...

...

Comments & reviews · 9
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

User avatar
Ashlee
Review
Ashlee wrote a review · Mon Jun 23, 2008 6:22 pm

"Gramps says, 'One: are you German?' Prisoner can't do much but say yes. 'Two,' Gramps continues, and the prisoner sighs in relief, 'if I gave you this gun, would you kill me?' Naturally the German lies through his teeth and says no. 'Three: why shouldn't I kill you?'


That part is really funny.

I like your story. I think it's very good. I look forward to reading more of your writing. Good luck and keep up the good work!! :D


~Ashlee~ :D

User avatar
Prokaryote
Comment

Thanks a lot XxxDo!

I apologize about some of the spelling errors; this was a slightly older version of the story and I forgot to replace it with the fixed revision. That stuff is corrected now.

One thing that confused me is whether the whole story is meant to be a letter sent to the law enforcement, or not... Also, at one point you say "I". But it is in 3rd person, so you shouldn't use I anywhere other than dialogue.


It is part of a letter, yes. Your complaint about the shift to first person (it's supposed to illustrate that the one writing the letter actually is Weaver) is a common one I've received, so I will try to change that.

Thanks again; I appreciate it! :D

Prokaryote

User avatar
deleted2
Review

Heya,

As promised, here's the review :D

I really liked the story, especially because of the description and the way in which weaver suddenly becomes a crocodile monster thing. The way you're in Weaver's head is also really good. The letter is brilliant too.

One thing that confused me is whether the whole story is meant to be a letter sent to the law enforcement, or not... Also, at one point you say "I". But it is in 3rd person, so you shouldn't use I anywhere other than dialogue.


Anyway, it was awesome.

Happy editing.
XxxDo

User avatar
Prokaryote
Comment

Thank you all very much for the reviews.

In retrospect, perhaps I should've broken this up into two parts -- reviewers not having time to read it all is a red flag. ^^;

TNCowgirl wrote:Just dont' use so many big words unless the people you want to read this are the people that would know what they mean.


Erm -- okay? XD

Azila wrote:Is it all a letter to the police?


Yesh -- the non-italicized story is the body of the letter. I apologize if it was a little unclear.

Thanks again!

Prokaryote

User avatar
KJ
Comment

I really liked this. What I liked most was your hook. I didn't have time to read it all - maybe you should shorten it? Just a thought.

Don't have time to say anymore, but good job on what I did read.

User avatar
TNCowgirl
Review

I feel really really bad. Because I promised this crit a while back. So here it goes.

It was pretty good. Just my mind doesn't like big words and there were a lot in the first part. Other then that it seemed pretty good. Just dont' use so many big words unless the people you want to read this are the people that would know what they mean. Other then that good job!!!!!

User avatar
Azila
Review
Azila wrote a review · Sun Mar 23, 2008 7:36 pm

Hi, Prok! Here's my review, I hope it lives up to what you wanted!

If Timothy Weaver ever told the truth, it was a half-truth, and Tim Weaver didn't tell the truth often.
I don't really like the fact that you said "Timothy" and "Tim" in the same sentence, referring to the same guy... especially because you continue to call him "Weaver" for the rest of the piece... it gets kind of confusing. I suggest you change the bold part of the sentence above to "he."

"He's got a demon in'im."
Shouldn't here be a space after "in"?

But the greatest reward was the intense feeling of control he experienced: stringing along credulous commoners and toying with them like marionettes; simultaneously manipulating their minds and belittling their intelligence with every confident word that left his lips.
This is a really long sentence, and I particularly don't like the fact that you use both a colon and a semi-colon in it.

The tavern served a varied group of customers: farmers, fishermen, and fur-traders, with no shortage of degenerates and criminals.
I suggest you rephrase this to "The tavern served a varied group of customers: farmers, fishermen, fur-traders, and no shortage of degenerates and criminals."

Built a few years earlier to take advantage of the booming traffic, Clemen's Tavern was once a beautiful building, outside and in; but this last crowded year had taken its toll: the path leading up to the door was a muddy slush pool; the interior walls were caked with grime; the smell of cigarette smoke clung to everything inside the pub.
Two things: 1) I think you should have mentioned the name of the tavern earlier. 2) Do you realize that there are three semi-colons and a colon in that sentence?! XD That's a bit much, methinks.

Weaver opened the heavy oak door with a grunt and stepped in the tavern, splashing mud into the already-soaked entranceway.
Shouldn't that be "into" or "inside"?

A few there that night, though not as many as a weekend would bring.
This should be "There were a few [people] there that night, though not as many as a weekend would bring."

Two out of three wasn't bad.
What--? This part confused me. :?

"Anyway, he told one particular story more than any other."

"One night after a fierce round of fighting, a few captured enemy prisoners were brought back. My grandfather managed to get himself alone with one of them. I'm not sure whether Gramps could speak German or if he had a translator, but this is what he says happened.
The quotes after "other" shouldn't be there.

Weaver picked up a grubby knife and fork and began eating. When he was finished he retrieved a toothpick from his jacket and placed it in his mouth.
That was really fast! Either you should go into more detail about him eating the stake, or you should have him eating it while they're talking about his grand-dad, because as it is I was thinking "ok, he just got a big steak... wait a moment; where'd it go?!" ^^

I bit off his head.
I think this should be in italics.
-----------------

I was confused by this, to tell the truth. Is it all a letter to the police? If so, why are only parts of it in italic? I think if it is a letter, you should make more references to "you guys" in the narrative... if you know what I mean. If you don't (or even if you do) here's an example: rather than saying "Weaver frequented a small tavern. It was situated on a heavily-traveled road that connected two trading towns." You could say something like "Weaver frequented a small tavern. I'm sure you know the one; it was situated on a heavily-traveled road that connected two trading towns." I think that would be a good effect.

Another thing I noticed is that you use a lot of colons -- semi and normal. It's really no necessary, and it actually kind of got on my nerves... especially when you used more than one in a sentence. I pointed some of them out in my nitpicks, but I suggest you comb through the whole piece and get rid of all the unneeded ones. Feel free to PM me and I'll help you find 'em.

Other than that, this piece was very interesting. You have a really intriguing style that kept me reading even though it isn't the kind of thing I usually like reading. I absolutely love the beginning; there's nothing like starting with a good analysis of an eccentric character. :P I assume this is the beginning of a mystery-type novel(la)? Well if it is, (or even if it isn't) PM me when you post more! it'd be interesting to see how this turns out. ^_^

Hope this helps. Please feel free to PM me!

Good luck!
~Azila~

User avatar
mizz-iceberg
Review

Like Loose said, Wow. I loved it. I was sorta surprised towards the ending but I liked it. I rather enjoyed the story Weaver's grandfather told about the war.

Characters, Plot, Description...spectacular. I was really drawn into the story and started seeing
and living it. I mean as it ened, i slowly came back to my surroundings, my room, my house, life.

Good job!

User avatar
Loose
Review
Loose wrote a review · Sun Mar 23, 2008 6:00 am

Wow. Prok, this was sensational. It was like a fairy tale for adults for most of the beginning.

"Depends which town you mean." His voice sounded rough and unused. "Ashur, yeah."


I loved that! "Rough and Unused". It's not a term you usually hear when discussing ones voice, but I completely understood where you were coming from. Brilliant.

Ruthless sonofabitch.


I think "sonofabitch" would be better with some hyphens. "Son-of-a-bitch". It still presents the fast past on which he says it, but it makes it seem more like... English.

All in all, this story was great. It arouses such spectacular imagery in the readers mind, and I love it! Well done.



The inner machinations of my mind are an enigma.
— Patrick Star