The Wingless Girl

Well, I'm back, after a long absence due to schoolwork and standardized testing. I probably can't stay long either because of the upcoming AP Tests, but after those I should be free to play on YWS as much as I want!

Anyway, I've started giving serious consideration to my writing again (between writing comic scripts for my sister...), and I've now come up with an idea I'd like to make my first novel. What I have now was written quite some time ago and will probably be quite different from the final product; nonetheless, the basic ideas (and most of the characters) are in place, so...please examine this and help me decide whether this is worth continuing or if I should just discard it. Thanks in advance!

The Wingless Girl (chapter one?)

Dr. Irvin quite liked the neophyte's wings. They were sleek and streamlined and shiny black, like a raven's, and stood in stark contrast to Irvin's own massive, snow-white, powerful ones. But those wings--like the wings of any person--complemented the rest of the neophyte: He was thin and pale and bore a shock of dark hair and serious dark eyes. His lab coat was white and impeccable, and the shirt and tie he wore underneath were perfectly crisp and straight. The name tag on his chest read Ira Dirinel, PhD. He was obviously a recent graduate from one of the Universities, but which one Irvin didn't know.

Irvin felt confident about his prospects with this neophyte. According to conventional folk wisdom, the courtship period between a white-wing and a black-wing might be a little rough, but they would soon settle into a long-lived, happy relationship. That is, if the neophyte wasn't already taken. With his looks, he probably was.

"How are you liking the Fortress, Dr. Dirinel?" said Dr. Irvin politely. Dirinel stared back over the desk. The sound of waves crashing against the Fortress base thundered loudly, even all the way up here, in Irvin's office.

"Does it ever stop?" said Dirinel, glancing out of Irvin's large port-way, where the salt smell of the sea filtered in. All that was visible outside the port-way was the bleak white sky, and the shapes of seagulls and occasional flyers. Nevertheless, the low roar of the waves could be heard even in Irvin's office, thirty stories above the sea.

"What stop?" said Irvin, though he knew quite well what Dirinel was talking about. It was the question all neophytes, having grown up in their insulated city Universities, asked.

"The waves...that sound. Even during night?" Dirinel questioningly tilted his head toward the port-way. He looked so innocent right there that Dr. Irvin suddenly realized just how young the man was--couldn't be any older than twenty-five. They were getting their PhDs younger and younger nowadays, these neophytes...

Irvin threw his head back and laughed. "Of course not, dear doctor! Do you think the very sea would stop pounding just so we insignificant human scientists can get a good night's sleep?"

Dirinel turned a rather curious shade of red, and suddenly Irvin realized that he had embarrassed the neophyte. "Of...of course...I wasn't thinking...but do you ever get used to it?" he pressed on. Irvin smiled at the neophyte's persistence.

"Yes. Over time...I've spent the better part of twenty years here, I've become quite used to it. In fact, when I visit land, I feel almost...lonely...for the beast is not serenading me." Irvin stood up from his desk to take several long, powerful strides towards the office port-way. It was a larger port-way than most, to accomodate Irvin's powerful frame and massive wings, and there Irvin stopped, his hands folded behind his back, admiring the sea roaring and crashing stories below, ceaselessly against the old rock foundation of the Fortress...

"It becomes the sound of home," he explained after a silence, as the neophyte watched him.

"Ah, well," said Dirinel, with a slight shake of the head, "I'm still not entirely used to it. It is quite loud..."

"Yes, that's why we learn to shout here," said Irvin. He took in a deep breath of the sea's salt tang before heading back to his desk, though he did not sit down. "Dr. Dirinel, from which University did you receive your doctorate?"

"Calvin, on the mainland," said Dirinel, jerking his shoulder in a dispassionate shrug.

Irvin thought a bit. "A good school," he finally said. "Turns out a great number of excellent scientists, almost all who head for the Fortress...speaking of which, Dr. Dirinel, do you know exactly why you're here?"

