Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
I'll keep in mind the below comment - these are cinquains.
Take with salt; yadda yadda.
Cinquain reference(for my own benefit):
1. unstressed-stressed or short-long (iambic)
Then 2 stresses, 3 stresses, 4 stresses, one.
Alright. I don't usually use such explicit forms. This will be interesting.
Phhaw... Well. Already the meter doesn't follow what I found online. -_-'
It goes fine in the first and second stanzas, but the third and fourth are each short a stress. (bolded for reference.) This could be purposeful. I don't know. I don't do meters. -_-
Anyway. Otherwise, dying hands extend to grasp the last light; then darkness. Good. No qualms, quibbles, or scribbles.
Okay, stresses so far: 1-2-2-3-1, 1-2-2-3-1.
I suppose "eyes" may be stressed... My scansion skills are meager. It doesn't feel stressed.
Meter aside: "Once dark, black consumes me, shutting my eyes"
I think by "Once dark" you mean "once it is dark." Unfortunately, that does not follow without those nasty extra syllables. Consider: "Now dark, black consumes me..."
Holistically: the dark was unexpected - blown fuse or tripped circuit, yeah?; instead, you just "flip the switch." I immediately think lightswitch. Could be circuit. Unclear. Hrm.
Meter? Ain't nobody. Ain't. Nobody.
I'mma do it anyway, because I feel like I should... 1-2-1-4-1. This one really gets me. The stress on "van" is questionable; perhaps you are suggesting a stress on "to" or "the"? "Show" and "way" are both... unstressed. "Lurking" is two stresses for one.
"calloused mazes" could be a reference I'm not catching, or it could just be poor diction. I favor the latter, but I'm biased towards myself. I think you were just looking for a stressed syllable that sounded nice.
2-2-3-2. And the first line is not short-long, but long-short. And there are only 4 lines?
Keep in mind I suck at scansion, and yell if you see something wrong.
You realize you rhymed a little? "Shrinking", "drink in."
Your lines interplay, then the last one breaks the flow.
Last two clauses don't flow.
Stressed-unstressed first line. Not iambic. 1-2-3-4-1. It follows Crapseyan form! (Except the first line -_-' )
The ideas are all solid and follow well.
Except for the first line, it fits. 2-2-3-4-1.
Hmm. Fear of dark stemming from a soul lost to hell.
"Shallow wet" is poor. Perhaps use pool? Or water?
Perfectly follows Crapsey form.
"Of" is egregious. Along with the "the" I removed before. Just so you know what they are.
1-2-3-3-1. Perhaps faded could be two stresses.
What was, is to come; not ghosts but remnants. Hrm.
I don't feel the stress on "Only," so... Eh. I also don't count "only" as a stress anywhere before.
1-1-3-4-1. First line is iambic.
The dashed breaks are weird. Not sure about them.
So... Hell melted the veil of ice around surrendered soul, now reaching for it, you are burned. I follow.
Reaching for Hell's captive soul, you reached within, found naught - and realize never was there one for Hell to take. Shivering stuff.
1-3-4-3-1. A little off again. First line is iambic, though.
The breaks in the middle of words: Sometimes okay, I think. But usually, it breaks flow. Which is bad.
Whoo. Well. Quite the poem, honestly. A lightswitch hitch into a soul-searching goose chase, shattering failed escape. I like the story, holistically. Technically, there are improvements to make. But good.
Be forever hortatory,
~Skorlir
Hello Epic,
A difficult format to write in, so, I understand why you did some things, but it was still confusing until I got the hang of it. For example, in the first sentence I read the word tendrils as ten drils, which confused me. Though, awesome poem overall. Like I said, this looked very hard to write, but maybe go back and think about word choice so that you can improve clarity. Great Job!
Zeph
Hola, donk!! I liked this one. This is a pretty good poem to me. I am a little confused.
Why are some of the words cut off? Maybe I just don't understand cinquains, but I got lost a couple of times.
A couple of times in fact. But, It's still a good poem. Keep it up!!
I wish you'd have explain the confusing parts, but thanks, hon! <3
Hey, Epic!
Euphers here to "review and rip apart" your poem, as you asked. c:
Let's get started..
Title:
I love it, and it definitely captures the essence of the poem, but I feel like it would still be just as bold, if it weren't such a mouthful, and you cut it back to "Fading Lights (Regret)"* o.o
Construction:
You're spacing drives me absolutely crazy.. >~< I feel like there are certain sentences that you split up, that should just be a new line of it's own.
Poetry itself:
As i told you before, I love the lyrical vibe you get as you read this poem. It's truly magnificent, and just .. I'm in awe, it's beautiful. :3
Overall:
Great job kiddo, and keep up the good work! I'd love to check out more of your work.
Hope this helped!
Thanks, love! <33333 As for the spacing, these are written in cinquains, so I tried to stick with the syllables. xD