in the work, along with other sorts of memories - especially if you were to elongate this. Alternatively, you could not say it in the same way - maybe in the sounds that you haven't explained as much, you could hint towards an engine, and then say how it reminded the title character of Laura, and how three days before her death... Etc. - so you could introduce it in another way. (This is only a suggestion - I do like how you've put it already, but it's just an option.)
Otherwise, I really loved this piece. I think the final sentence, especially, is really powerful, with a finalising tone to it, and I think you've made an amazing piece here. Keep up the good work!