Published June 6, 2011
[Post Deleted]
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Notwithstanding Octave's signature line (from On Writing, which is an excellent book on writing) http://books.google.ca/books?id=bO1WAAA ... r_versions
This is the link I was trying to find when you logged off. Also:
In places, you commit the error named here:
http://www.bartleby.com/141/strunk5.html#14 (read number 14)
Hope this helps.
pen
Okay, so my main problem with this is the lack of plot. This is an event, not a story. oo" It's well-written, no doubt about it, but where's the plot? The theme is obvious here, but you failed to really show me a plot. oo
Examples of the difference between plot and theme:
A young orphan enters a magical world he discovers he's a part of. - Theme
Harry Potter finds out he's a wizard and that a dark wizard is out to get him because he's the only person standing between that dark wizard and victory, so he works to survive the hurdles aforementioned wizard will throw at him. - Plot
A plot is a series of events that's connected to one another. For example, the king dies - that's not a plot. But the king dies and the queen commits suicide out of grief is a plot. But you probably know the difference, so I'm really just rambling for nothing. >> oo
Anyway, I do like the voice and the fact that the whole insanity thing isn't too in-your-face, but I find that the beginning crept along so slowly I felt like giving up. I like the way you write - you have a good grip on flow and such, but the pace is kind of not tight enough for me. The beginning is much too slow, but it does pick up when he goes nuts and sees the blood. Still, maybe you can drag that scene up closer to the beginning? The looong description about the fever kind of turned me off.
The characterization here is a little too subtle, but I think it works anyway, so I'll leave it be. For the most part, this is a really good piece! Just...not enough plot. oo" Maybe have your MC want something? I don't know. It's your story, so it's up to you.
Lastly, you tend to beat your reader over the head with a stick? oo" You repeat some things so much it's akin to drilling the information into my head with a jackhammer, and it gets kind of annoying. You can afford to cut out some things here, since they basically say the same thing over and over again over an extended period of time. ^^" Mention it once or twice, and your reader will understand it. The only exception to this is an obsession, and I think your soldier doesn't really have an obsession with his fever...does he? o0"
Cheers. 8] I know it isn't much, but I tried. This was just pretty good, so I couldn't really critique so much. oo I hope I helped anyway.
Sincerely,
Octave
Oh my. . . .
Well, I've made my first post less than twenty minutes ago, got the notification of your reply six minutes ago, so let's see. . . it took you all of 2 minutes to have my mind utterly riveted upon your story.
Before I begin the official review, this is a first for me, so I'm sorry if I seem presumptuous or arrogant, or if i just flat out do it wrong. . . .
I'm not going to lie. This was sick. It was gut-wrenching. It was horrifying. I DID NOT WANT TO READ THIS! For this, sir, I give you a standing ovation. You told your message in an intense, graphic way that is going to be unpleasant to many because of the cushioned lifestyle they live.However, you stayed true to that message. I especially applaud you on telling this in such a way that it shows that the true traumas an armed soldier faces are fought off the battlefield, in the mind, rather than with a gun in a foreign country.
Your word selection and vocabulary was varied and impressive. This is going to sound very stupid, but using 'rapture' especially made me realize that you had a large arsenal of adjectives at your disposal.
Your imagery was gruesome, icy spikes into my veins. Perfect. You showed the terror of being trapped in a 'reality' that is only real to you, and the utter horror at events that could occur within this reality-that's-not-reality.
I only have one critique--
"All Creed could see was bloodshed and destruction of war." Personally, I would either make it "THE bloodshed and destruction of war", or "was bloodshed and THE destruction". Personally, I'm more partial to the former, but it's up to you.
Well, that concludes it, i guess. I hope that you find this at least a little helpful.
Yours truly,
Pyro
Hey,
You're theme was challenging, and you were very true to it.
I liked your character though he's insane and out of it. Your portrayal of a disturbed soldier's way of thinking is realistic, bothered with the gore yet focused on it. I wrote a story on a soldier recently, and the way he thinks isn't very believable.
Um... This story had no plot to me. It didn't really go anywhere. I mean, the language is great, as always. You have wonderful description, but nothing happened. He woke up from a dream which kind of feels like you're taking the easy
way out.
My only nitpick is the name of the nurse. It's unnecessary and makes the sentence kinda clunky. That's my opinion though, so ignore it if you disagree.
This is a crappy review, but I've been out of reviewing for a while now, so your piece was a step back into it after exams.
Good luck in the contest,
Megsug
Hi! I'm here to repay the favour! I have to say that I liked this very much. I can tell that it's been very well thought out...you've worked really hard on this and your effort has clearly paid off. I loved the last sentence: ooh, chilling...I have only one nitpick
- I think this would read better if you said: her lips formed a lovely smile.I honestly dont think you get enough recognition for your work and I'd love if you can get a feature, particularly for this piece. A * like* from me.
Keep writing, Hayden!
~ Amelia