I can remember the day almost exactly.
It was Rosie’s birthday. I had a gift for her tucked under my arms (a pile of books, all of them wildly fantastic) and I was running to our little cave in Gull’s Cove. Rosie liked to call it the Secret Garden. I don’t know why. There weren't any plants in there. Just sand and rocks. But that’s Rosie for you, I guess. She had all her quirks and then she’d give inanimate objects their own quirks. That teapot loves knitting. The bus has an awful cold today but the pharmacy doesn’t stock medicine powerful enough for it. My phone wants to be on Australia’s Got Talent but doesn’t actually have a talent. I would laugh at her and then she’d pretend to hit me and say “Shut up Xander, you’re making the phone sad!”
But I digress. It was maybe eight-thirty in the morning. Thursday. Summer holidays. It was incredibly humid, as if God just dropped a bucket of water into the air but it forgot to fall down. I was already sweating.
I knew Rosie would be there already, and Georgie too. Georgie was early to everything. Even school. Some days she would turn up at the school at seven o’clock and just sit outside the gates, waiting for the teachers to turn up and let her in. She called it being punctual. I called it hating herself. Who chooses to wake up at six o’clock every morning? She likes to tell me I should go early with her. I tell her that if she suggests that again, I’ll transfer to the boy’s school down the road.
I raced down the old wooden steps onto the beach and made a beeline for the water. I kicked my sandals off and put them on top of the box I had wrapped for Rosie. She wouldn’t mind if it was a bit sandy. The water was cool on my feet. My footsteps sank into the sand. It felt like a perfect day.
I got to the Secret Garden after ten minutes of nearly getting my feet stuck in the sand. It was quiet in the cave. Maybe they weren’t there yet. But then I saw a shadow move, so I barged right in.
“Happy birthday Rosie!” I yelled. “To many more years of knitting teapots and un-talented iPhones!”
Then I looked up, and Georgie was crying, and I realised that for Rosie, there would be no more years at all.
—
“There was an accident,” Mum told us. “A car accident.”
Georgie sat next to me. I was shaking. Georgie was still crying. She refused to make eye contact with anyone.
“What kind of car accident?” I asked hoarsely.
“There was a drunk driver. He went off the road, and Rosie was walking there…” Mum hesitated. “The paramedics said there was nothing they could do.”
I found Georgie’s hand and gave it a squeeze. Georgie hadn’t said anything to me. All she had done was run after me as I sprinted back home, Rosie's present forgotten on the sand. Mum had been on the phone when I got home.
“Okay,” I said. I meant it as a dismissal, but Mum didn’t leave.
“Xander,” she said quietly.
“No,” I said. I guess that was rude, but I wasn’t in the right mindset to care about manners.
Mum finally took the hint and shuffled out of the room. I closed my eyes and counted to ten, and when I opened them she was gone and the door to my bedroom was closed.
Georgie and I sat like that for a while, just staring at the closed door. It felt like closing the door on Rosie’s life. It was too final, too much.
“It’s not fair,” Georgie bit out.
That was true. No one deserved to be killed by a drunk driver at eight o’clock on a Thursday morning, much less Rosie. Rosie was the kind of person who lived her life in a whirlwind of colour and noise, and that’s how she should’ve gone out. Tied to a firework at the ripe age of 86 and let go with a bang, in an explosion of light in the sky. That was the only way I ever thought Rosie could die. She always seemed so immortal, like nothing could hurt her. I thought she was untouchable.
Evidently not.
“I know,” I said.
Georgie and I didn’t say anything after that.It was too quiet. All I could hear was Georgie breathing and the fan. I didn’t think anything like this could happen on a day like that. Tragedies happen in winter, in the pouring rain under booming claps of thunder. I got my phone out and plugged my headphones in. I put on this emo shit. I don’t know why. I don’t usually listen to that. I guess I just needed something to distract me. Something loud and screamy. Something that reflected the cyclone inside me.
