Hey Mailice!
RandomTalks here with a short review!
I actually did not expect the reunion between the father and daughter to take place so soon. Usually, you introduce the idea of encounters like these between the main characters and then use the next couple of parts to build up the anticipation until your readers can't take the suspense any more. However, I found this break of pattern to be quite welcome as it hits on the emotions that are still raw, thereby creating more effect.
Secluded in an isolated world, Claire lived her pipe dream.
I really loved the way you translated Claire's building emotions in this part. Usually, she buries herself so deep inside the imaginations of her head, that it becomes a little difficult to decipher what she is thinking or feeling. However, her emotions were clearer in this part, and the reader could feel the jumble of nerves and fear that she herself experienced. I liked how you set the mood for the part in the very beginning, giving us a precise idea of what is going to follow. The entire first half of the part seemed to be situated inside Claire's head, and we were able to navigate her thoughts and feelings regarding the approaching reunion with her father. It was a good supporting piece and I really liked the way it complemented the other half of the part where more of the action and dialogue was based.
There was no aunt.
There was no Emma.
There was no Léonard.
Lonely and abandoned, she had to go to her father.
I thought it was interesting that in her moment of helplessness, when she truly did not know what to do, Claire's thoughts turned instinctively to Leonard and Emma, as though she half expected some miraculous interference from them to bail her out of this encounter with her father. It is strange because Leonard and Emma are not exactly the first people one would depend on in situations like these. For one, they have never been there when she really needed them, and Leonard has a long history of carrying out his plans and then discarding the pair of them when he has finished using them. It seems almost illogical that her thoughts would turn to them in this moment, especially when she is so dedicated to icing out Daphne who was right beside her the whole time and was very much concerned about her well being. The only conclusion I can reach here is that it was wishful thinking on Claire's part. She knew that nothing could really stop what was about to happen, and so she focused her energy on miraculous suppositions that could never come true but at the same time provided her a little relief by giving her the chance to wonder about it.
They were all tiny ants amidst the imperial stones.
I loved the descriptions you provided here. They felt kind of separated from the main text in this part and cleared a little space for the readers so that they were still able to breathe amidst the conflict of feelings inside Claire. It provided a break in the narration and painted this beautiful, distracting visual that for a moment took our attention to somewhere else. I could imagine Claire's awe at it as well, and I could almost imagine the moment of buffer it created as she was swept away by the elegance around her.
This part along with her conversation with Ernst about trains did not have any immediate connection to the plot of the story, but I appreciated the change it brought to the tone and pace. It was almost a small moment of respite before we were swept again by the turmoil of emotions Claire was experiencing.
Hesitantly, he raised his arms and put them around his daughter.
I really liked the start to this reunion. Benedikt enclosing his daughter in a hug, hesitantly and unsurely, as if it was more of an instinct rather than a physical act was a really sweet moment and for a second, I could almost imagine that things could be this easy between the father and daughter. It had, after all, been a long time since they had seen each other the last time. I liked the way you portrayed the different reactions in this short scene - Benedikt's shock and surprise at seeing his daughter, Claire's discomfort and the silent bitterness she held against her father and Ernst's awkwardness at being an intruder in this private moment between a family. Claire's second-guesses about how to act in that situation increased the tension and somehow her doubts and concerns felt very realistic in that moment.
Her father was not really angry. He looked overwhelmed. That's where the anger came from. Perhaps she was not concentrating on his daughter but on himself.
Somehow, the reunion got out of hand more quickly than I could ever have anticipated. I knew things were not going to go very smoothly, but the transition in Benedikt's behavior towards his daughter changed rather abruptly. It was like a switch going off, instantaneous and without any warning. It did feel like in that moment, he was harsh towards her simply because he did not want to give her the chance to speak. He was hasty in telling her to get out of his sight, giving her the key to his place almost like he wanted to get rid of her in that moment. It later occurred to me during my second re-read, that maybe that had been the point all along. Benedikt and Claire both do not like expressing their emotions and most of the time, they do not know how to express them either. In that moment in his office, Benedikt was very much overwhelmed by the surprise of seeing his daughter again. He did not know how to react and thus he harshly and almost hastily, removed Claire from the situation so that he could actually process his emotions without her standing witness to it.
However, what surprised me most was Claire's own conclusion that her father must have been overwhelmed and had been focusing more on himself in that moment rather than on her. This was a surprising change, mostly because until now, Claire has always grabbed at any opportunity to present her father as the anti-climatic villain of her story. The understanding with which she now considered him was a surprising change, but I also got the feeling that it was what she wanted to believe for herself rather than what she actually believed.
That's all!
Keep writing and have a great day!
Until next time!
Points: 58164
Reviews: 527
Donate