I no longer come on here. Sorry. ;P
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Heeey I'm here to hunt memories but mostly to review this story~
This is my thoughts on the stories and it's all honest.
Grammar? I don't do reviews on that. I review content.
NEXT!
The writing style is something I admire in works because it defines the author. This has a good writing style, and the fantasy world is really amazing, however I may not be the targeted audience. But I have to admit, the writing style is what got me hooked.
The thing I felt was not for me was the 'telling'. I'm not sure but I prefer stories that show readers what's happening/what things are rather than telling them. Though, you can 'tell' the readers, it's just not what I prefer, I guess.
No matter how much I try to not include this in my review, I'm going to include it anyways. The writing style got me hooked and all that jazz because I was interested in this story and what is in it (I like fantasy stories. They were the first stories I liked. Ever), but the long paragraphs kept pushing me away. I know, people have already said that, but I just wanted to tell you how I feel.
Now, no matter what I say, please keep on writing. I want to see more of your writing because things like this make me admire the writing world even more. People like you inspire me to improve my own writing and my voice. I'm still having trouble finding mine, and you just gave me some boost to start working on it.
I hope you write stuff that reveals your voice more. I like it. Please. :3
Just to let you know....You are reading it as if there are multiple people telling the story.
I actually managed to read it all in one day XD YAY


is that just to save points, because that's pretty clever XD
Anyway, hey SoVirgo, I is here to review your story :3
This has so much fantasy content, and it's so complex and interesting. The little bits that told me about each creature throughout the story were pretty sweet ^-^ I got to learn new things, so yay to education!
I like the idea of the character thingymajiggy before the story starts, but I like finding out about the character throughout reading the story, as then whatever image I had in my head of the character may end up changing, which is what I really like, but here there's this thing telling me everything and I'm like "oh, okay then". It's not a bad thing, because some people might like it, it's just my personal preference is all!
Also, one thing I'd like to ask... why all the italics? XD nothing wrong with it, I'm just used to reading stuff in normal text, with italics used to emphasise something or for showing what a character is thinking.
I quite like how you've put all the chapters into one thing, instead of releasing everything in separate publications
Thorn, as a character, is super awesome ^-^ your descriptions of her are on point and I can easily imagine her in my head
Your story overall (so far) is so epic and I can't wait to find out what happens next!
Keep writing!
Huggles from BornLoser ^.^
:') You just made my day.
Aww :'D you're welcome ^-^
X'D
Hi, sorry it took me so long! Here's my review:




Your story is really imaginative and fantasy-tastic. Your writing style is really unique; I have never seen anything like it. It's really interesting that way. I really like your characters. They are really imaginative and creative. (SPOILERS!) I liked how much emotion you showed when Thorn's parents died and the realism she showed when she realized that she was five. You've created a pretty cool realm and I encourage you to write more.
I will admit that this was my favorite part:
'The day started off muggy, the clouds faded from neon blue, neon green, and golden toast-yellow.'
I find neon colours cool and I have never seen a neon blue before (I know it exists and I really want to see it). But that's not the exact reason why I like this part so much. I really like the part about toast. It is a genuine description and a very good one, too. I have never heard of it before (I love toast!) and I was very surprised when I saw it. It was really awesome. I liked it. It made me smile.
You really have made such a wonderful fantasy world here. It's so original and creative. I've probably already mentioned this though.
But what I mean to say is that I really liked this.
(Realizes that this was posted the day after I joined YWS and smiles.)
I know that this was such a short review for such a long story, but it's still a review, right?
I still really encourage you to right more.
Stay awesome!!!!!!!
~Holographic Ladybug
Woaaah. o-o This is really long XD
Did you read it all?
Working on it haha
Tell me what you think..i updated it.
Hello, there. I figured I'd leave you a review seeing as this peice has been in the green room for awhile.
(excuse any typos I may have made, as I am on mobile and the auto correct tends to strike when I'm not paying attention >~>)
Okay, my first and most important suggestion to you, is to break this story up into shorter paragraghs. And, even better yet, I would reccomend separating it into half chaptors, as opposed to huge chunks of writing. People are more likely to read your story if you provide them with shorter reads. Kind of ironic on a site for writers, huh?
Anyway, onto the review....
So I applaud you for big able to write this much. Well done, and your story has a good basis indeed!
