Hey Radrook! It's been a while since I've reviewed poetry/reviewed in general, so just a heads up that if I seem a little rusty, I probably am.
She’d seemed divine dressed in her wedding gown.
"She'd" seems out of place here, and that's important because this line keeps repeating. I think you intend it to be short for "She had seemed", which also sounds a little odd. I think that you can just leave it as "she seemed divine...", because you use the same past tense for the rest of the poem. Does that make sense? "She seemed" would line up with "I dreamed" and "I felt", so I think in this way, too, it reads better than "she'd".
Dissolved were all the reasons for my frowns.
No longer was aloneness destiny.
She’d seemed divine dressed in her wedding gown.
This is a stanza in particular that I thought could use some negotiating. One of the trickiest things about rhyme is getting the ends to line up properly while having the line itself read naturally -- plus, you're thinking about meter as well! Still, I think that some tinkering would be good here. While both lines are technically okay, some rearranging could really improve the stanza. For example, the second line could be, "For she destroyed my lonely destiny" -- maybe that's not quite what you want to say, but something like that reads a little more straight-forward.
I felt the envy of entire towns
as they proclaimed I’d done so splendidly.
I feel as if these two lines don't quite go together. They both do a good job of showing how wonderful this girl is perceived to be, but I think envious towns wouldn't be "proclaiming" how he'd done so well. I'm not sure how I'd change it, but I thought I would mention it just in case you had an idea on it and wanted to change it.
But suddenly she called me fool and clown..
Accursed be the day she married me!
I think that the main thing here is that the first line rings a little hollow. I think that's mostly because "fool" and "clown" are sort of old-fashioned and not very strong. While of course they could be very hurtful, especially in this case, they sound a little bit silly among the majestic imagery, where they could have sounded stronger. I'm not sure that clown is the way to go -- maybe something with down, along the lines of "she threw her flowers down". Of course that's not the right meter or anything, but you get the idea. The imagery in that action sends a very strong message where calling the narrator clown is a little lesser. It's your choice if you want to go this way, but I just wanted to say that it's something I was thinking about.
Overall, this is a neat poem. I think that maybe you could use a comma or two throughout, and maybe work a little more on individual phrases, you did a good job. I really admire the villanelle style, and I'm glad you were able to pull it off so well! It takes a lot of planning.
Good luck with future writing!
-Q
Points: 6141
Reviews: 499
Donate