z

Young Writers Society


E - Everyone

Common App essay- feedback!

by gottahaveFaith


So, for college applications I needed to write a common app essay the prompt was: Some students have a background or story that is so central to their identity that they believe their application would be incomplete without it. If this sounds like you, then please share your story.

so this is what I decided to write. Please review it and give me feedback.

Not all fighting is dangerous, or violent, and sometimes not even against someone else. Fighting is bravery, strength, and courage. It’s persistence, it’s not giving up, and it is determination. It’s not easy, typically fighting means a struggle but just because it is a struggle doesn’t mean you give up.

I know what it’s like to fight, but I needed to find strength within me to win the battle. December of 2011 I was diagnosed with Crohn’s Disease. I felt defeated since it was my own body turning against me. I couldn’t eat anything without having to throw up, I couldn’t last a day without a fever, and when I went to see a doctor they were perplexed. I ended up losing 30 pounds, and was not able to get up; because of this I missed a great portion of school. It was difficult, but I pressed on and finished the school year with a 3.4 GPA. It was not an easy task but I fought hard for my grades even with me missing a lot of the information.

A year after being diagnosed, my junior year, I was still suffering from medical issues. During this time period, along with fighting Crohn’s, I got in a snowboarding accident and suffered from a concussion and whip lash. Once again I missed school for a while to recover from my injuries. Even when I could go back to school it was difficult since I had to wear a neck brace. I ended up being months behind in work and I stayed after almost every day to make up what I needed to. I worked all the way up to the last day of school in order to hand everything in. Battling a concussion seemed even worse than having Crohn’s since I couldn’t exactly retain or remember the knowledge. The sad thing is I like learning new information and gaining knowledge but all my medical issues made it hard to accomplish that. I didn’t stop trying though and I finished my year with a 3.0 GPA and still made it my mission to understand what I didn’t before.

You could fight for your rights, for love, for yourself, but what I found most important is to fight for others. I have learned throughout my life to be brave, to stick up for those who can’t stick up for themselves. I know what it is like to get bullied, it happened every day in middle school. No one stood up for me or came to my rescue. I learned to fight for myself, but I also learned that I am not the only one. I wanted everyone to feel safe in their environment and feel like they had someone to count on. I learned from Gandhi that In order to see a change in the world, you have to start with yourself. I no longer let people walk all over me, or anybody I see getting harassed. I refused to be an innocent bystander even if that meant they attacked me next. I learned how important it is to fight for other people because if I show I am willing to stand up for them, then they can stand up for themselves too.

I am shaped through my experiences. I wouldn’t be who I am today without the problems I’ve faced and the lessons I have learned because of them. I am a fighter of good, rather than evil. I lead by example, to show others that you can be successful if you’re willing to fight for what you want whether that’s personal health, or anti-bullying. It’s possible to fight without fists, and it’s possible for change without violence. If you have the determination and strength to fight, you have the power to succeed.


Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.







Is this a review?


  

Comments



User avatar
46 Reviews


Points: 891
Reviews: 46

Donate
Tue Feb 25, 2014 1:10 am
queenofscience says...



Hi. this is Queenofscience. I would like to say that i really liked your essay. I feel that due to you battling this illness and continueing to work hard at school with make a good impresson on you.

Currentlay, I am going through somthing similer to you. It's a health issue, a very bad mentla illness and what is worse is that no one understand outside of my theripist at school. She can only help me so much. My family think that i am crezy and stuff and I have no support outside of friends on the internet. Every day I struggle. Every day is a new challange and I honistly don't feel like continuing my few collage classes. It's not because I'm a slacker, but because I have no drive to do anything. This is also due to my illness. I have been suffering for months.

I know how you feel, honsitly. You can pm me if you want/if you just want someone to talk to or anything.

Oh, and what is worse for me ( not saying that your situation was not horribal or anything because it is, and i very glad that your better ) that what i'm going though is a 'mental' illness. And it hurts because people stigimitze mental illness so heavly, so I have no one to talk to beucase apperantly 'mental health/illness' is a massive no-no according to scocity. This is what I hate most of all besides my symtioms.

If you want to talk about whatever, PM me ok. :)




User avatar
878 Reviews


Points: 35199
Reviews: 878

Donate
Sun Feb 23, 2014 1:21 pm
Demeter wrote a review...



Hi there gottahaveFaith!

It's truly inspiring to hear your story and for that reason I wish that I wasn't here to review this piece. My intentions aren't to review your life story, but since college applications are a big deal, I tried to read it with as critical eyes as possible, as if I was a college teacher determining whether to give you a place or not.

The first paragraph needs to be clarified a bit, in my opinion. I think you should make sure right from the start that you're talking about fighting with personal issues, not against other people with your fists. You do touch this a bit, but when I first read this, I was a bit confused because I didn't realise what sort of fighting you were talking about. Since the first paragraph is one of the most important bits in any text, I would try and reach perfection with it. Also, I wasn't sure why you mentioned "giving up" - there didn't seem to be a prompt for that.

Moving on!

When you started talking about the ways the disease affected you, it sounds a bit like a list. It's good to let the readers know your background, but don't present them with just facts. How did the symptoms affect you and your school work? How did you decide you needed to push through it?

It was difficult, but I pressed on and finished the school year with a 3.4 GPA. It was not an easy task but I fought hard for my grades even with me missing a lot of the information.


