Come closer, Reader. Closer. Lean in, just so. Come, take a seat on my devil's side and incline your ear to my dark tale. It is not a nice story. No, stay. I do not mean to frighten you away. Only, I must be frank with you. This is not a story for children, unless they are rebellious and must learn the punishment for that. This is not a story for the old, those who are frail and weak of heart. This story, dear Reader, is yours alone.
It started with a girl, as trouble often does. She was a small thing and when she was smaller still, her mother told her that freckles were kisses from the sun. So Emily decided that the sun must love her very much, for she had many of those. But the sun didn't love her, or at least no more than it could love the flowers or another child, for beings as great as that can not see anything so small.
Every year, at the turn of the Summer season, a fair would come to town. Emily had seen the fair often, from a distance, but never before had the chance to go. Her father was a God fearing man and thought the event too crude in its origins, while her mother was a doctor and much too busy to take her daughter to the fair. This year though, Emily was twelve. And twelve is such a very large number.
The fair was like fire, crackling under the night sky. Carousel horses danced away from their posts and a prince presented his lover with a cotton-candy cloud, charmed down from the sky. It was a magical kingdom, just waiting to be discovered and Emily was the brave explorer. She paid her fee at the gate and passed through alone, her feet crunching on discarded candy wrappers and the first leaves of autumn.
In the distance, behind a canopy of strobe lights and flailing limbs, the Big Wheel stood on top of it all and it was there that Emily's eyes led her.
“Let me guess, the big wheel.” The voice barely registered as Emily stared up at the swinging carriages and the laser beams shooting out like bicycle spokes. The Big Wheel would take her so high that she'd be old before she came down again. She'd step into the carriage and she'd step out somewhere else, at Cinderella's ball with admonitions to be home by midnight, which she would obviously fail to keep.
“Yeah, you're just the kind of girl to be drawn in by flashy lighting.” He snorted and this time the words landed and Emily turned around with a glare. In one long, contemptuous look, she knew him to be a fair worker, from the cap pulled down over his floppy, blonde hair to the bells on his grass green coat. Emily knew that fair workers were tricksters who were only after your money, and they weren't like real people at all.
“Oh yeah? And let me guess, you want me to try out your poxy, little attraction instead?” Emily was not a rude child, but she knew that if you weren't rude, the fair workers would never go away. Besides which, it did look like an awful waste of money. The cardboard wall behind him was painted in faded red and yellow stripes, looking less enticing than a mud hut with a straw roof. It was like deciding between the hopscotch or the monkey bars, as if there was any competition.
“The Hall of Mirrors can be exciting too,” the boy insisted. “But that's okay, you run along. Some people just aren't supposed to see the truth.”
“What did you say?” Emily blinked her big, brown eyes and backed off a step. The truth? Was she supposed to be afraid of the truth? Now reader, you may think this a poxy, little thing to be afraid of, but Emily was, yes. Emily was very afraid of the truth.
“You heard me. But that's okay, girls are always too afraid to enter the Hall of Mirrors. I'd even offer to go inside with you, but I know that even then, you'd be too afraid.”
“I am not!” Emily insisted and she took a step forward and then again. Emily was just as brave as any boy, especially one with floppy, blonde hair and a nose as big as a mountain. The fair boy smiled and he reached down to lift up a small card-board sign. The handwriting was poor and hard to read but Emily could just about tell that it promised to be back in ten minutes. The boy secured it in the window of his cardboard hut before stepping out.
“Very well then, miss. If you will follow me.” He bowed and then struck a gallant pose, holding his arm out for her to take. Emily hesitated, this boy was a stranger and her father had warned her against them. But. He had promised that he would be back in ten minutes and that was hardly enough time to look around the attraction and certainly not long enough for anything else to happen.
“So... we're being nice now?” Emily hesitated before accepting the arm.
“If you like,” the fair boy said. He twitched the curtain aside and led her into a hallway lined with mirrors and lit by glowing panels on the ceiling. Emily glanced at the mirrors suspiciously but after four or five, all of which did something different to her shape or size, she let out a nervous giggle and started to enjoy herself.
“This one makes your nose look even bigger!” Emily exclaimed, looking to her left.
“Oh gee, thanks,” the boy drawled, his eyes fixed straight ahead.
“You're not looking!” Emily realised with a gasp. “Are you scared, is it because you're afraid?” She covered her mouth as a giggle tried to escape and then pulled hard on his arm, trying to turn him around. The boy didn't resist and came face to face with the mirror, his disdainful expression matched by the other boy's.
“We didn't come for these mirrors,” the fair boy explained. “We came for the one that tells the truth.”
