You Are

by MJs_Magic_Pen

Published April 6, 2007

Why do I love you?
Because you are young?
Because you are a man?
Because you’re a 6 months older?
Or simply, because you are: you!

Why do I love you?
I keep on thinking,
Trying to figure out,
Why it is you of all.
Are you the one I want?

Why do I love you?
My friends ask too.
You are such a rebel,
Wearing makeup and all,
But they forget, I am too.

Comments & reviews · 3
User avatar
niteowl
Review
niteowl wrote a review Review · Apr 8, 2007

In addition to what they said above, you put way too many questions in this poem. In fact, the whole poem is a long, unanswered question about why you love this person. Instead of just saying "because you are: you!" show us why "you" is so important to the narrator. What does "you" do/say that's so great? How can you show that special quality in a poem that's interesting and will actually capture a reader's attention?

Best of luck in future writing! :mrgreen:

Electric Tangerine wrote a review Review · Apr 7, 2007

Hmm...it's a bit repetitive like Siegfried said. The idea of having "young" and then "older" two lines down sort of confused me. I'd look into changing that. Basically I agree with Siegfried. Grab a thesaurus to help you with word choice repetition.
also something about the colon in this like

Or simply, because you are: you!
cuts the flow for me.

-tangerine

Random avatar
deleted6
Review
deleted6 wrote a review Review · Apr 7, 2007

Again I say like with one before you concentrate on repetition too much. These poems if less repeative be good, just try a poem like less repetition and maybe more variety of wording.Good Luck and please try listen to advice.

Vernon



mashed potatoes are v a l i d
— Liminality