Hey, sorry I've been away for a bit. A bunch of novels I'm caught up with released chapters all at the same time.
Nit-picks and nice moments:
Nikki snorted then mocked playfully, “Oh you’ve asked plenty. He just answers yours without a fuss, don’t you loverboy?”
Ivy thought she could see Grey redden beneath the layer of grime on his face. She could feel her own face heating, so she was glad Grey suddenly couldn’t look her in the eyes.
Ooooh that wasn't something that had occurred to me. Maybe a little more foreshadowing... Although actually I guess the mirroring of the two of them in the chapter where they respectively meet Ghost/find bread might have suggested something like that... Okay yeah, I think I buy it.
Alder sends me to go dicker over the cheapest food I can find on the weekends.
Ah, okay, that answers a question I had from a previous chapter.
and his eccentricity causes him to live like he’s poor
That's a bit clunky. I think something like "and just lives like he's poor because he's an old eccentric" might flow better.
(still a little bit of a weak ending, but what can you do?)
Ach, you're fine. Not all chapters need to end on wicked cliffhangers. Actually I wonder if the periodical nature of a writing site causes writers to tend towards that. Gotta keep those readers hooked... Whereas in a book you'd just turn onto the next page, especially when you're already this far in, you know what I mean?
(flat swaths of iron with holes drilled along the sides. They always needed more metal panels)
It's kind of weird to start a new sentence inside parenthesis so maybe use a semi-colon instead.
No specific bit to quote, but could you maybe underline the POV character's name, or put it in bold or something? My eyes skimmed over it and I got confused for a second. Not a big deal if you'd rather not though. And actually it probably only matters in this one case where a work contains bits from two chapters.
Ivy nodded and stood, stretching a bit. “What are we going to be doing?”
“Working on Alder’s obsession. ‘The Machine to Cull the Darkness’ or whatever he calls it.”
This sort of underlines an issue I'm having. They joined for a reason, and I'm not overly clear on what it was. You told us a lot about how Alder spoke, but not a massive amount about what he said. I assumed it was his conspiracy theory that hooked them, but if that is treated by the characters as a sort of side thing, then I think I'm confused.
projects actively being worked on ended up there
"ended up" sounds like something that is covered in a layer of dust
In a way. The workshop was a hurricane, with the most clutter in the center.
That should all be one sentence.
I realize that hethink’sthinks it’s physical
Gahhhh this is so steampunk I love it!
They spend the next several hours working
"spent"
His ears automatically strained to listen to what they were saying
not a nit-pick but I read that as "straightened" and pictured Grey as a fox/wolf/lynx for a moment
and the coldbox is an iceless icebox
iceless?
Overall:
It was very good to get a solid chapter in of what working in the workshop is like. I get the feeling a fair bit of the story is going to take place in the workshop, so getting a lot of the setting out now means that you only have to tell me interesting bits in the future, so the plot isn't held up by having to explain background. I quite often forget to do this (the first couple of chapters up for my current work are soooo confusing) so nice work on getting that done
The relationship between Ivy and Grey is developing at a decent pace. It was maybe a bit of a sudden development but like I said I'm undecided on that. I'll keep an eye out for the pacing of that.
My main criticism is that I still don't really understand what they're doing there. I get that Grey doesn't even know, but I'm unsure what it was that they stuck around for if it wasn't this trapping the darkness thing. I think that could be just a bit clearer.
I stupidly announced on the discord that I was going to catch up on my revmo reviews tonight so I'll see you soon,
Biscuits
Points: 31396
Reviews: 760
Donate