I put my headphones in, then turned the volume way up. I put it louder and louder, until I couldn’t hear anything else at all. Just me, the music, and no Rosie.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Excellent! I love how much personality you gave your characters. I feel like I know Rosie and can sympathize with the characters why they are so distraught their perky friend is gone. Xander's reaction was very low key, but maybe he isn't very expressive?
Hey, maisewriting! Lupa here for a review!
Let's begin...
1) "I would laugh at her and then she’d pretend to hit me and say “Shut up Xander, you’re making the phone sad!”" You're miss some punctuation here. Put a comma after "say" and "up."
2) "I put it louder and louder, until I couldn’t hear anything else at all." "Put it" isn't the best verb to use here. You could use "turned it up" again--it works just fine.
3) Your sentence structure seems really choppy, and at some points I got really tired of hearing three- or four-word sentences. Make some sentences longer and see if you can combine some of them to make longer ones.
Overall, your writing style was really good, so I didn't have many nitpicks about your piece. You did very well with expressing the grief that comes with death. The sadness, the pain, and the numbness were all there in your main character. Good job and keep writing!
XOX,
Lupa22
Hello, herbgirl here for a review!
Before i start, let me just say welcome to YWS! i hope you enjoy your time here, i know i sure have! If you need any help with anything, or just want to chat, feel free to contact me!
Now, on to the review. i really liked this story, mainly because your characters are very well developed. Your details about Georgie and Rosie allow the audience to grow close to them, or at least to appreciate them more.
Now, that being said, i recommend giving a little bit more character development to your protagonist, Xander. The audience learns a bit about him through your descriptions of his reactions to his friends, but there's a lot more i think you could include, especially throughout his reaction to Rosie's death. You did a good job detailing how the death confuses Xander, but you never say how he feels when he realizes Rosie is really dead. Does he cry? Does he continue to deny that any of this is happening? Does he feel suddenly grounded? Or like he's been released, and is lost? There's a lot more you could say here, and i encourage you to explore it.
Secondly, you have a lot of short, simple sentences that gave your story a bit of a choppy, lengthy air. You can really see this in your first paragraph, although it does occur throughout your story. An easy way to remedy this would be to replace some of the periods with commas. See how much you can say with the least amount of words. This will make your writing clearer and more powerful.
Anyways, i really liked this story! The characters were very nice, although, i would like to know a bit more about Xander. Let me know when your next part of this story comes out, i would love to read it!
herbgirl
Thank you! I see what you mean about not having many details about Xander %u2014 POV characters that lack in personality seem to be a recurring issue for me
I just published a revised version of this chapter which is almost 500 words longer so if you'd like to see that I just put it up!
This was incredibly good, especially the writing. When I first started reading I was afraid I wouldn't be able to find anything that needs to be improved upon.
You started with a great description of Rosie's personality. Your use of words to communicate how Rosie acted was impeccable. You set the scene fabulously.
As I read further and found out that Rosie was dead, I came across the biggest problem. The biggest moment in the story should have been Xander finding out Rosie had died, but it was rather underwhelming. Up until that moment, the buildup was great; you had me excited to finally meet Rosie and then he finds out that she has been killed. I understand that Xander is supposed to be devastated, but the whole moment isn't as emotional as I think it should be. Especially since Xander is looking back on that moment. He could have been shell shocked at the time, but since he's looking back on he should be more upset that she's dead because it has had time to sink in.
There is one thing that the story left me questioning and confused about. Are Xander and Rosie siblings? If so, why isn't their mother more upset? I think as a whole, the emotions could be more developed.
I'm sorry I went on and on about that one issue. This story is just so good that I really want it to be written as well as possible. If you ever do rewrite this, I would be very, very interested in seeing it.
Thanks for the feedback! I totally understand what you mean by it being underwhelming
I went back and edited and worked on it, so if you'd still like to see it, I just published the revised version! I hope you find it better!