Hey there! I thought this looked interesting, so I figured I'd go ahead and quickly review it today.
What drew me into this was the character and the way you immediately landed us in his world - you did a great job of establishing right off the bat that Adam isn't a normal officer here, that he's currently conflicted about what's been going on. You also did a great job at using the names of things in that universe without explaining them, but still making it so the reader can easily understand what's going on. I was able to infer very quickly the setting and central conflict of a military outpost on this planet, and ethical concerns of using sentient robots/clones (I assume that's what S-62 is) to fight with.
However, Adam's voice also just felt off. It felt very flippant, without any of the gravitas that his actual words are conveying. He's lax in the introduction and as a whole, the tone feels very teasing, at least until he talks about S-62, where it feels a little more serious.
I realize that may have been intentional - maybe flippancy is Adam's way of coping with what's been going on. But I feel like that sort of flippancy wouldn't come through in a letter to his commanding officers. I would have thought he would be trying to hide it. As a whole, it diminished the severity of the letter, and just didn't quite work as a character introduction for me.
I’m starting to fear your tactical prowess is diminishing.
I think it was this sentence that really made it feel like he was teasing them.
What most interests me after reading these letters is finding out what the Overguard program is and why they need volunteers. I'm guessing that would be the main project you mentioned in your reply to the previous review.
I think that's all I've got for you! Sorry for the shorter review, but good luck, and keep writing!
Points: 90000
Reviews: 1085
Donate