Emily fell silent and allowed him to lead her through a maze of mirrors and doors. The further in they walked, the darker it got as some of the lights started to flicker and others failed entirely. Emily pressed herself closer against the boy and tried not to look in the mirrors which held shadowy figures and grasping hands. After one turn, they came upon a mirror so suddenly that Emily walked into it and felt the glass hard and cold against her cheek. Her eye stared into the depths of the eye reflected back and she thought she saw a face there. A face with freckles and eyes as dark and wicked as coal. But when the boy steadied her, she realised it was only herself.
Emily thought hard about what the boy had said. He was leading her to a mirror that told the truth. But it wouldn't be scary, no. Emily had convinced herself that it would be a normal mirror. A mirror that showed her, as she was. Just her. Nothing scary about that. And, she felt smug because the boy had forgotten to ask her for any money so it didn't even matter that this was lame and not scary at all.
“Through here,” the boy said, pushing hard against one of the mirrors until it swung inward on hidden hinges. Beyond, the room was dark and a cloud of dust swirled out causing Emily to cough.
“In there?” she asked apprehensively.
“Come on.” The boy climbed through and reached back to take her hand, pulling her in after him. Surprised, Emily stumbled down a step, sliding against the door and falling into her companion who laughed and pulled her further in.
“I... I bet it's just a plain, old mirror,” Emily said bravely.
“No, it's not. I wouldn't bring you all this way for that. Wait, stand here.” The boy dropped her arm and moved away, stepping behind a great big dust sheet. “This mirror was so scary and so terrifying, that it had to be removed from the attraction,” the boy explained, lifting the bottom corner. “Anyone who looked in it was never the same again because they had seen... the truth.” He whipped the sheet away dramatically and Emily was almost afraid to look. But she had come so far. And it was there, right in front of her. But what was there?
It looked at first like any mirror. The frame was gold and engraved with leaves and the glass fit snugly inside, dusty but clear enough to make out her reflection. Pale skin, dark hair pushed back by a red headband. Skinny legs and spindly arms sticking out from the lace trimmings of her best, red dress. Every detail was exactly correct, right down to the fading bruise on her left forearm. There it was, reflected on the mirror girl's left arm.
“I don't see-” Then the arm reached out and Emily realised what was wrong. Ordinary mirrors didn't show the truth. They showed everything as it was, but the wrong way around. But not this mirror. This mirror was not showing herself, but another girl, a girl who looked just like her, standing across from her, as if she had a twin. And the girl reached out and pulled Emily in.
“Come,” the fair boy said, holding his arm out to the girl in the mirror. “Come and let me show you what this world is like.” And out she stepped in her red, buckle shoes. She looked up at the fair boy and smiled wickedly.
And that night, Emily stepped on to the Big Wheel, but the girl who stepped off wasn't Emily at all and she certainly didn't make it home before midnight.
________________________________________
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
So I'm not your Secret Santa and this isn't the first of my two reviews as your Secret Santa because like I said, I'm not your Secret Santa. But if I was (metaphorically of course), I would apologise for reviewing something from 2011 and blame it on the fact that you haven't posted much recently besides poetry, and a goldfish with one eye and a disfigured tail could write a better poetry review than me.
So yes, anyways.
I thought this was really cool and the originality of the whole thing is awesome. I love dark stories like this because they can be pretty spooky, and hey, I like being spooked. One thing I thought you did really well in this is description. Now I am absolutely appalling at writing any kind of description--heck, even using adjectives is a struggle. Partly as a result of my lack of skills, your descriptive skills have really impressed me. I especially love your original description of the fair where you describe the fair as being like fire, and methinks that paragraph is great. Just an overall really neat, interesting piece, y'know?
With regards to critiques, I'll start with a nit-pick. I can't help wondering how Emily was in the fair in the first place. You previously stated how her father would never allow her to go, and so I can't help wondering how she was allowed to go (especially go alone) if her father is so against it. Okay, I guess she could have sneaked out, but then surely her parents would have noticed her missing. Plus their first guess would probably be that she's ran away to the fair. Maybe I'm overthinking this, which I probably am, but it's something to consider.
Something else imma discuss wit you is more of a suggestion than a critique really, and that suggestion is that I think you should go all out when it comes to formatting and sentence structure 'nd stuff in this story. One of the main things I think this story would benefit from is the use of short sentences. While you do use some, you don't really use that many at the moment. I'm not saying you should go wild and make every sentence, like, two words long because that would just be awkward, but you should really take advantage of them. This kind of story is perfect for short sentences because there's a lot of suspense and tension, and short sentences are great at portraying that.
I also think you could play around a bit more with the formatting of the first paragraph in this. I like how it starts with a sort of storytelling voice thingamabob because you immediately direct the story to the reader, and I think that could be even more effective if you mess around with the format a bit more. Maybe put some sentences as their own paragraph/in their own line. That kind of thing.
