Hey there, it's MysteryMe, here for a quick review!!! Thanks for the PM, btw. I'm glad to know that you value my opinion . Hopefully I can help you out with this.
For starters, let me just say that I think you did a very good job with this chapter. I remember the first chapter had a few repeated mistakes (missed punctuation, winding sentences, things like that) but you seem to have completely gotten those under control, now. I also found this new chapter to be a considerably more interesting read, which is great. Obviously, boredom is not something you want your readers to be feeling, and you did a nice job avoiding that.
In terms of characterization, I also thought you did fairly well. You didn't describe much, and you left us with a lot of questions (why does Sarah's father force her to steal in the marketplace, for example) but I did get a good idea of her personality just by her actions, and I thought you did the whole 'show, don't tell' aspect of writing very well.
The only thing I was a little bit unsure about was the bit at the end with Sarah and Abelard looking into each other's eyes. Their meeting was very sweet and cute, but it was a bit of a 'love at first sight' kind of thing, which can come off as sort of cheesy. Still, this advice comes from someone whose very picky about romance, so if you like it that way, then keep it. This is your story, after all!
Now, time for a few nitpicks:
"Seeming like a normal peasant teenager buying food for supper, this teenager was looking for something: a target."
This sentence sounds a bit awkward, to me. Try not to use 'teenager' twice in a sentence, since it gets repetitive. Consider changing it to "Seeming like a normal peasant buying food for supper, this teenager was looking for something: a target."
...
"The thief stalked this target for some time, waiting for the perfect moment to strike."
Throughout this entire piece, you used the words 'thief' and 'target' just a bit too much. It gets very repetitive, and even sort of annoying for the reader, so watch out for that. Try using more pronouns or changing it up with some other word choice.
...
" ‘You can keep the money,’ Abelard said, pointing to the purse on the ground, ‘I was just curious to see who stole from me.’ "
Okay, this part was just unbelievable for me. Not that he gave her the money (it's actually good characterization, showing that he's so rich that money barely seems to matter to him) but just the way Sarah reacted to it. All she said was 'thank you.' Don't you think she should be a bit more surprised? A bit more suspicious? A bit more grateful? She's a thief, obviously very poor, and she's probably never experienced someone being this kind to her before... especially a noble like him. You just play this whole scene by so fast, it doesn't seem real. Try to slow it down a little and add more descriptions of emotions. That would be a lot better, in my opinion.
...
Well, like I said, nice job! I wish I could be of more help, but honestly, that's all that I think needs changing. Everything else is great!
Feel free to contact me again when you update. I'm looking forward to seeing what you have in store .
Points: 654
Reviews: 101
Donate