Good Boy
Was he for real?
Often, when I passed Main Street, just past the small pawn shop and quaint diner, right underneath a big maple tree, I saw a dog.
It wasn’t an exceptional looking dog. Just a scraggly mutt with brown fur and black button eyes. He’d lay underneath the big maple tree, partly shrouded by the tall grass growing around him. Somebody really needed to mow that place, you couldn’t see where you were putting your feet!
He lay with his head on his paws, just staring. Into nothing, it seemed. His tail never wagged, ever. The many times I’ve seen him that dog’s tail never wagged. Just sat limply on the ground collecting dust.
What a weird dog. Was he for real?
I even tried to gain his attention once. Thought he was a stray and I could turn him in to the nearest shelter so he’d get a chance at a life. I was wearing high heels so it wasn’t like I could run. I just walked towards him slowly, careful not to make too much sound with my grocery bags and clanking keys. I got within ten feet of him. A good ten feet. Then I stretched out a hand, nothing too surprising. Unfolded my palm. In it was a doggy treat I’d picked up at the front counter of the grocery store. Free for the taking, too. He didn’t respond. Just stared at me with those black button eyes.
I lost the staring contest, by the way.
He didn’t take the treat. What kind of dog was this? I’d seen other dogs happily snarfing down the biscuits that their owners gave them. So why didn’t this mutt take my offering?
I waited for a few seconds, the treat still in my outstretched hand. Nothing. No movement. No tail thumping. No barking. Just… staring.
I slapped a bug on my leg with the other hand, jingling the bags on my wrist. Jesus, these bugs were driving me batshit crazy. The grass was so long it grazed my thigh!
Fuck. Nearly tripped over something. Something flat. A plank? I couldn’t see past all the green.
“Doggy want a treat?” I cooed, inching a bit closer to him. He didn’t move. What the fuck kind of dog was this? I huffed, pocketing the treat. This wouldn’t do. I had an appointment to go to in fifteen fucking minutes. I’d come back later for this mutt.
But that day, when I came back a few hours later when the sun was drifting lazily below the sky, he was gone.
Today, I kept my eyes trained on him. Watching him. He was in the same exact position as always, tail flat against the grass, head on his paws. He didn’t seem to give a shit when other dogs and their owners passed him on the sidewalk just a few feet away.
Now that I thought about it… The other dogs never seemed to pay any attention to him either. Even when they started barking at another dog a few feet away, they never barked at this dog.
Strange.
“Hurry it up, we’ve got a bus to catch!” My partner. He was always so impatient, that one. Never really stopped to observe his surroundings like I did. I suppose I needed him to keep me on track. I was a daydreamer, definitely.
“Do you see that dog?” I asked absentmindedly. He walked back over to me with a hand on his nose bridge, a sure sign of frustration. We had to catch a bus in ten minutes, to a meeting he had downtown. Normally his work let him stay home but today, since he had to actually leave the house to work, he was in a cranky mood.
“What dog?”
I pointed. “That dog.”
He squinted. “The pathetic one under the tree?”
I turned to him, shocked. He had never really liked animals, but I didn’t expect him to say something like that.
“Why do you think he’s like that?” I asked softly, avoiding my partner’s outburst. He shrugged. Kicked a stone.
“Beats me. A stray?”
I was about to turn and ask him what he thought was the right thing to do for the dog but he was already walking away, scuffing the dirt with his feet. “Get a move on! We’re going to miss the bus because of some stupid mongrel!”
I made the dog a quick promise that I’ll be back. I was starting to feel a connection to the mutt, having passed him almost every day to work.
With one last wave and a sure eye-roll from my partner, I left the big maple tree and walked off.
I was back before long. The next day, actually. I couldn’t seem to stay away…
The dog was there, like always. Same position, same glassy stare from those black button eyes.
This time I approached boldly. I had no treat. No intention of roping him in.
All I wanted to do was touch him. Run my fingers through that scraggly brown fur and see his reaction.
Quick steps. Now was not the time for hesitation.
He didn’t react when I got five feet within him.
Three feet.
One foot.
He skittered away. As soon as I reached out a hand he skittered away.
Too bold? Was I going too fast?
Not too bold.
Too late.
I had missed my chance.
When I looked up again… He was gone.
---
Ay, you nearly made a new friend there!
Woof!
She’s a gentle one, that woman. She wasn’t going to hurt you, Sonny.
A whimper.
Aw, it’s okay. You’re a good boy. Yes you are!
A furious wag of the tail. Woof!
She really seems to like you…
A whine. A pat on the head.
The man looked up to the sky.
Almost time, Sonny… Don't be scared. I'm waiting for you right here. I'll be the first person you see when you pass.
The dog slowly padded back to where he had been laying before.
He knew it was time.
---
I stopped.
Where was the dog?
He was gone. Right underneath the big maple tree was… nothing. Just tall grass poking out of the ground.
Where had he gone?
I stepped closer, clutching the dog treat I had snagged once more from the grocery store. I was sure I was gripping it so tight there were crumbs falling off. Where was the dog? The mutt? The brown mutt with black button eyes?
The one that had won me over?
I had seen him so often under the big maple tree that I knew exactly where he had laid. Strangely enough, there was no indent shaped like a dog. Just… grass.
Wait.
There was something else.
I parted the grass and bent down, narrowing my eyes. I hadn’t found a dog…
I had found a grave.
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hunnybunny, you made me read this story from the beginning till the very end with great interest. Well done, buddy!
I loved the way you describe the dog, the emotions of the MC, the lack of curiosity in the MC's partner, and so on. You definitely have a great ability of portraying the emotions of the characters in an obvious fashion.
I agree with papillote about the ending. It sort of just flew right over my head and didn't reach anywhere close to my brain (Pardon me if I'm being harsh!).
I also would love to mention another point: You seem to have a tendency to use incomplete sentences in your story (I'm not mentioning the examples here). It is at times a very artistic thing to use in literature. But maybe you've used it slightly excessively here, thought it's my personal opinion and you don't have to agree with me.
Overall, I truly loved reading the story.
Keep writing.
Thank you for your feedback! I was trying to use incomplete sentences in this story to make the mood choppy and unsure, like MC's emotions. I'll tone it down when necessary
About the ending, I will probably change it later on, seeing that so many people are a little confused
thanks again for reading!
Hi, HunnyBunny, I really liked this short story, but I was a little confused at the end, especially after I read the other review and realized I hadn’t understood it at all the right way. I thought it was his owner talking to him and that he was a live dog standing guard over a grave. Clearly, he’s a ghost dog, though. Maybe they’re both in that grave…? Please, let me know.
I would like to say, just for the record, that the MP’s partner sounds like an asshole. One of the most quotable sentences in the Harry Potter books stayed with me: “If you want to know what a man’s like, take a good look at how he treats his inferiors, not his equals.” Always take a good look at how people treat animals.
I made a note of some small mistakes and comments I think could be useful:
- I think the sentence “Often, when I passed Main Street, just past the small pawn shop and quaint diner, right underneath a big maple tree, I saw a dog.” sounds just a little odd because of the repetition of ‘passed’ ‘past’. Not necessarily bad, it makes it sound a little like a nursery rhyme or something.
- “Somebody really needed to mow that place, you couldn’t see where you were putting your feet!” comes a little out of nowhere where you put it and breaks the rhythm.
- I noticed you tend to end your paragraph on a sentence without a conjugated verb. I often do the same, and it’s fine to put some emphasis on what you’re putting in that sentence and to mirror speech patterns – maybe your MP’s, but it’ll get repetitive if you do it too often.
- “I lost the staring contest, by the way.” That was oddly hilarious.
- “Today, I kept my eyes trained to him.” It’s not “trained on him?’
- “Normally he didn’t come with me but today was an exception.” I assume you mean that they usually don’t go to work together, but it wasn’t completely clear.
- “I turned to him, shocked. He had never really liked animals, but I didn’t expect him to degrade the dog so harshly and so suddenly.” I don’t think what he’s just said was that bad. Maybe if he had said something like ‘The pathetic mongrel under the tree?’
- “I make the dog a quick promise that I’ll be back.” You probably mean ‘I made’.
- “I stepped closer, clutching the dog treat I snagged once more from the grocery store.” ‘I had snagged’
Final word: you’ve got everything you need to make a great, little story. All you need now is to make some small modification to make sure there are no more mistakes, typos, etc. and, of course, that your readers understand exactly what you meant for them to. That's really good, you're almost done.
Good luck, HunnyBunny, I hope you publish other short stories. I really liked this.
Thank you for pointing out my little mistakes! I will fix it right away. As for the plot, the dog was a live dog, but his owner had passed away, so the dog was standing over his owner's grave. At the end of the story, the dog dies. I'll see if I can make the plot a little more clear.
I was right, then