Dirinel gave a curt nod. "Yes, sir. We're here to study parallel universes, correct?"

Irvin jerked, startled. Dirinel's reaction was not the usual reaction of most neophytes--in Irvin's experience, most Fortress neophytes were eager and excited to be taking part in such a mysterious, young field of study. It even amazed Dr. Irvin himself, at times, to think that there were millions of other worlds out there, hidden, but there...and he found himself thinking once more of the wonderful prize that the Fortress had recently obtained...

"Doesn't that interest you a bit?" said Irvin, somewhat puzzled. Dirinel shook his head jerkily.

"No sir. I mean, it does, but in a purely theoretical manner. There's no way one can travel between universes, after all. It's just an interesting theoretical problem, isn't it, sir?" Dirinel looked up at Irvin, and the older scientist realized that the younger was worried that he had offended his senior.

Dirinel's position was a good one, a logical, solid, tenable position, and certainly one those poor University-bound scientists had no choice but to follow. Suppressing a mirthful chuckle over the ignorance of the University scientists, Irvin instead decided to completely, and cruelly, break down everything Dirinel had believed about parallel universes...oh, how cruel he was.

A rough courtship period, indeed!

"Actually," said Irvin, unable to suppress his triumphant smirk, his heart pounding as he unveiled his trump card, "it isn't. You see, we've proven that there is a way to journey between universes. The proof is there, if you will follow me."

Dirinel stared at Irvin, his dark eyes wide. He didn't move, even as the older scientist headed for the door out of the office. It was plain that he was shocked beyond anything, and in fact, he looked even paler than his usual tone.

"Wh...where?" he finally said. "What proof? Where?"

"A specimen, if you will," said Irvin airily, sliding his key card into the door's lock. It slid open with a hiss, and Irvin motioned for Dirinel to follow him out into the hall. "It's in the underground lab...the below levels."

A slight crease appeared between Dirinel's brows. "The underground levels...how do you access them? I don't see any port-ways for them..."

"No, we take the elevator," said Irvin, having come to a stop before the rarely-used Fortress elevator. He punched in the button for the Underground 4. Dirinel eyed the elevator with some level of distate, which Irvin understood.

"This makes me feel like a child again," complained the younger scientist as he stepped inside the plain, unadorned box of the elevator, folding his wings to his slim body for space.

"I dislike it too," said Irvin sympathetically. In particular, he always found his massive wings a tight fit, and with someone else in there with him... "Why don't they make this bigger?"

"No one uses it," pointed out Dirinel.

They spent the rest of the long journey in silence, Irvin disliking the closed, cramped space and wishing heartily that he could simply just fly down to the below levels, though of course that was impossible. From the way Dirinel was impatiently fidgeting, he was thinking the exact same thing.

At long last, the elevator came to a clanky stop, and the doors whooshed open, to Irvin's relief. He didn't hate the elevator that badly, as he now used it almost every day, but Dirinel glared back at the elevator and grumbled, "I hope I never have to do that again."

"Oh, you'll be doing it a lot," said Irvin simply. He didn't know exactly why he was showing this neophyte the specimen--perhaps it was simply because he wanted to convince this skeptic that yes, travel between dimensions was possible. Or maybe it was something of a...date.

Dirinel was now examining the small room they had stepped inside. It was an underground laboratory, smelling of dank earth and, like the rest of the Fortress, sea salt, with lab machines and computers lining the small walls. A single mousy female technician with dull-brown sparrow wings was working on the machines--when the two scientists entered, she gave a polite nod in their direction.

But now all of Dirinel's attention was focused on the very center of the room...on the crackling orange containment field, and the person inside it: A girl, completely naked and hairless, even on her head, looking no older than twelve or thirteen...and...

And she had no wings.

"Well, Dr. Dirinel?" said Irvin pleasantly, stepping up to the younger scientist, who was staring wide-eyed at the girl in the containment field. She was hardly complacent about her prison--she was banging on the field and shouting muffled words that sounded like curses through it. "What do you think? She has no wings. Think of it. A human with no wings."

