Hi there! Just a short review here to leave some of my thoughts on this fine review day!
First welcome to YWS and congratulations on already posting! I hope to see many more of your poems in the future.
Formatting/Style
Now the first thing I need to comment on is the styling formatting of the piece. Normally I don't like to linger on this, but you really did something unique here with the format so it's worth commenting on at length.
As Kara mentioned often poems are divided into stanzas with short little lines like 12 words at the most -- but you sort of combined the normal formatting with "prose poetry" which is where you adhere more to the rules of prose writing. Prose poetry normally requires the use of a lot of poetic devices (ie. rhyme, metaphor, repetition, alliteration etc) because without it, people are bound to ask, "isn't this just a short story" and completely misunderstand the meaning. The benefit to prose poetry is people don't really get distracted by line lengths and are more apt to read the whole piece kind of at once rather than philosophizing about each line individually -- they take it all together.
I'm not sure that combining both methods was effective for two reasons.
1) By taking the really "poetic" elements and removing them from the long-lined prose sections, the prose sections ended up reading as just prose or interludes to the poem itself.
2) It ended up seeming pretty random and/or arbitrary why you switched back and forth.
I would suggest sticking to one method or the other for the most part for a piece like this so that you can either capitalize on the benefits of prose poetry or normal poetry formatting rather than not truly achieving the benefits of either.
Last formatting comment, I don't think the lack of capitalization and minimalistic punctuation helped either - it sort of went with the feeling of "trembling" but again I didn't really understand the purpose of it.
Moving on,
Theme/Plot/Characterization
I thought the overall theme was pretty neat. You were able to quickly establish a feeling with the repetition of the mother being worried and establish conflict -- where the characters have to leave. It's sort of a unique theme and I think it was executed pretty well. In a way we could see the child leaving as a metaphor for coming of age or becoming their own person, or interpret it as inheriting their mother's worry -- there's a lot of interesting implications.
And the hint of bravery in the last line "but i step out anyway" is just the resoluteness that as a reader I wanted at the end of the poem. One aspect I wanted a bit more background on was the mother's backstory -- I see the spiritual elements but couldn't directly understand how those related to her feelings. But overall I liked the characterization of both characters.
I look forward to reading more of your work in the future!
best,
~alliyah
Happy Review Day!
Points: 119757
Reviews: 1026
Donate