z

Young Writers Society



Syall

by hawk


This is the beginning of a story centreing around the girl Syal, but i don't know if it all is flowing so well/

Winters in the north were long and hard, as the black ice laced the bitter hilltops, long hard lances of the high winds from the north scattered dead leaves from the resting place of fall. Syal leaned against the cold stone window frame and gazed out across the open fields as the first flakes of snow drifted in over the valley, a long, smooth strip of bamboo she held out into the air, swiping drifts as they passed. The snow she had seen before, and the pastures with men and horse, but this excited her all the same, though somewhat small in evidence to look upon.

“‘You go to your stitching lesson today, Syal?”

The girl turned from the window to see her brother skip up the last two stairs behind her. He was dressed in light shorts and a tight grey training vest, and his eyes spoke of sleep.

“Take me to the quarter Chriten,” she said, stepping away from the window. She thrust the stick into an invisible adversary and mimicked a parry. “I want to practice.” Lowering the stick, she complained, “I never get to practice, it’s always stupid sewing or balancing things on my head. Stupid lady stuff, as if mother does stuff like that.”

“You never even go, little sister,” Chriten laughed, snatching the stick from her hand. “But come on then. I’ll show you what the Capitan taught me yesterday, but you’ll have to wait in the kitchens I’m awfully starved.” The two set off down the corridor and into the warmth of the kitchens. The sun was not quite up but it was well light and breakfast was well underway, Chriten snatched two pastries from one of the trays and a piece of buttered toast. Handing Syal one of the pastries, they raced from the kitchens and out into the main courtyard below. The main courtyard, despite its name, was rarely used. Gnarly old chestnuts sheltered it from the sun that never came, and it was as spacious as it was empty. Brittle leaves of late autumn littered the ground and shuffled lightly in the breeze, but the heavy oaken doors were pried open into the forest, and thus the two escaped easily with sticky fingers and empty hands


Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.







Is this a review?


  

Comments



User avatar
4099 Reviews


Points: 253788
Reviews: 4099

Donate
Sat May 14, 2022 1:33 pm
KateHardy wrote a review...



Good Morning/Afternoon/Evening/Night(whichever one it is in your part of the world),

Hi! I'm here to leave a quick review!!

Anyway let's get right to it,

Winters in the north were long and hard, as the black ice laced the bitter hilltops, long hard lances of the high winds from the north scattered dead leaves from the resting place of fall. Syal leaned against the cold stone window frame and gazed out across the open fields as the first flakes of snow drifted in over the valley, a long, smooth strip of bamboo she held out into the air, swiping drifts as they passed. The snow she had seen before, and the pastures with men and horse, but this excited her all the same, though somewhat small in evidence to look upon.

“‘You go to your stitching lesson today, Syal?”


Okay well that's a simple enough start there. A very straightforward sort of moment to be starting off on and I think you're doing a pretty neat job as far as that's concerned. Its certainly enough going on there to get our attention fairly well as readers and on the whole it does seem like we're headed towards some exciting prospects here.

The girl turned from the window to see her brother skip up the last two stairs behind her. He was dressed in light shorts and a tight grey training vest, and his eyes spoke of sleep.

“Take me to the quarter Chriten,” she said, stepping away from the window. She thrust the stick into an invisible adversary and mimicked a parry. “I want to practice.” Lowering the stick, she complained, “I never get to practice, it’s always stupid sewing or balancing things on my head. Stupid lady stuff, as if mother does stuff like that.”


Alright, well that immediately tells us more than a couple of interesting things about what this person may be like here. You definitely get a decent sense of their character and perhaps a little bit about the kind of environment they are in as well. It definitely works well with introducing us to what this story might be about here.

