Hello,
This is a cute story!
I really liked how you wrote it—that almost childlike, earnest, sweetly sincere way... it really felt like it was written with David's age and outlook in mind, which I appreciate. It fit the story nicely.
The flow and pacing were mostly all right, though parts of it definitely felt rushed. (Though I get, since this was for a contest with a page limit, that was sort of a necessity.) I really enjoyed the dynamic between David and Danny and their mother—they seem like an interesting, close, adorable family. I have a weakness for monster stories and creepy stories of all kinds, and I love that yours had a young boy as the protagonist. Something about a scary story with a child at its center really makes the stakes seem higher and the story more intriguing/intense. Of course, with this particular story, there wasn't a whole lot of intensity (we'll get to that in a minute), but as I said, I did like the naïve, innocent spin you opted for. It's really a shame you're not going to continue it/rewrite a longer version, because I think the bones are good and it would be quite entertaining.
In terms of what could've been improved, I do wish the story had felt a little more frightening or, at the very least, spooky. I never really flinched at any point, or felt as concerned for David and his family as I should've been, you know? And the ending's definitely flawed, but I understand about the page limit and everything. I also agree with Lupa: You tell more than show, and the story doesn't have as much imagery as it could. And I do wish it had been a bit more realistic in regards to David's reaction. (And yes, I know that demanding realism in a monster story that takes place at a haunted house is a little absurd, but I want it nevertheless.)
You also misuse commas quite a bit throughout this piece. I'll be pointing some of them out in my nitpicks, but not all of them because, frankly, there were just too many and my brain went numb after a certain point. XD You've gotta watch for that, though. Commas are notoriously easy to misuse, and it's pretty annoying for the reader.
Which brings us to... nitpicks (and other comments)!
Danny even said that it looked haunted. Danny was David's older brother; he was starting high school in August so he had to know what he was talking about.
When Danny said that the house looked haunted, Mom got mad at him. Usually, David agreed with Mom, but, for once, Danny was right.
So you kind of contradict yourself here. You start by setting up Danny as being someone who, in the eyes of David, is older and wiser and knows everything. Then you say that David usually agreed with his mother rather than Danny, and imply that Danny is rarely ever right. So which is it? Does David look up to Danny and thinks he knows everything, or think he's a goofball who's usually wrong?
Danny was scowling at Mom, he wasn't any happier about the move than David
Incorrect comma.
David turned his head to look out his window. He held his breath; outside the trees was a massive, dog-like creature. Its shaggy fur was brown and mottled and it stood like a gorilla. Glittering eyes peeked out from behind its fur, and yellow teeth gleamed with dripping saliva. David felt his stomach lurch and his heart start to beat faster. He blinked and the monster was gone. He looked back to see the creature loping into the trees. Not gone, the car had just passed it.
I know Lupa already called you on this one, but I think it's worth repeating. David's reaction to this is very weird. He should be scared! He should be screaming and pointing at the thing! Or, he should be frozen to his seat, wide-eyed, aghast. Something. And the way this is written should emphasize the fear and bizarreness—I'm talking short, choppy sentences, broken up and punctuated with David's thoughts or reaction, and written in a way that will make your reader scared. When I read this, I actually assumed that David was imagining things or playing pretend because his reaction was so off.
David shuddered if that was what was in the woods, then what could be lying in wait for them in the house?
Period after "shuddered."
He really didn't want to go anymore, if there was one monster, then surely there could be more!
Run-on.
Mom got out too, throwing her arms in the air, "We're finally here!"
You shouldn't use a comma to end a sentence right before a bit of dialogue. Really, the only time when a comma should lead into dialogue would be if the line preceding the comma is something like "I said/he said/my friend asked/my mom shouted." You make this mistake a few times.
"It seems like a bit of a fixer-upper," David knew that was sarcasm
Yet another incorrect comma.
David still ventured closer, placing a foot on the rotting wooden steps, he felt the hairs on the back of his neck rise and he didn't dare look behind him as he ran the rest of the way up the steps and to Mom.
Run-on, again. Don't be afraid to shorten your sentences.
Danny came up too, resting a hand on David's head, just that contact made David feel a little better, he wasn't alone.
Another run-on! Sadly, you do not get a prize.
So, overall, I liked this piece. I liked the way it was written, that childlike voice used to underscore David's age, and I liked the premise. Who doesn't love a good ol' haunted house/monster story? It's a classic for a reason. That being said, you have to work on your emotion, and making your characters react in a way that's realistic and believable; you have to work on your suspense and fear factor when writing a story like this; you've gotta try to 'show' more than 'tell'; and lastly, COMMAS. Don't overuse/misuse commas, and don't be afraid to shorten up those long, ugly run-on sentences.
Nice work and keep writing!
Points: 2856
Reviews: 41
Donate