These two sentences are very similar - essentially, you're saying the same thing twice. Since it's so closely related to you, you must have more to say about it than that it was difficult. We can all imagine that any education is difficult if you're not completely healthy, and the college teachers know this as well. What makes your situation different? Don't be afraid to share your personal thoughts - that's what will make this essay unique.

In the fourth paragraph, you introduce the concept of fighting for others. It's a noble idea and good attribute, but I'm not sure how it relates to your story here - isn't the point fighting the disease to make you yourself stronger? This paragraph seems separate from the rest of the essay, since you don't mention the disease once. How does it tie together with the rest? Were you bullied because of the disease? What did you learn from the disease that makes you fight for other people even more?

I learned to fight for myself, but I also learned that I am not the only one.


The only one in what? Remember that even if you know your story, your ideas, and your thoughts inside and out, this is the first time the college teacher is acquainted with any of you. They won't be bored with details, because they haven't heard them before.

You also use some ideas that will certainly win you points, like the Gandhi quote and the last paragraph - these are all admirable features you speak of, but be careful not to make yourself a cliche. What makes you more worthy of the college place than the other applicants? Remember that the point of the applications is to impress the people who read them and make them think "Wow! We want that person to go to our college!" It's all about first impressions. Don't be afraid to boast a bit about your good qualities, but make it subtle, not cocky. What have you learnt from having the disease that will help you in the future?

I apologise if I've sounded overly critical, but this is a big deal and I really want you to be able to get to your dream college. I wish you the best of luck and remember to let us know how it went. :)

Good luck!


Demeter x




User avatar
763 Reviews


Points: 3888
Reviews: 763

Donate
Tue Feb 18, 2014 4:13 am
Lava wrote a review...



Hi there!

Well, so let me go over the essay and interject it with my thoughts :

Not all fighting is dangerous, or violent, and sometimes not even against someone else. Fighting is bravery, strength, and courage. It’s persistence, it’s not giving up, and it is determination. I think the sentence here would sound nicer if it was something like It's persistence and determination. It is not giving up. This structure gives it more of an impact It’s not easy, typically fighting means a struggle but just because it is a struggle doesn’t mean you give up.I like your opening paragraph. Sets the tone well

I know what it’s like to fight, but I needed to find strength within me to win the battle. December of 2011 (I maybe wrong, but should it be : In December 2011 or something like this? I was diagnosed with Crohn’s Disease. I felt defeated since it was my own body turning against me. I couldn’t eat anything without having to throw up, I couldn’t last a day without a fever, and when I went to see a doctor they were perplexed. I ended up losing 30 pounds, and was not able to get up; because of this I missed a great portion of school. It was difficult, but I pressed on and finished the school year with a 3.4 GPA. It was not an easy task but I fought hard for my grades even with me missing a lot of the information.You could talk about how you put in extra effort; how you worked hard through the portion missed. Also, I really hope you take care. c:

A year after being diagnosed, my junior year, I was still suffering from medical issues. During this time period, along with fighting Crohn’s, I got in a snowboarding accident and suffered from a concussion and whip lash. Once again I missed school for a while to recover from my injuries. Even when I could go back to school it was difficult since I had to wear a neck brace. I ended up being months behind in work and I stayed after almost every day to make up what I needed to. I worked all the way up to the last day of school in order to hand everything in. Battling a concussion seemed even worse than having Crohn’s since I couldn’t exactly retain or remember the knowledge. The sad thing is I like learning new information and gaining knowledge but all my medical issues made it hard to accomplish that. I didn’t stop trying though and I finished my year with a 3.0 GPA and still made it my mission to understand what I didn’t before. understand what? I don't think I'm getting your point here.

I think you can work on a better starting sentence. It would be nice if you transition from the previous para into this. Something about how maybe getting help from peers was difficultl, but it taught you to fight etc. And then say how it taughtyou to fight for others. --- I just think you can work on these sentences/reorder them to make it flow better. You could fight for your rights, for love, for yourself, but what I found most important is to fight for others. I have learned throughout my life to be brave, to stick up for those who can’t stick up for themselves. I know what it is like to get bullied, it happened every day in middle school. No one stood up for me or came to my rescue. I learned to fight for myself, but I also learned that I am not the only one. I wanted everyone to feel safe in their environment and feel like they had someone to count on. I learned from Gandhi that Inin. Small typo order to see a change in the world, you have to start with yourself. I no longer let people walk all over me, or anybody I see getting harassed. I refused to be an innocent bystander even if that meant they attacked me next. I learned how important it is to fight for other people because if I show I am willing to stand up for them, then they can stand up for themselves too.

I am shaped through my experiences. I wouldn’t be who I am today without the problems I’ve faced and the lessons I have learned because of them. I am a fighter of good, rather than evil. I lead by example, to show others that you can be successful if you’re willing to fight for what you want whether that’s personal health, or anti-bullying. It’s possible to fight without fists, and it’s possible for change without violence. If you have the determination and strength to fight, you have the power to succeed.


One the whole, I like this. It truly shows who you are; and shows you are capable of working through what comes at you. It's a good essay; and I think polishing it will make you stand out.
I wish you all the best.

Cheers,
Lava





I say, in matters of the heart, treat yo' self.
— Donna, Parks & Rec