Published July 19, 2010
First attempt at writing fantasy please give me your honest opinions and critique, especially harsh, is very much appreciated
bElL3
Prologue- Departure
He walked silently along the trail, stepping over the gnarled roots and ducking underneath the overhanging branches
of the trees that fringed treacherously across his path. All was silent there among the twisted ebony trees, but he could
sense the creatures watching him curiously from the safety of the shadows, both in the underbrush and in the tangled
black branches above. He listened to the rhythmic beating of their hearts, and felt the minute vibrations that it caused
as the blood rushed to and from their feet, as well the tremors caused by their every movement.
He closed his eyes as he walked, fully aware of his surroundings, and focused on the constant buzzing of thoughts alien
to his own in his conscience. He could only grin when he sensed the apprehension of the villagers far behind him as they
rushed about the village trying to prepare everything before she arrived. The women were afraid that there would be no
time to prepare the feasts in time for their consumption. Many of the servants hurried to arrange unlit lanterns around
the village and pick bouquets of flowers for the table. All minds were spastic and thoughts were muddled in the
excitement of things. All save one.
His mind was like a beehive, filled to bursting with bees that drummed along throughout the hive, and with each one of
the hundreds of “bees” he shared a close and personal bond where there were no secrets between them, no lies or any
possibility for deception. Sometimes it was all so loud in his own conscience that he could not hear his own thoughts or
musings and he longed for silence, true and absolute silence. However, he knew there would never be a chance of that
prospect ever coming to pass. It was impossible to ignore, impossible to control.
The forest thinned out into nothing, the hard clay soil was replaced by soft sand which blurred his vision uncomfortably.
He opened his eyes and saw a single figure standing alone on the shore beside a sail boat.
Swallowing, he approached the figure and knelt on the ground before him.
For a long while, the only sounds were those of the waves that crashed against the shore, and the cool breeze that
whispered through the forest.
He looked up at the figure standing in front of him to find he was gazing down at him with soft, wistful blue eyes full of
hope and pride that seemed to read into his own eyes of violet, full of self-doubt and pain.
The other turned to face him, and at last, began to speak, ‘My time here is over and done… This night, I leave for the Land of my Fathers, never again to return. I leave behind my legacy to be remembered by my sons and my people. And I bestow upon thee, Heir, my kingdom, the land crafted by our lord, Ashe`, and the right to be its king, to govern our people on a righteous path and to guide our kind into the dawn of a new and glorious era. Do you accept?’
‘I do,’ he half-whispered, his own voice sounding distant to his ears.
The other cleared his throat, ‘Then, son of Zaera, now passed, and of… Ashe`, god of all things shadow… I name you King of Isle Sha Do.’ He placed a silver band over his head and took a step back, ‘May you reign many long and prosperous years.’
He stood to his feet, and it was silent again.
‘I wish to give you my broadswords,’ the other said softly, revealing a black leather sheathe which he pulled out of his cloak, ‘These have been handed down from generation to generation for thousands of years... My father gave them to me when he departed. And while you are not my son by blood you have been my son in every other possible way.’
He accepted the sheathe and whispered, ‘You realize you are the only one I ever have and ever will consider as my father?’
The other was quiet but smiled tearfully, and then climbed into his sailboat.
He watched him sail away and disappear beyond the horizon, and stood where he was until at last his conscience slipped
out of his reach.
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hello, bElL3! Firefly here for a review!
Grammar (punctuation usage, word choice, spelling, etc)
Syntax (does you sentence make any sense)
First of all, I'd like to congratulate you on making an attempt at writing fantasy. It can be pretty difficult to effectively set up a brave new world in a way your readers would not only understand, but enjoy. And, fantasy happens to be one of my favorite genres, so double kudos!
Secondly, during this process I will be looking for these two elements:
To make this process easier, everything is color coded!
(Blue words) in parentheses represent comments on anything other than what's listed above
Green words represent comments on syntax
Red words represent changes in grammar usage
Red wordsthat are struck out mean you should remove that word entirelyNow, I suppose I've stalled long enough. On to your review!
I felt nothing for either of your characters. How could I, when there wasn't enough known about them to feel anything for them! This lack of information really turned me off from the story, because I couldn't emotionally attach myself to anyone. To help with this, you should describe your characters: what they look like, what they're thinking, how they feel about a certain thing, etc. Do this, and your story will go up dramatically in personalization points.
Overall, I feel that this story has potential. It's a bit muddled right now, and there are certain areas that just don't flow very well (for instance, the continuity of the beehive metaphor). What it's about, exactly, remains a blur, but I have faith that you'll clear this up and make me eat all of my words from tonight!
I'll keep an eager eye on your story. Keep writing!
~Firefly
Hiya bElL3! SporkPunk here for the review.
So, overall: I thought it was a good idea, but I found it difficult to follow and immerse myself in. Is there a reason why the characters are unnamed? Usually, I tend to like the anonymity in prologues, but for this particular piece, it didn't work for me.
I noticed a few things you might want to take a look at. One, your spacing. Why did you choose to space it that way? For me, it was really awkward trying to read it. I didn't like it much. Single quotation marks aren't used unless you use the double ones first.
Like that. You only use the single ones like this:
Other than that, I don't see any major grammar errors. The idea you have is good, and with a bit of tweaking, it could be amazing! Feel free to PM me if you have any questions or would like an expansion on anything.