Hello! Happy Review Day!
I'll start with some nitpicks and general thoughts as I read through:
A child was sitting in front of the Bottle-O, chin on her knees. Swaddled in clothes too big for her. Twisting a knife between her fingers. Metal edge trapped light. Spun on point. Slipped. Silver tip buried in her thumb. Opened her leathery skin wide. Blood welled in her palm. Streamed down her wrist. She wiped it on a grimy handkerchief and wrung it out on the footpath.
I would start a new paragraph at "a child". Also, I tend to really like short snappy sentences, but here it doesn't work for me for some reason. I think it's too much.
Wait, the protagonists see this but no one stops to help her? Seems like sort of a weird place to start, this description of a little girl hurting herself and then right into what the other characters are doing as they go about getting ready for their trip.
Alex’s chosen beach was long and full of clean air, tide so far in it was butting against the dunes. We drove up to the lookout and ate fish and chips watching for whales. Hot paper burnt my legs through my jeans and my mouth stung from heat and salt. When we’d finished we listened to Morrissey sing about grey days as the sky deepened and rain drew down to meet the sea.
A lot of stuff happens in this paragraph. I'd think about slowing it down, spreading it out, and adding a lot more description.
Whales were jumping half out of the water and smashing onto their backs, fins outstretched. Blue whales.
I'm no whale expert, but do blue whales do this?
I was watching them, wondering if we could get the camera before they disappeared, when I heard branches crack beneath me. Alex yelled for me to follow her; she was trying to find a shortcut to the beach. We were parked at the top of a rocky hill, and the quickest way down was to slide. Only it wasn’t so much a hill as a cliff, with a threadbare covering of young trees. They grew out from rocks at odd angles, twisted by salt winds. Alex was sliding down from one to the next, using them to slow her fall.
I really liked this level of description. That paragraph I said to add more description - I think something like this would be good.
Still, I got the impression that something else was moving through the bush to our left. Keeping pace with us.
I'm not going to copy the whole paragraph that this sentence was a part of, but I liked this paragraph, too. Same as the comment above
Also, my thought with this sentence: ooooooooo ominous!
“Alex.” My voice had to be calm too. “Alex. She’s got a knife.”
ooooooooooooo extra ominous!! (should I be reading this late at night?) :p
Is this the same kid from the very beginning? I might try to separate that out more. I still think it's confusing to have the bit about the kid and then cut right to what the MCs are doing with no explanation.
“I’m exhausted. My leg is bleeding again. You are going to start bleeding more if you use your hand too much. We’re both terrified and shaking, and we’re only here because you want to take some stupid bloody photos. There is no fucking way you are getting me to climb down that cliff.”
I'm not feeling this dialogue. I think it's been good up until this point but this one felt really awkward to me.
“I don’t think we’ll have to.” She walked away a bit, and I watched her go. Then I saw where she was heading. The ground, which had been sloping up until this point, sloped down. There were no trees, just grass. It was an easy walk down to the rocks.
How did they not notice this when they were coming up?
“I saw her. While you were getting fish and chips. She was sitting outside, fiddling with it.”
Why didn't she say anything then?
“No. She cut her hand. I recognised the cut.”
“Poor thing.”
“Yeah.”
They feel bad for something that almost, maybe tried to kill them?
Interesting! Okay! You posted this as a short story, but this can't be the end, right? You're going to post more?
Overall, it's a good arch - you have goals for your characters, conflict, and stakes. But I feel like there's no resolution. I mean, they got their whale picture like they wanted from the beginning, but there's still this little girl with a knife wandering around! I need to know more about her. I have so many questions!!
I think your writing is pretty clean. There are times that I think you get a little rushed and you could slow way down and give a lot more description. The only character name I remember is Alex (is the other girl's name ever mentioned?) and I don't have a strong sense of who either of them are or how to distinguish either of them. This can be done through differences in dialogue/manner of speaking, mannerisms, actions, habits, etc.
Along with that, in terms of description, think of the senses and try to use those to bring more of this to life. There are passages where I think you do a really nice job with descriptions, but other times it falls flat to me. I want to feel like I'm there with them. Paint me a picture
Interesting story idea. I seriously want to know more about this scary knife girl, so please write more!!
Let me know if anything I said is confusing or if you have any questions!
Points: 32055
Reviews: 1162
Donate