This is just something I sat down and wrote late one evening. I didn't know what I was writing until the moment I put my pen to the page. It's not something that I'm particularly proud of, but you can tear it apart with your critique as much as you like.
That's why I joined YWS, anyways.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
The old man shuffled around in the garden, holding onto the fence as he went along. He couldn't walk if he had nothing to hold on to. If this was the case, he had to use his motorized chair.
In a way, he resented growing old. It wasn't fair to have to slowly die and lose mobility and the freedom to do things without the assistance of an outside source. He couldn't even walk a few yards without running out of breath. He lived on his own, but a cleaning lady had to come by and stay through the day to help him with certain tasks and to do menial work around the house.
In other ways, he considered it a blessing to have been allowed to live this long. It was a gift from God. He may have been impaired in some ways, but in others, he was excelling. His mind was still sharp. He could paint and sculpt. He could garden with little difficulty which is something he loved to do. He helped to keep himself healthy by drinking nothing but water and milk, an having a diet that consisted of mostly vegetables from his very own garden. He ate carrot sticks for snacks and drank milk to promote the strength of his bones. He kept himself updated on the world by having the local news delivered to his house daily, and never failed to do the crossword puzzle with ease. He didn't own a television. He always believed that they were brain-slurping monsters that would melt away your I.Q. in one sitting. Of course, he was a bit prejudiced, being raised in the days of no television and no computer. All he did back then was sit around and read. he also loved the outdoors back then, and still did, even as an eighty-year-old man. He loved to just sit on his back porch and watch the birds and animals go in and out of his spacious garden. He did most of his activities on that porch. He even fell asleep on it, sometimes.
Generally, he was a happy sort of guy. Very glass-half-full and optimistic. One thing that typically got him down was the memories of his dear wife. Theirs had been the classic love story. They met in high school and dated throughout it, married, and had kids, all at a young age. They had bough the house he was living in when they both were twenty, just before their first child was born.
To be continued.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
This can be said more eloquently. Or, you can say it indirectly with something like: "...holding onto the fence as he went along. He leaned heavily as he went, determined not to use the electric wheelchair."
Also can be done more eloquently.
I just don't get the feeling that a man of 70 or 80 or 90 years old is thinking these things, but rather a 15 year old is commenting on an old guy he/she saw in the street casually (i.e. you).
For example, you can take out the "it wasn't fair" part. If you describe the things that are happening to him as he ages properly, then we'll get a sense that he finds it unfair.
"...of an outside source" is unnecessary and wordy.
It's so vague that you're telling the whole world you have no idea what you're talking about.
Rewrite in shorter, more straightforward bursts: "He lived on his own, but an assistant stayed with him everyday to clean and cook" or something like that. Make it embarrassing, too, maybe. I know of bitter old people that curse the fact they can't wash their backs or butts, that they need help standing up from the toilet, that they fall asleep at the TV (though he doesn't have a TV), that they wet themselves and purposely spill coffee on themselves to hide the shame, that they can't make it over a step or lift their feet over an obstacle, etc. There's so much more to be angry about than having someone "help with certain tasks and do menial work."
This is in direct opposition to when you say:
"couldn't even walk a few yards without running out of breath" and "He couldn't walk if he had nothing to hold on to."
I have a garden, and I know it's hard work. A lot of bending over, lower back work, grasping, pulling, and digging. So I don't believe it.
That's not a very wistful way to think of your dead loved one. Fill it out with quirkiness. There are little things that people miss about loved ones.
So that's it. He's some old guy. Not particularly interesting. I'm not sure if you know what you're talking about.
All in all, I have no idea where this is going, if it's going anywhere. Put together something more coherent before you post and ask for reviews. It's like saying, "Once upon a time, there was a prince and a princess in a castle. They did stuff around the castle everyday. Give me reviews!"
Hello. wariofart is here, and a review is coming your way.
Overall: I'm not sure how long this piece is, but the part you posted seems to really short. The plot doesn't really go anywhere here, and frankly, its a bit boring. That's the biggest problem with this. It just feels so average. You're describing this old man, but there's nothing that is particularly interesting about him. He's old, he's weak and he's really generic. Even his love story looks to be generic. Now, if you presented this story in a new and interesting way, that would be fine, but that's just not the case here. Also, he just seems so happy. My advice is to maybe use this story as background information to make a more interesting story. Now that you know this man, tell us something interesting that he experiences. Maybe he meets up with a youngster, or a old women.
Confusing Bits:
The second sentence doesn't really make sense. If what was the case?
In conclusion, this piece didn't really have anything wrong with it, it just seemed generic to me. Best of luck with this!