Hey ToxicAnglerFish!
I know it's been a few days, but welcome to YWS. You can always feel free to let me know if you have any questions, but for now I'm going to review your lovely piece.
The first thing that I wanted to mention is the balance of dialogue and description--mostly because the only description you have is in the very last paragraph! It's cool to have a story entirely composed of dialogue if that was your goal, but here are two suggestions. First, if you didn't want to use all dialogue, it would be cool if you slipped in a little bit of description and imagery, or even just dialogue tags. And second, if you want to keep this as completely dialogue, then I think you might want to work over the dialogue to make it a bit clearer since that's the only way we can figure out what's going on. An example of this would be giving the characters really clear voices--heighten Rebecca's lovesick attitude, and heighten Rosina's relative creepiness. You can also add in some clarifying dialogue, like, "Lilly! You're back already?" "Yeah, I forgot I needed to get something at the store, but why are you talking to an empty garden?" That would give us a just a little more context that we'd otherwise get through description!
“My oh my, how beautiful these red roses are! How they look so soft and vibrant, yet bold and lovely at the same time! How they remind me of the legend of the Red Rose~”
“Hm? Who are you?”
“I'm Rosina, the watcher over the Rose Gardens of Mosswood, you are?”
“I’m Rebecca, I'm just visiting this town with my girlfriend Lilly as part of my summer vacation from work.”
“How lovely Rebecca, welcome to our little town! Anyway, have you seen the roses, their so beautiful, so delicate, so-”
The legend is quite compelling, but I wish your first few paragraphs pulled us into it a little more! Here, Rosina is a little like "oh hum-dee-dum, look at these flowers!" as if she's just waiting to be noticed by Rebecca. However, since she seems to be warning Rebecca about her own mistaken love, it might be better for her to announce herself and her purpose right away. If, for example, Rebecca had said, "See you later, Lilly my love!" Then there could be a little exchange like this:
"My love?" (Rosina)
"Who said that?"
"I'm Rosina (etc.) Is it possible that you haven't yet heard of the legend of the red roses?"
Then we'd start in with a little creepiness right away, if that makes sense?
Here,
“Aw, I won! Well, I hope you enjoy the legend that has shaped this town view on love, romance-”
“Get on with it Rosina!”
This is sort of how two friends joke around, which isn't really the position these two are in. It might be more compelling to have an edge of conflict, like,
"You're being really creepy about this, Rosina. I think I'll leave--"
"No! No, it's tradition to tell this story to anyone first entering the town. Please, just... listen to me."
Does that make sense? More than making Rebecca listen to the legend, you need to draw the readers into the legend as well.
As for the legend itself, the first thing you might consider doing is breaking it up into several different paragraphs! It's kind of in two big chunks right now, which makes it a little harder to read. Readers love bite-sized bits in paragraphs, and adding in paragraphs might help with the way your story flows as well.
Second, you focus a lot on physical beauty here. I think you're trying to make the point that the relationship was founded on ideals of beauty instead of trust? (Correct me if I'm wrong) If that's the case, then you may want to emphasize that theme. After all of the wedding imagery, drop some foreshadowing! Something like, "They made a handsome couple, and they looked beautiful together surrounded by roses, but as Rosie soon discovered, beauty is not everything."
And finally, just a smidge bit of practicality, sorry! I'm not sure the whole murder bit is believable-- not that it happened, but how it happened. Joseph told everyone it was an accident, but wouldn't they know it was a lie because he had already buried her? Who buries the body of their spouse after an accident occurs??? It would be more believable if he actually pushed her down the stairs (or some other "accident" scenario) and then immediately called the police to report it. OR, you could stick with your current murder, but instead of inheriting the money like he probably wanted to, the police would immediately launch an investigation and find proof of the murder. Just overall, I'm not sure he'd get away with it as much as he did and you might want to make it a little more plausible.
“I don’t see anyone… But maybe you, Anyway, here are some roses I found you for my Rebecca.”
“Thank you very much, Lilly… I really want to doubt the legend being real but something was off about the Rosina girl I might have been talking to…”
I don't think Rebecca has brought up the legend to Lilly before this? You might want to introduce it a little, like, "It's funny that you got me red roses, this Rosina girl was just telling me a legend about them." Even if she doesn't believe it, make the connection very obvious! It would be interesting as well if Rosina actually gave Rebecca a single rose, as a warning to her.
“Love you too, Rebecca.”
Since there's no description here, we can't tell how it's read! But I wonder, if instead of saying "I love you" back Lilly said, "Yeah. Thanks, Rebecca." or something like that we could tell that the love was not reciprocated. Just a thought you could experiment with!
“And as they went off with each other holding hands whilst in love, Rosina watched from behind as she had a sad frown on her face, tears rolling down her pale, see-through face. She dreaded knowing she could see a bottle of cyanide in Lilly’s pants pocket as Rebbeca and Lilly, the couple ran off with only one being in love.”
No need for quotation marks here, because no one is saying this part. But I do wonder how Rosina could have known about the cyanide...? And I wonder if you could make it more clear that Rosina is Rosie (I assume that she is). Like, "And she wished that this new couple could have learned from her story" would make that connection a bit better.
On a final note, you do have a few minor grammar slips like "their" instead of "they're", so just be careful and check back for those when you edit this! Overall, you did a nice job with the story, and although I was expecting the legend to be a bit creepy, I didn't understand all of the connections and implications about Lilly until the very end. Good job with that! And as I mentioned, you don't have any description until the end, so nice work at making this understandable without even a single dialogue tag.
I hope you have a lovely day, and keep writing!
-Q
Points: 6141
Reviews: 499
Donate