I've never been one for these caveat's provided by one-day authors to introduce their work. Let the work do the talking I say. But in this instance I feel some information is required or I will be inundated with nitpicks and general criticism about syntax and word choice. That's not what I am after. More and more I have felt I am getting close to a publishable standard. After a handful of drafts, my work becomes polished and consumable. I want to write this novel and this is a first draft. Before I continue with it, I wanted to get a little input. As stated, I'm not in the habit of publishing work to this site that I am not happy with, this piece is the exception and here's what I am after.
Advice on:
- Readability/Style
- Character
- Predicatability
- Premise
It's short, but so is the attention span of the average YW.
One in Two
The first thing you should know about Annabelle Clayton is she does not like to be called AC360, Alternating-Current or AC/DC, but simply Anna Clay. The second thing you should know about Anna Clay is she does not lie. I guess that’s why I believed her when she told me she was planning to kill herself.
“Hey Pauly,” she began. “I think I’m going to end it.” She took a bite of peanut butter toast, chewed, swallowed and smiled. “Why are you wearing that stupid look?” she then asked.
That was a special skill she had, she could raise a sledge hammer up the underside of your sternum and make you feel like an idiot for a change in your expression. Of course there was more to it than that.
Denial
“Oh come on AC what a terrible thing to say, you shouldn’t say things like that. You know there are people who don’t understand your sense of humour who might take that the wrong way.”
Negotiation
“So why do you feel this way? Have you spoken to your parents? Of course, you’re not going to do it. I know you’re not. Please talk to me AC. Think about your poor mom?”
Acceptance
“How long have you felt like this? Let’s go talk to someone about it, surely there’s something we can do to make it better. Does your doctor know? Other people with your condition have gone on to live happy and fulfilling lives.”
That's the cycle. Inevitably and regrettably what came next only made matters worse.
Anger
"It's just stupid, Annabelle."
"It's not, please don't say that."
“Has this got anything to do with Olivia?”
“What?” She said. “Are you insane Paul?”
“Well I fail to understand wh-”
“I’d rather die on my terms. Don’t make this about you and her. Jesus Christ Almighty.”
“If it’s something to do with-”
Her chin down, her eyes wide and fixed on me.
“Okay,” I said. “I don’t understand and I’m going to do everything I can to talk you out of it but I know it has nothing to do with that.” I cleared my throat quietly and looked away. “When do you plan on doing it?”
“Oh not for months,” she said. The flags of colour that had risen in her cheeks draining away again.
I didn’t cry, nor did she. I stood up and horsed my way around the dining room table, between the chairs and stacked junk and furniture. I crouched beside her and pulled her against my chest.
“This is nice Paul, but let’s not make it awkward, I’m not dead yet you know.” That special skill of hers again.
“Don’t do anything stupid, AC.”
“It’s probably the most logical decision I have made, but I know what you mean, PD.” She smiled and pushed me away. “So speaking of Olivia, how are things going?”
It’s not good form to leave someone alone after they have expressed a desire to end their life, but it is also not good form to leave your girlfriend waiting at the dentist while you visit another girl. So in the spirit of compromise I stayed with Anna a little longer, picking cat hair from my sweater and catching her up on what she has missed from school. On the recycled hard wood table my phone shuffled, heralding another missed call or text message. When the time came I called back.
“Hey, sorry I left my phone in the car.”
“I have been waiting for half an hour.” Olivia said. “It’s just rude. If I knew you were going to take this long I would have driven myself.”
“I’m sorry Olivia, I just had to stop off on the way.”
"Well I'm across the road at the shopping centre now."
I’m sorry, got to run I mouthed to Anna.
"Okay, okay, I will be there in five."
Anna shot herself in the temple with her finger, her mouth falling agape and her eyes rolling. Then as if realising the symbol of her gesture in light of our prior conversation, her neck tightened and her shoulders raised. Oops sorry, she mouthed back.
“I’ll be there in five, just sit tight okay?”
“I’m not happy, Paul.”
Anna’s house is kept as a metaphor for her mom’s personality. Inside it is aged and tacky. Cluttered, with a greasy floor and stacks of clacking junk, spilling from ripped boxes and bin bags. Pots clutch at you from the kitchen sink as you pass by, the moth eaten curtains are rarely drawn and mute the sunlight in an oddly distasteful way. Perhaps all that can be said about the interior is the warmth. In winter the double brick and open fire see that layers, gloves and hats are stripped and discarded upon entry. As you approach the front door from the outside, it is well kept, the lawn and garden neatly groomed, the roof an adobe red and the weather boards are bright against the navy shutters. I gave the kitchen window one last glance as I reached my car, I could only see the road reflected back but I wave, in case she was still watching me.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Dude, this is amazing!!!!!! I love it!!! You sir, are a writer. The master at the craft! Everything was painted into my mind. That is serious show not tell work right there. Keep up the amazing work.
Readability / Style
Reads smoothly, like a baby sliding down a warm butter mound. My eyes keep going, and if there were pages, I would be turning them. You don't waste the reader's time with pointless descriptions, you jump right into the story and let the reader figure it out from there. One complaint about readability would be Anna's house -- I'm not sure why I should be caring about Anna's mom quite yet.
Character
Nothing is explicit, a lot of things are implicit. Paul cares for Anna, even though now he's with Olivia. However: I find myself really disliking Anna. I don't particularly care that she used to be together with Paul, and suicide threats are a great way to make me hate somebody. This translates to a similar feeling towards Paul -- why is this idiot paying attention to somebody who's so desperate for it? Plus, she's a bit of a jerk with her little remarks -- what Paul calls the "special skill". Well done, you have made me feel something. However, I hope your intended feeling was not sympathy, because I have none of it for either of these people.
Predictability
Not a clue what happens next.
Premise
Again, the only feeling that this piece evoked in me is strong disgust for the characters in it. I understand this is only a short excerpt, and there is plenty of room to build that later; the writing is stellar, of course, and this alone will keep me reading for a while. But it wouldn't last the whole book. I want to see some positive side to Anna, something that would make me want her to keep living. As she is now, if I were Paul, I'd just say "would you like some soap for that noose?"
Your power outlet,
aC dCcCThanks CC, insightful as always.
I know the feeling, I remember the general loathing I felt about the narrator of The Fault in Our Stars, I can't stand characters that show attention seeking behavior or cultivate a sense of artificial morbidity. With that said I would be lying to you and myself if I said this story is not the least bit inspired by TFIOS so maybe I have borrowed that particular character trait from Green.
Hooooooooooooooooooooooooooooly crow.
Never in my short life have I EVER seen such writing.
The last paragraph is especially good; it contains lots of information about, 'what's her face's' mom. It's like you already knew her and got acquainted! THAT'S how good it is.
Person, you're too good a writer for your own good.
Write on!
~Swiftfur