Something like that but better because that's a pretty bad example, but still, d'you see what I'm sort of getting at? The first paragraph is almost a conversation really, and I can't help feeling that a sort of conversationesque format would go down well. This is obviously just a suggestion and not a necessity or anything, so it's up to you what you do with it. Just have a think about it and what not, I guess.
Now as for a more juicy critique, the main thing that bothered me about this story is how easily fooled Emily was, and how willing she was to go into that hall of mirrors place. The first thing you mention when Emily is spoken to by the fair worker is how she knows they shouldn't' be trusted e.t.c. yet she trusts him pretty easily. I get that she agrees to go with him because of her pride and what not, but that still seems off to me. She is only twelve so she would be naive, but I know that I wouldn't have been so willing to follow a stranger into some place alone when I was twelve. Especially if that someone is older than me. Plus she doesn't seem stupid. Naive, yes, but not stupid... and doing what she did is pretty stupid.
The only other issue I have with this, so to speak, is regarding the beginning of this. You spend a paragraph or so at the beginning describing Emily's freckles and how she connects them to the sun, but the sun doesn't actually give a poo. Maybe I was just overthinking this, but I got the impression that was important and would become very relevant in the future of the story. Now admittedly, this may be down to the fact that I have an attention spam of a mangled goldfish (I like goldfish, in case you haven't figured that out yet), but it turns out the whole freckles and sun thing isn't relevant with regards to the overall story. Like I said, maybe I'm just missing something, but I just thought I'd mention my views on this because it's something that stood out to me.
Righteo, anyways, I think that's me done. I think this was a really cool piece overall, and with some tweaking and editing here and there, it could become something pretty epic. Sorry again for reviewing something from, like, three years ago. I was going to try and tackle some of your more recent poetry, but I failed so miserably I wanted to run head first into a tree, knock myself out, and then repeat the process all over again. But yes, I shall now move on to the second piece of yours (this one will probably be from 1995 at the rate I'm going) in a way that is totally unrelated to me being your Secret Santa because I'm not. I'm totally not.
Keep writing,
xoxo Skins
Hey Kitty15,
I'm really sorry for my lateness, but I'll try to make up for it by this review.
Wow, that was both spooky and creative. I mean, I didn't guess that that would happen at the end. But I didn't feel connected the character somehow. I mean, that the story haven't gone long enough for me to really connect to them and feel what they feel. Although you are going for a third person narrative, it still should be able to make us feel scary and tense. And I believe that's what this story is missing.
Mistakes
I think using the word "poxy" so nearby to each other is going to sound overused, and since this is sort of a distinct and rarely used word. It would be better to use either "stupid" or "dumb" for the second sentence.
Plot
The way you developed the plot is good as it slowly carried itself without much effort till the end. And the twist at the end was good as I did not see it coming. But I feel like it went from relatively calm parts and into the plot too fast. The transition wasn't that smooth although the plot itself went with a flow. I'd say go through this again, and see if you can even the fast flow from the 1st part to the 2nd.
Descriptions
Descriptions were perfectly done. Not too much, not too little and I liked the way you used the environment itself to describe the setting. Also, I loved the way you explained specific characteristics of the two characters, specially this,
It describes about her appearance and her naive personality. So there's nothing I can point out to improve in this section.
Title
I loved the title, but it does sort of give away some of the plot, but I guess the title suits the story, in both it's mysteriousness and it's connection to the plot. So, good job in that.
Overall, I think it's a good story, spooky and written well. But pay attention some of the facts I mentioned above.
Good luck
- C -
As with the people above, it was truly excellent. The start of it totally drew me in like nothing else I have ever read. I genuinely could not find a single thing I would change about it, except maybe that Emily's first section of dialogue seems out of character for what I expected of her. It's not just the rudeness (I thought she'd be politely disdainful to be honest. That's the sort of person she came across as), it's the modernness of her speech as well. You wrote the story in an "ye olde tyme inn" sort of tone, and her speech didn't seem to fit in with that.
That's honestly all I can say. I hope I've been helpful in some way, and good luck with the contest! Keep it up!
A review is coming.
That ending is magnificent. It stunned me and creeped me out yet I was thrilled at the same time by the pure genius of your story on top of so many other dark, spooky emotions I can't even identify.
Wonderful work!
In the beginning when Emily had only seen the fair from a distance until she was twelve actually reminded me of the movie Tangled, in the way Rapunzel dreamt of leaving the tower but wasn't allowed outside. At that point I thought the story was going in the direction of being a spin-off of that concept, but, jeez was I wrong!
There're heaps of vague twists and turns, bumps, climaxes, drops, and whirls, just about every emotion a rollercoaster throws at you. And I LOVE rollercoaster’s.
~Ceely
I thought it was brilliant. I love your language and your choice of words. It adds wonderfully to the story.