Published April 25, 2009
deleted.
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Purgatory, eh? You say it's a cliche? I dunno, sounds pretty cool to me.
When I first read this, I thought she was saying this in a calm voice, kind of like "Gaunt, you and your crazy antics. Ha ha." It had a comical effect on me that I know wasn't intended. Just stress how she's worried and concerned, as I'm sure that's what you meant to convey.Your writing is decent, but I would a less passive voice next time I write and try to use an active on instead. Do you know what I mean?
In other words, you say "this happened, that happened," but you should try to involve the reader as much as you can by making him feel like he's in the book, rather than just observing a scene. When you use a passive voice, the reader doesn't feel as interested, even if something really dramatic happens, like what occurred in this story.
Word of advice, however: there are some cases when passive voices are appropriate and okay to use. Rule s in art tend to slip. It's usually best to show and not tell, but there are some cases when telling is best, etc. Don't think of writing as "rule-driven" like math, but context-sensitive.
Let me give you some examples to start you off:
This is just one of the examples where you use a passive-voice. You state this as though it's no more interesting than dropping by the store and buying groceries. At least, that's the impression I get. You could try something like:
Running at full-speed, he quickly jumped into the air, his body shattering the window. He had no conscious thoughts as this happened, but he heard the firing of a pistol, and could feel it glide JUST inches above his neck. Despite being in mortal danger, he didn't think much of this. And then he began to fall... See what I did? I might have made some personal mistakes, but at least I made the reader feel like he was the character, and not just a passionless observer.
I'll make a mental note to check on your next piece and see how you improved
Don't worry, the characters are developed later in the story (When they're in purgatory). Yeah, I know its a bit cliche but the story gets more creative as it progresses =D.
Thanks for the review!
Some minor errors with grammar, and your word choice was a little off at times.
Otherwise, your narrative is coherent and easy to read. And some of your images and lines were quite effective.
I found the characters to be a little stereotypical and the plot rather flimsy. There are some cliche elements that make your story both more cheesy and more accessible to the reader. I would say that you haven't taken yourself seriously enough for the cliches to matter greatly, though.
Overall, it comes across as a simple and fun piece to read.
Keep writing.