Hey there mosedesmoulins. It's just lizzy dropping by real quick, so without a further ado, let the reviewing begin.
1. I haven't read an essay on YWS for awhile so when I came across your piece I figured why not. There is one little problem with the essay classification, this doesn't come across as an essay. It's more of a philosophical look at the past and future with a warning/message to other generations. I would classify this under "Other" instead of "Essay". The choice is yours but this doesn't seem to fit the essay parameters.
2. The title was certainly intriguing enough to draw me in. Usually I would go on for a paragraph or so trying to fix a title. I don't think that I will need to in this case. Congrats you have 1 out of the many possible points for this review from me. Want to earn another? Look at your first sentence of your first paragraph. This will be the second thing anyone sees and it feels a little bit weak and repetitive.
When I was your age, disease, infection and sickness ran rampant around the world, yet somehow we managed to survive.
It is obvious from the fact that you are re-telling this to someone, that you survived. You may want to consider rewording this. It is a good sentence but the "yet somehow we managed to survive" doesn't flow good. You could just re-word that phrase a little. Perhaps like this.
...but we managed to survive.
See how that isn't so wordy but still gets your point across.
3. The topic you chose is a pretty good one that has been moderately written about. It was a good comparison that you used in the last paragraph. I don't however see the need to move that separate thought all the way to the edge of the page. The bold was necessary to define it from the rest but the other seems to distract from the rest. It then has no relation to this long explanation you just gave. That's just something to think about.
4. Well that's about all I have for this review. Sorry I couldn't be of anymore help. If you have any questions about this review or anything else feel free to PM me.
Have a nice day.
-lizzy
Points: 650
Reviews: 766
Donate