Published January 23, 2020
...
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hello again!
I've read a couple of your stories so far and I really like the humour in them, and I guess I should actually write a review! So here it is!
I like the idea of angels, and the general plot of the story a lot! I'm just a bit confused about why Piphael didn't notice that Professor Perill was an evil scientist, but then again, he doesn't seem like the brightest angel in the sky.
I like how he treats this whole incident as more of an embarrassing mistake like forgetting to turn off the oven when you leave the house than a complete disaster. I guess when you're an immortal angel things seem like less of a big deal. (Are angels immortal? Really old anyways.)
Sorry I don't have a better review for you, but it's a great story!
-Gnomish
Hi HG!
First impression: I love the concept. I like how you maintain a divine being's point of view. Millions of people probably died and who knows what else Professor Perill did to the others. But seeing it through Piphael's POV, it doesn't feel like that big of a deal. We focus on the humor instead. It's not dark, it's just well executed irony — it led to some tension too.
I love this line. It's an interesting interpretation in the context of the story. It also paints the gods and angels of this universe as more complex beings — they have the capacity to feel vengeance and it's ironic (and funny) that they'd bring up the old book to justify that.
You missed an apostrophe.
The they here is a little too vague. I can guess you're talking about the other gods/angels. You go on to talk about how the humans also did "the exact same thing." So when in the next paragraph you write "But that hadn’t stopped them from ... the years he’d missed," the reader is forced to stop for a second and think. Some clarification would help this part flow better, I'd say.
It's nevertheless a good line. We've seen this theme before and it's always interesting how divine characters are often depicted to be hypocritical. It'd be a fair interpretation to say they represent real life officials to some extent.
"Stopped."
I think you meant to type "that had been disturbed." But it's still hard to visualize what's happening here (that may still just be me).
Another point. You began the story with "Piphael descended into the dark.." I wondered what he was descending from. But you later write that hadn’t stopped them from throwing him down here. Here is the keyword. Where is here? You were of course referring to the.. let's say, the chamber or labyrinth where Piphael had been banished. Here implies Piphael (the character whose POV we are following) is still in that place of banishment. That's paradoxical if Piphael has already descended from that place (as the first line implies). But I could have read that wrong — it's possible that the basement is a part of the chamber of banishment.
(If Piphael had indeed descended from the place of banishment by the start of the story) one suggestion for an easy fix may be to substitute the "here" (in "throwing him down here") with "there." If Piphael hadn't, then you could consider cutting the first sentence and pasting it — you could add some exposition to it for the sake of coherence — just before the paragraph where you describe the gloomy basement.
The semi-colon may be unnecessary.
It's also paradoxical but I wonder if it was intentional. We are after all seeing it through Piphael's POV. In my opinion, this little bit establishes Piphael as a rather ignorant and sloppy god/angel, which makes sense as we read on.
Agent is a title that is followed by a name and so should be capitalized.
I wonder why you chose to italicize this part.
The sentence doesn't sound right to me. I think the sentence is missing a preposition and most likely before the phrase "any two individuals who had to kill one another."
I have a suggestion. They were both firing at each other and tossing the occasional piece of furniture with the most amount of passion that Piphael had ever seen in any two individuals had to kill one another.
Something's missing here.
Missing an apostrophe. Cool name for a villain, by the way. I like this line too. Very special-agent-esque. Although I probably would've liked the dialogue to have started in a new paragraph.
Disbelief, indeed. Made me feel the same thing. What are you doing, Piphael!
Did he go on hiatus (again) for two years? Come on, Piphael!
Oh bother cracked me up. I would have objected that there's no way the gods hadn't noticed Piphael's major blooper or that two years of global chaos would've been enough to make the gods wonder that somebody did something. But good job on having established early on that the ones Up There are exactly like Piphael if not worse. At the same time, I wonder how praying works in this system. Doesn't praying (could also meaning "hoping") that nobody Up There notices his mistake only notify them that he made a mistake? Honestly, they'd probably just swipe past the notification. I don't know if that's an intended subtext but that'd be hilarious.
That's the review! Keep on writing and best of luck for review day (hope you have joined a team!).
Excelsior!
~MAS
Hii @H.G ! I just read your story and I must say I enjoyed every bit of it .I may not be the best in reviewing but I will tell you how I felt .

It was really interesting and engaging. The title 'A Truly Divine Mistake' - I loved it and it was later truly justified.
I liked how you began by explaining why Piphael (the angel) descended from the heaven and argued that it was not just his 'mistake' for showing negligence to his duties .
The ambiance of the place where he entered was described nicely .The fight scene was well-written and I loved how Piphael's character was shown so gullible that he could not judge the actual thing happening in front of him. He was so easily persuaded that the poor old professor was the victim here . The best funny part came at the end when you revealed the outcome of the angel's little mistake . You did not went on to directly explain the details, that's good because it will let the reader realise it on their own and then have a good laugh at this funny incident that meant to bring some good on earth , but actually resulted into global annihilation.
I loved the entire plot and didn't find anything to criticize. it kept me entertained. You have really got a lot a potential . Hope to get more like this from you! All the best.