“You never even go, little sister,” Chriten laughed, snatching the stick from her hand. “But come on then. I’ll show you what the Capitan taught me yesterday, but you’ll have to wait in the kitchens I’m awfully starved.” The two set off down the corridor and into the warmth of the kitchens. The sun was not quite up but it was well light and breakfast was well underway, Chriten snatched two pastries from one of the trays and a piece of buttered toast. Handing Syal one of the pastries, they raced from the kitchens and out into the main courtyard below. The main courtyard, despite its name, was rarely used. Gnarly old chestnuts sheltered it from the sun that never came, and it was as spacious as it was empty. Brittle leaves of late autumn littered the ground and shuffled lightly in the breeze, but the heavy oaken doors were pried open into the forest, and thus the two escaped easily with sticky fingers and empty hands


Hmmm...well that presents an interesting ending there. Its not the most straightforward of moments there given it doesn't fully seem to lead to too much there, but as far as presenting a bit of a start goes, it does certainly work out here. I think you have a pretty solid bit going here and you could certainly take this quite far.

Aaaaand that's it for this one.

As always remember to take what you think was helpful and forget the rest.

Stay Safe
Harry




User avatar
415 Reviews


Points: 31520
Reviews: 415

Donate
Sun Sep 16, 2018 5:56 am
keystrings wrote a review...



Hello there.

Popping in to give you a much-deserved review even if this is very late.

First off, I think that the description in the opening paragraph is a little long. The repetition of "long" and "hard" takes away from the (I'm guessing) foreboding tone you're leaning for. I guess I'm feeling a little thrown off by the really in-depth starting scene, but I think it gets a little distracting after a while. I'd suggest to maybe take away a few of those many describing words and instead bring some of these sentences shorter and more linked. I'd almost rather know why snow excited her, especially if it seems a sign of the mentioned tough winters.

Continuing on, I would like to point out this kind of goes more towards like an out-of-world narrator as the reader is no longer given any real thoughts anymore from Syal. Rather than just saying "lady stuff" I'd almost rather see her describe it instead of just talking about it. Also, I'd be interested in what Syal looked like, to even contrast the description of her brother. Their ages would at least give some decent information, to maybe see if she's being spurred onto marriage, or maybe he's the heir of something?

Finally, again, I think the description goes a little awry at the end of this passage, especially with the loss of a certain voice. But, I do want to point out I kind of want to know if that was breakfast time, do they not eat with other family members? Besides her mother apparently not being an actual lady but wanting to teach her anyways, the reader doesn't know much at all with the dynamics in this family. The very lond sentences come back with a vengeance, and although I do understand wanting to establish setting, I don't know if the wording of "the sun that never came" really fit as they just said it hadn't come up yet? That confuses me as well.

Overall, I think that this has some promise in the sort-of historical vibe, but I do think that this needs to be longer, for one, and to have more thoughts of the MC if this is meant to be from her perspective.

That's all I've got for now.




Random avatar

Points: 690
Reviews: 1

Donate
Wed Feb 09, 2005 11:39 pm
Atashi_Talespinner wrote a review...



I like thus far, but it seems almost too wordy. Try using less adjectives, or spreading them out more, to make the sentences less heavy. That seems to fix itself as it progresses though. There are some spelling errors, but that can be fixed with editing. I do hope that this isn't the very beginning, it seems a little incomplete (outside of the fact that this is only a portion of it). Try writing up a prelude of somesort to this to better introduce the characters and the setting. I feel like I'm lost and sitting among strangers.

Constructive critisism,
~Me




User avatar
1259 Reviews


Points: 18178
Reviews: 1259

Donate
Sat Feb 05, 2005 12:19 pm
Firestarter says...



It's short, but I can see already it's well-written and I'm expecting some good stuff with the follow up. Don't disappoint me, okay!?




User avatar
683 Reviews


Points: 890
Reviews: 683

Donate
Fri Feb 04, 2005 4:05 pm
Emma says...



It is very good so far. Though it didn't get me hocked at the beginning. Keep it up and I cant wait to see the second half.





cron
We always talk about the "doers" and "dreamers" but I'd like to give a big shoutout to the "tryers".
— Hannah Hart