Good end to a crappy day, thank you for that
Hello,

This story has a really interesting idea and it kept me hooked from beginning to end. I love mysterious stories... and this one was really well-written. I liked the twist at the end of how this dog was actually dead all along... but this got me wondering about the section that was italicized. Was the dog imagining himself with his owner? Did the owner pass away before, and the dog was just waiting for his turn? Was the grave mentioned at the end the dog's or the owner's grave? Also, how could this MC and her partner see the dog when no other person or dog walking by reacted to him? If it was the dog's grave, then who buried it? There's still a lot of underlying mystery to this story, but in a part, I like the wonder this story leaves readers with.
Overall, I really liked this story, and I hope to read more from you!
Keep Writing
Hello,

This story has a really interesting idea and it kept me hooked from beginning to end. I love mysterious stories... and this one was really well-written. I liked the twist at the end of how this dog was actually dead all along... but this got me wondering about the section that was italicized. Was the dog imagining himself with his owner? Did the owner pass away before, and the dog was just waiting for his turn? Was the grave mentioned at the end the dog's or the owner's grave? Also, how could this MC and her partner see the dog when no other person or dog walking by reacted to him? If it was the dog's grave, then who buried it? There's still a lot of underlying mystery to this story, but in a part, I like the wonder this story leaves readers with.
Overall, I really liked this story, and I hope to read more from you!
Keep Writing
Thank you for your feedback! The dog's owner had passed away before, hence the dog resting on his owner's grave. You guessed it right, the dog was just waiting its turn.
The reason the MC and her partner could see the dog will always remain a mystery
It was all just part of the mysterious focus of the story. Thanks for reading, again! I appreciate it.
you're welcome