But I do have suggestions, and they are as follows:
1. You opened the story with a description of your character. I didn't like this. You should write this into the story, as readers tend to be thrilled when they can peice together what a characer looks like. Now, that doesn't mean the description should be detailed. Trust me, a character's appearence, unless the character has an in-human appearence, need only be vague. So, I would reccomend finding a way to write that into the story as opposed to giving these details outside of the story.
2. “MOM?” I’m sorry baby girl. “MOM?!” I wish I could have loved you more. “DON’T LEAVE ME. NOT AGAIN! I’M NOT READY TO LET YOU GO!” Good bye, baby doll. “MOM!!” -- okay, I understand that you just wanted to emphasize that the character was screaming, but the all caps wasn't necessary. Neither was the double '"!". Even without all of these caps and exclamation points we can tell the character is yelling or under disress. I would reccomend changing this.
Also, different character dialogue needs to be separate from each other.
3. Toward the end of the story, you had another info bubble. As said before, you should find creative ways to write that into the story as opposed to doing it the easy way and writing an info bubble. This just completely messes with the flow of the story, in that while im reading, I don't like to have info dumped on me, especially when it's not even apart of the actual story.
Okay, bear with me there. Those are just a few suggestions that bothered me when reading your story. You have a great story-line and basis, but it would help to go through, make it smaller, edit out some of the unnecessary exclamation, etc etc. Trust me, you'll have an easier time getting reviewers if the peice is posted in shorter parts. Good luck with your story, and have a great day!
..... ;...; I said i was sorry...why must you be so mean....I....I don't know how to do what you are recommending...i'm just writing it...the editing part is for my editor. Also....not everyone will be as observant, so them liking my story may help them to read more later in there life... :'|
You like making me sad. T...T
.....if I offended you it wasn't my intention. I simply gave you advice on your story...?
But why give a book to someone who can't read? - Read between the lines
......what?
Nothing...you did what you needed to do...
What? You're not making any sense. All I did was leave you a review?? O.o
:'( I'm sorry...i'm just broken is all...
Well.. I'm sorry if I made you any more upset than already. I seriously didn't mean to upset you! If you want to talk, feel free to PM me. I truly hope you feel better soon.
We're the same age!
I'm not trying to act superior than you in any way... I just feel badly that you are upset. I simply tried to reach out, and help. I really don't know what to say, other than, the offer still stands, if you need to talk, you can PM me.
But i did pm you....
Okay, I didn't get a notification, but I saw it, and replied. Sorry.
Ok...
What do you think of it now?
Hey SoVirgoMaleke,
I figured I can write you a review.
Okay just letting you know I was only able to skim over your writing. Something that I found that was awesome was your title, like it is super creative and awesome. * silently gives you a high five*
Something to think about is tho not be switching between first person and a Narrator perspective. I understand you may have your own reasons for doing so but it gets confusing for the reader. Plus it kind of distracts the reader from the story. especially since you go LOOOOOOONNNNNGGGGGG periods at the narrator and LOOOOONNNGGG periods in the first person. And as a reader I get lost.
here:
You can definitely break this up into smaller paragraphs. Long paragraphs make it hard for the reader to concentrate. and kind of make a story boring. Smaller paragraphs change the pace at which your readers are taking in the story.
Something to thing about is to not put all of this in the beginning
All of these things are details that readers love reading. you shouldn't have to tell us all of this. The best thing to do is to use details to show us. This way the reader still has a creative process when reading the story and they are almost discovering the character as the story progresses not just being told like "THIS THIS and THIS"
Hopefully this all makes sense and I can't wait to read more from you later on. If you have any questions about what I wrote let me know and I will try to clear it up.
~ RedHoodWriter
Thoresis in her simply classic librarian glasses would allow them to droop onto the tip of her nose, her hips being held by her hands, as she glared at the writer in a red hood. She chewed on gum silently, her eyes squinting, and she couldn't help but to feel bugged.
"So...I don't know who you are, but the name's Thorn. I thank you, for reading my story. As we speak through out school days this particular story is updated, but in future time and special days it would be updated as well. You see the faults, that is good...but they won't stay there...as you can see the story isn't a huge paragraph, so that should have given you an idea of what was happening. By the way, love...You should ask questions, tell me what all you like, and tell me what gives off the most feeling. When doing so, i'd love to reply as fast as my Maker will let me. See you again eventually, and remember...don't take anything i type/say personally." ;3
~Thoresis/SoVirgo