Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Ummm, so hey! I like the rhythm in this poem. I like the words that you choose, because you do have a tendency to go with clear diction that can bring out the ideas in your mind pretty clearly.
But I'm really side-eyeing the topic of this poem. Really hard. Because I was okay with the reference to the chariot in the first stanza. It doesn't have to be taken the way of the hymnal, and could represent old greek mythology or something. But then you definitely take it down into slave territory. And I'm not saying writing about that topic is off limits completely, but it made me uncomfortable when the last couple stanzas took the liberty of speaking for those slaves, which you have no real idea of what their life was like, and said they had never FELT ALIVE until they were free.
Now, we both know that slavery was a terrible time, and that human rights were being ignored or not even though of at the time. And slavery still exists in places in the world, but I think it's almost parallel to saying that the slaves were animals and only really became people once they were recognized and freed, which is, I think, not at all the message you would portray if you knew that's how it came off. Yeahh~
So hopefully that opens your eyes a little bit to a potential problem. I love that you want to deal with strong issues, but be aware of every kind of implication!
PM me if you have any questions or comments about my review.
Good luck and keep writing!
Thanks for the comment! It was very interesting to read. I in no way, shape, or form wanted to portray anything about slavery. I didn't even mean to hint at that topic at all. This poem has nothing to do with slavery. I'm sorry if you got that feeling. In hindsight, I can see how you might have thought I was referring to slavery with the line "crack of the whip". I will definitely change that in the future. Thanks again for the comment and opening my eyes up to that! I really do appreciate it!
Hello there,
This certainly is a poem, one I found to be a very pleasant read. It lacks punctuation and capitalization, two things that are critical to writing any piece of literature, but I'm not sure that the poem suffers without them. The absence conveys a relaxed feel, and the lines themselves add to that. Calling out the allusion so openly was something I appreciated, because I never would have gotten it without your direction.
Keep writing!
Thank you! I'm glad you enjoyed it especially without punctuation or capitalization. I was a little nervous about not using those things, but I think I agree with you.
I love "The Tide Rises, The Tide Falls!" I didn't mind adding the allusion at all.
This is such a beautiful poem! I had goosebumps! I particularly liked the second stanza and the image of the chariot flying across the sky, which like for IHI, gave me the image of Apollo. The last line was amazing too!
^^
Woop! Apollo - you got that right! I was hoping somebody would get that.
The last line is my favorite, too, just because it is very personal to me. I wrote this poem recently and it's very reflective on, well, me.
Thank you for the comment!
this is a poem , which definitely rises your interest on poetry to next phase
Hello there! Your poem is fine actually. I like the repetition of 'this is a poem' but I don't really understand the point you are getting at. I suggest you might use situations or concrete words that could illustrate the true emotions or imagination you want to portray. You can also add a little touch of your experience so that we readers would be able to relate. There's always a room for improvement but you did a good job
Thank you for the advice!
I like the repeated phrase "this is a poem". On the other hand I think the format of the poem would look better if you capitalized all the words at the beginning of every line. Also I don't know if you meant this or not but I was thinking of the greek god Apollo while I read this. Was that intended or not? It would be great if you reply to this review and tell me. Oh, maybe a period or a comma at the end of every stanza might make it look better too maybe? I'm not that good at finding the deeper meaning in poems or at grammar but I hope this helps.
It is an allusion to Apollo! I love Greek myths and he is one of my favorites. I actually did not want to capitalize or use punctuation. I usually write my poems without it. I don't really know why - its just my kinda style. Your review did help. Thank you!