"Oh, who's here to study me this time, huh? What're you gonna poke in me this time!" shouted the girl, and finished with a stream of curses. Dirinel continued to stare wordlessly at her.

"She speaks our language, though," he noted, his words cold.

"True," said Irvin.

"Who's to say she isn't an exile?" shot back Dr. Dirinel, spinning around to glare at Irvin, his dark eyes fierce. "You bring me this--a girl who speaks English, and who just might be a wingless exile--and expect me to believe that travel between dimensions is possible? Are you mocking me, sir?"

Irvin shook his head, unable to help the smile that crossed his face. Good...so the neophyte was smart enough not to accept everything on face value. That was excellent, an excellent quality, but Irvin was in no way mocking him. "No, I'm not mocking you. Spin around, miss." He rapped on the field to get the furious girl's attention.

"What?" she snarled, defiant, angry. "Why should I do what you say? Am I your lab rat or something? Huh?"

Irvin sighed and indicated Dirinel, who was hanging back, cold and skeptical. "He doesn't believe you're not from our dimension. So show him you aren't. Spin around."

"Tch, you winged freaks," grumbled the girl, before turning around slowly--to reveal a smooth back, free of the terrible heavy scars that, along with their cut-off wings, were the signs of an exile. Dirinel actually stumbled backwards in shock, and Irvin had to catch him to prevent him from tripping over a few cords.

"That's not all," explained Irvin, who was definitely enjoying the younger scientist's reaction to the wingless girl. "Here--show him--" He was speaking to the technician now, who obliged, bringing up several x-rayed pictures on her computer monitor. "Look at the x-rays of her spine...she doesn't even have the characteristic bone growths that even exiles retain."

"Then...then..." Dirinel struggled to bring his words out. "Then...you are saying...she has no wings...and never had wings." The thought obviously disturbed him, as he brought his own sleek black wings closer to him.

"Yes," said Irvin, waiting to see if he'd won Dirinel over or if the neophyte was going to come up with even more arguments against this girl being from another dimension where people had no wings.

Dirinel folded his arms and turned pointedly away from the girl, who continued swearing through her containment field prison. "You do know that there are genetic disorders--blessedly rare--that result in people being born without--without...wings."

"Yes, but usually those disorders come with other complications--bad eyesight, susceptibility to illness, etcetera," said Irvin, calm as ever. "Come now, Arram's Razor, Dirinel--the simplest explanation--"

"Is that she's from our world," said Dirinel shortly. "Travel between dimensions is impossible."

Irvin was about to answer, but the wingless girl saved him from. "That's what you think, ya winged freak! I'm from another world, and it's a damn sight better than yours!"

"She believes it herself," said Irvin. Dirinel glared at Irvin out of the corner of his eye.

"But that...it...it's simply...well...preposterous," he muttered, so softly Irvin could hardly hear him. Suddenly, he glanced up, at the low roof of the lab (which Irvin's head almost scraped), and added, "In my...where I come from...there are rumors...of societies of wingless people...high in the mountains..."

Irvin unleashed a short and impatient laugh. "Resorting to regional fairy tales, now, are you? Come now--what's more believable, that this girl is part of some hitherto undiscovered secret society of wingless mountain people, or she comes from a completely unexplored other dimension where people have no wings?"

Dirinel's argument was fading, fast, and the neophyte seemed to know this. He gave a trouble glance over to the still furious wingless girl, and then looked back at Irvin. "Another dimension...I don't know how that is possible. How...how did she get here?"

"I got through the falls, I keep telling you folks, I got here through the Bloodstone Falls, didn't I?" shouted the girl, banging on the containment field. "I don't know how that happened, either, but I lost my party and then I found the falls and when I woke up I was in this weird place where everyone had wings..."

