Hello, MemoryHunter here to review your short story~
First of all, forgive me if I suck at reviewing because fictional short stories are not my forte at all, but I'm still going to review this because it is interesting.
Personally, I found the beginning to be a little bit plain. Don't get me wrong; it's fine, but could use more of an impact. I mean, the beginning of short stories is where it all happens. Where people get hooked to your story. I believe you can improve the descriptions or perspective in the first part ^-^.
Okay, so your plot was very intense. I loved it. It's so mind-boggling and heart-trembling and has a suspense-ish feeling to it. I couldn't help reading as fast as I could to see what happened to the other guy et cetera. There were so many things with this that made my emotions just let loose.
However, the other guy was the problem. To begin, I know that perhaps the reason for his disappearance is pretty obvious, but I still couldn't get it. As IceWinifredd implied, he could have died, etc. but maybe there is something else to the story? The suspense is killing me, and it may be great for most because the feeling of a short story undone is somewhat artistic, but personally I don't like it. I want to know more about these guys. What was the cause for his disappearance?
To fix this, you can add more hints as to what happened, but don't go full throttle and explain the whole thing if you want to retain your style. But I'm not telling you to do so, because maybe other people like this work as the way it is.
Next, the characters.
The characters were awesome. I don't know why but I always have trouble connecting with my fictional characters. I think it's because I know they're not real. But you, sir, have made them pretty authentic. They seem to be real people drinking and contemplating about what to do. Kudos to that!
Okay, so that is all I have to review. I also read that you are conscious of your English. As a fellow English Is Not My First Language guy, I can relate. Especially when most of my readers are in fact, well versed in English. However, I like to believe that English is for everybody, and that if you make a mistake, you shouldn't feel that bad. I believe that languages were built for us to understand, not for us to correct. Whatever. You get the point. xD (Grammar Nazis please don't bash me.)
Another tip for you: never give up! I have been a crappy writer since day one and my dad was a well-known poet slash editorial writer back in his days. I always felt inferior to him and my works were as terrible as a potato. Maybe that is because of the fact that I started when I was in 1st grade BUT THAT'S NOT THE POINT. xD What I mean is that don't let those failed attempts discourage you. Trust me, it's all worth it.
Last tip. Seriously.
If you have time, check out this website. http://ellenbrockediting.com/novel-boot-camp/
It's for novel writers but some articles can be applied to others too. It has been helpful for me and I wish it will be for you ^-^
Points: 104
Reviews: 77
Donate