Nooooooooo Kale and God-pretending-to-be-his-dad. Just killing my heart. I'm so so glad that, despite all the awful things that have happened to Kale thus far in his life (being trapped inside, being ignored by his mother, being hunted by demons, etc) he has this sweet moment before I'm sure everything goes to hell (lol).
This is one of those important moments to have in a story, especially after something as sad and story-changing as Kale's father dying. This quiet moment also allows us more insight into the figure of God in this world and this story. I love the relationship he has with Kale. I'm really interested to see the first major scene where we watch another character interact with God and whether it's any different than how he interacts with Kale. I'd venture to guess that, yes, it will be different. But I'm interested to see how.
The biggest question I had in this chapter was why Kale didn't realize that something was happening just downstairs? I don't live in Chinatown, but I live in an old Chicago apartment building and I can hear stuff happening both above and below me all the fricken time. If there was a fight, he'd know. Heck, if there were three extra people just walking around downstairs, he'd know. In that case, obviously, he might not be suspicious because his parents own a store and people walking around would make sense. ANYWAY basically, I wonder why Kale doesn't at least hear something strange and wonder what's going on.
I also think it would make a much more impactful moment to see Kale's mother telling him his father is dead happen on the page in scene rather than in summary. This is the first majorly devastating thing that has happened to him. One of his only friends and loved ones has just died, and we see how sad he is at the end of this chapter, but I'd really love to see him react in the moment to finding out his father is dead. It would also give us some insight into his transition back into the real world from his years of seclusion. This is the real world coming screaming straight at his face. That's a fascinating change, and I think you can get a lot out of it.
Otherwise, another great chapter! Now I'll be waiting patiently for more. Please do prod me if/when you share more of this story with YWS!
Keep writing!
--Lauren
Points: 370
Reviews: 541
Donate