I am smiling at you ...

by Iamnotperfect

Published August 18, 2010

Hi, this is my very first poem and I just wrote it on the go but it might be a bit rusty, however it does express my opinion.

Thanks everyone for your constructive comments. I have to admit that this poem "in particular" is better with punctuation however I always remain of the idea that punctuation is not a MUST in poetry. Thanks again :smt002
.................................................................

I am smiling at you did you ask yourself why?!

My face is just like a mask
Why don’t you ask?

With my mask I can almost do anything ...

I can cover my anger,
I can pretend I am happy,
I can hide my feelings,
I can also be someone else

I am smiling at you did you ask yourself why?!

You laugh, you cry, you get angry
But you are always you,
Not afraid of what they are going to say

I am smiling at you now you know why.

Comments & reviews · 6
User avatar
kitrosemon13
Review
kitrosemon13 wrote a review Review · Aug 21, 2010

Nice, I liked the idea of it. Oh and welcome to YWS! Here are a few pointer tips in the future,

Iamnotperfect wrote:Hi, this is my very first poem and I just wrote it on the go but it might be a bit rusty, however it does express my opinion
.................................................................

I am smiling at you did you ask yourself why?! (Go with stanzas and punctuation marks; do you see what I did below?)

My face is just like a mask,
Why don't you ask?
With my mask I can almost do anything....

I can cover my anger, (This as if nothing else in this poem stood out to me the most, try a different approach than just the 'I Can' thing, it fell through the cracks here a bit.)
I can pretend I am happy,
I can hide my feelings,
I can also be someone else.

I am smiling at you did you ask yourself why?!

You laugh, you cry, you get angry. (Good use a commas here.)
But you are always you,
Not afraid of what they are going to say...

I am smiling at you now you know why !


Overall this was good for a start, if you have any questions on reviewing message me or go to these links the help you get started....topic13842.html this is all about critique another's work. Also, topic57651.html have a great time here and check out those two info pages! Keep writing and good luck!

User avatar
Button
Review
Button wrote a review Review · Aug 21, 2010

Nice piece.. especially if you don't do much poetry. I would recommend adding some more punctuation in the lines themselves (not at the ends of them), and maybe reducing some of the repetition. It seemed a little overdone to me. I would also add in more a story.. this is a great deal of unexplained emotion, however well done the emotion is. The rhyming scheme is a bit inconsistent, which can throw off the reader a bit.. I would recommend throwing in some more couplets or making that one rhyme a little bit more subtle. Overall, a good write.

Random avatar
Iamnotperfect
Comment
Iamnotperfect commented Comment · Aug 20, 2010

Glimmerglass wrote:Hi, there. :)

First off, I like the statement you're making in this poem; it's a bit injured and defiant and angry, as if the narrator is finally tired of someone not noticing him or her. I think your poem expresses the feelings of many who are ignored or misunderstood.

A couple things: I noticed that two of your lines rhymed while the other ones did not.

Iamnotperfect wrote:My face is just like a mask

Why don’t you ask


I'm not sure if this was intentional, but I would remove the rhyme to make things more uniform. ;)

Three lines also caught my eye:

Iamnotperfect wrote:I am smiling at you did you ask yourself why?!


Iamnotperfect wrote:I am smiling at you did you ask yourself why?!


Iamnotperfect wrote:I am smiling at you now you know why !


I think you could add some punctuation in the middle: for example, try adding a colon after "at you."

Iamnotperfect wrote:I am smiling at you: did you ask yourself why?


For your finishing line, I might do the same:

Iamnotperfect wrote:I am smiling at you: now you know why !


As a finishing touch, I might also add periods at the ends of your sentences, so that it's a little more precise.

This is a very good first poem; I like how well you expressed your feelings. Keep writing!

--Glim



Hi thanks for your constructive comments :)

However my rhyming in one of the stanza's was intentional. Also I know punctuation is very important in general literature but I believe that having punctuation in poems is not a MUST since this type of writing shouldn't be constrained, especially in this case :smt002

Random avatar
Hersheypiegirl Comment
Hersheypiegirl commented Comment · Aug 18, 2010

I really liked this poem, it reminded me of myself. It really speaks to how most of are, waking around with masks hidding our true feelings.
-HersheyPie

User avatar
Glimmerglass
Review
Glimmerglass wrote a review Review · Aug 18, 2010

Hi, there. :)

First off, I like the statement you're making in this poem; it's a bit injured and defiant and angry, as if the narrator is finally tired of someone not noticing him or her. I think your poem expresses the feelings of many who are ignored or misunderstood.

A couple things: I noticed that two of your lines rhymed while the other ones did not.

Iamnotperfect wrote:My face is just like a mask

Why don’t you ask


I'm not sure if this was intentional, but I would remove the rhyme to make things more uniform. ;)

Three lines also caught my eye:

Iamnotperfect wrote:I am smiling at you did you ask yourself why?!


Iamnotperfect wrote:I am smiling at you did you ask yourself why?!


Iamnotperfect wrote:I am smiling at you now you know why !


I think you could add some punctuation in the middle: for example, try adding a colon after "at you."

Iamnotperfect wrote:I am smiling at you: did you ask yourself why?


For your finishing line, I might do the same:

Iamnotperfect wrote:I am smiling at you: now you know why !


As a finishing touch, I might also add periods at the ends of your sentences, so that it's a little more precise.

This is a very good first poem; I like how well you expressed your feelings. Keep writing!

--Glim



You never really know how much of you takes residence in other people... We all exchange bits and pieces of ourselves with each other until we're big sparkly collages of everyone and everything we've ever loved
— GengarTheGhost