Hi there!
I absolutely love your writing. Just wanted to say that ^_^
This may just be my writing style, but I feel like the "she dreamed this" should be made into separate paragraphs or it's own paragraph. I know that it would be a bit of a stretch with your flow, but hear me out. It's very repetitive. Instead of saying "she dreamed of this this and this" you take the time to point out each dream individually. With them in the same paragraph like this it seems like you want them all connected. When in the sense that she dreamed them all in one night, they aren't exactly the same. It seems that she went through different dreams, one that led to the other, and these dreams each had a different feel to them. I think it would be more dramatic if you separated them.
I like the short chapter. Sometimes writers get too stagnant and forget that writing is free and doesn't really have rules. A chapter doesn't have to be over a thousand words or a certain number of pages. Its length depends on the content. This chapter makes sense short because all you're telling us is that Ana was sleeping. We do get a bit about her dreams, but there isn't much time put into exploring them. It's just a reminder that she's there and conscious enough to have dreams. I like it
The pony - who she plainly called Jane - snorted.
There's no need for he dashes here. The name of the horse directly correlates with the information that the pony snorted. It's like when you write "Her dad Bill." You wouldn't say "Her dad - his name was Bill - blah blah." If it's a name it can be shared directly.
“Unusual,” Esther murmured, and stroked the side of Jane’s head.
The forest where Esther lived was an unusual one in many ways,
Just a nitpick here. You use the word 'unusual' twice here in that many sentences. Find another word to replace one of them.
It had been her impression that the forest had been as long as the rest of the things that the world she knew had been built upon had been.
Another nitpick for you. Past tense is always tricky because of the past tense of the past tense; ie when the word 'had' comes into play. I've noticed that I overuse it in places that it isn't needed and I see it a lot in other people's writing too. This is one place where it isn't needed. Saying that it had been her impression means that she doesn't believe it anymore. From reading this my impression is that she still believes it. So there's no need for the 'had' at the beginning of the sentence. You can simply say "It was her impression..."
I like the description of the veil. You don't just give us the basic "there's the veil"; you give us the feeling that the veil creates and show us how the veil affects Esther. That makes it almost more real and gives us a great image.
I do wish there was some visual aspect of the veil as well. Anything that exists no matter how it is has some sort of tell to it. Nothing is invisible. I mean, I guess something could be, but it's a bit of a stretch. Even if the veil isn't able to be seen, surely it affects the things around it. Maybe there's a tree that is half in the veil and half out so when looking upon it you only see half of it. Obviously that's something you would come up with, but I'm just throwing out an example. Otherwise it's hard for us to grasp that this veil really is there. The static is fine and dandy, but I want more.
Jane searched Esther’s palm for a bit of apple or sugar.
You can't really say for sure what Jane is looking for, unless you want to make the horses's actions and thoughts known to us. Esther can assume that the horse is looking for this, but she can't be certain of it. This sentence almost comes from the POV of the horse. I didn't get the feel that the horse is going to be a personified (for lack of a better term) character.
This is a good chapter. Esther is a very interesting character and I like that we're spending a lot of time with her. You could've skipped straight through to the action and have Ana wake up and ask a bunch of questions, but you're taking your time. We're getting a look around this magical forest and seeing what it's all about. I am left wondering about what other creatures or other people might be in this forest. Maybe it's not time to dive into that yet, but it would be nice to know.
I can't wait to read more!
Keep writing!
**Noelle**
Points: 3733
Reviews: 1417
Donate