Violence these days has become a tweet gone viral, with 140 characters of hatred and a hashtag of lunacy.
How easy it is to post “Modi is a coward afraid of war with Pakistan” and how painful it is to take bullets on your chest and bury your dead.
For every other headline saying “Delhi on red alert against attacks” there’s a normal citizen like me terrified of doing my normal things. The thought of a family member being blown away makes every inch of my skin tremble with fear.
If you call blood thirst courageous, I’d better find solace in cowardice. Of all the history I’ve mugged up in school, I don’t remember any war that has done us some good. But I do remember civilizations being wiped away and nations ripped off their social, economical and political stability due to war.
True that we need a solution.
True that we cannot and should not tolerate terrorism.
But I am sure war is not any obvious answer.
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
So hey there ishtadutt. It's just lizzy dropping by real quick, so without a further ado, let the reviewing begin.
It's been a long time since I've sat in the reviewing chair so please excuse anything you view as an offensive comment about the story. I know people get picky when protecting their works of art and I assure I'm not trying to make anyone mad. It wasn't meant that way, I'm just trying to adapt to being a people person again.
Please Note:
Spoiler
Okay first off the title. To me it sends across emotion but doesn't really reflect the truth of your story. I'm guessing you are referring to war being the monster but the writing doesn't really speak to me like that. My own opinions aside, you're trying to make it sound like war acts all by itself. That of course is inaccurate judging from the support you give.
Let me boil this all down a bit. Your opinion says one thing but the writing say another.
The paragraphs are sort enough to post down here but I'm going to put them into spoilers anyways, just to make everything a bit neater and tidier.
Spoiler
1. Numerous typos aside, I still have lots of material to use here for this paragraph. The comparison repeat over and over again and I can see why you were doing it. You liked using the family/friend comparison because that's something everyone will know. And it's great to use once or twice but you can't use it so many times. It gets repetitive and loses its meaning. It's sort of like when there's too much cursing in a comedy. After awhile all of the shockers aren't so funny anymore.
2. The little snippets of dialogue like stuff here and there is also a bit awkward for reading. You need to put a bit of punctuation, even if it's just a comma or split line, to separate those quotes a bit. It makes it hard to see where they begin and where they end.
3. For the love of god, please proofread for typos better. I mean they didn't affect the reading that much but for some reason I judge stories with simple mistakes more. Probably because the mistakes are so simple. I don't mean to sound so mad, I guess it's just one of my pet peeves.
1. The only thing I have to say for this one is simple. It's a good sentence with good emotion but I think you should probably just split it up. It seems like a better order, at least to me, to give this meaningful little piece of thought, stop, and then start again with further explanation.
2.
1. I actually really liked this line because it was free of all the things I usually end up judging good lines for. The emotion was pure and the reader can finally see what the author is trying to get to.
My next comments don't come until your final lines.
1. I don't think splitting the lines up like this are doing any extra good for your story. It may be best just to combine them together except for the last last line because they are really the same. Here's one order I was thinking. Also add an 'it's' before the true, otherwise it doesn't read well.
2. [/quote]
Well I guess that's about all I have for today. Hopefully some of this will help in some sort of way.
Happy Saturday and Happy Halloween.
Lizzy
The Queen of the Book Clubs
Thanks for your inputs
Hi Ishita.. just so you know, I am also an Indian.. And I can totally relate to the point you have picked up.. I love the statement- "If you call blood thirst courageous, I’d better find solace in cowardice".. The essay is realistic and makes us think.. Which is I think a great achievement for any writer.. I personally love writing realistic non-fiction essays and I truly find this one as an inspiration.. And I would like to add this for all readers that let us all just for once think peacefully for a change.. Thank You
I'm glad this could inspire you at some level. Means a lot :')