Irvin was ignoring the girl now, and instead he motioned for Dirinel to get back in the elevator. They had spent long enough here, after all...the superiors had warned him and the other senior scientists from staying with the specimen for too long, lest they culturally contaminate her. Dirinel, for his part, looked more than relieved to leave. He didn't even bother complaining about the elevator.

"We don't know how she got here," explained Irvin when they were in the elevator. "That's what we're looking in to right now. She claims to come from these 'Bloodstone Falls', but that's completely preposterous. We've been examining her...it's the best we can do."

Dirinel didn't appear to be listening, however. He had instead wrapped his wings around his person and was gently running his hands up and down the pinions, stroking the feathers...preening, right here? Irvin was a little surprised--Dirinel didn't appear to be the kind of person who preened in public, but then again, appearances could be decieving.

"People without wings..." he said, in almost a whisper, sounding both troubled and marveled. "It's hard to imagine...an entire world...where nobody has wings...how do they get places?"

Irvin shrugged. "I suppose they have other ways. But I suggest if you're interested, you can talk to the specimen. She's more than willing to divulge all about her world--seems to think it's far better than ours..."

"Better?" Dirinel still sounded more than a little disturbed, as he continued examining his wings. "How could it be better, if no one can fly?"

-----

I'm welcome to any suggestions! (First, I probably should reduce Dr. Irvin's skeevishness...whatever). And again, I'd like to know if this is worth continuing or not. Thank you all!

Comments & reviews · 13
Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.

User avatar
babymagic18
Comment

I really enjoyed reading this the title really caught my attention thats good a good story should always catch the readers attention. You have a gift of good writing it's nice that you can share with others.

User avatar
Antigone Cadmus
Comment

You aren't being demanding at all! Afterall, I'm an instructor. :wink:
That's what I'm here for!

Bad choice of words...I know. O_o Not that I've been in the most lucid of moods today. Honestly, I've been having a bit of a bad day mostly because I discovered my school cut all three of its major advanced placement science classes because "there wasn't enough interest". Just goes to reaffirm my school as a school for idiots. >_> And now I'm all worried about screwing my schedule up for next year.


That sucks... all the schools in my area are like, "ZOMG SCIENCE!" and are dumping liberal arts programs.

And this piece was good! Keep in mind that it's only the first chapter. You didn't fail on anything.

You can have an over dramatic character -- but you need to make it obvious that you made him that way.

You can show this with the way your characters react to each other. Have Dirnil rolls his eyes discreetly when Irvin says something weird. Or something like that. :D

You should be glad that I'm getting this in-depth. It means there weren't enough grammar errors to bother me, so I'm being insanely nit-picky with the plot.

If you have any more questions, feel free to PM me.

--Antigone

User avatar
Bickazer
Comment

Ack, please ignore this post...is there a way to delete posts? >_> Because this is a total mistake...it's not meant to be here.

*feels like an idiot*

User avatar
Antigone Cadmus
Comment

Hey again! So you wanted me to elaborate.

You had good points, especially on the description (though now I feel conflicted, because a previous reviewer suggested I needed more description, not less...). I did write this about two years ago, so my style was different then....though I think that I still suffer from a few of the same issues...



More description?:shock: No offense, but the amount of adjectives you used were a bit... annoying. I personally lie the write minimalistically, but this was... agh. XD
Remember my butter analogy. Most description in your story was grouped too closely to be enjoyable.

And yes, Irvin is meant to be gay (well, bi, as the next chapter reveals). I'm sorry if that wasn't clear enough; I didn't want to go out and have him say "Guess what, I'm gay!" in his narration, but let the reader infer it...but I guess I wasn't clear enough. >_> I'm too ambiguous...



Well, I guess the problem I had with that was that there is a difference between a gay man checing out someone of the same gender and looking at him for marriage.

I would have him view the other neophytes with lust as opposed to like a woman looking for marriage. :wink:

"Neophyte"...I dunno, to me it's a word that I've always known (at least since fifth grade or so). But I've realized after some eleven years of schooling that I possess a much larger vocabulary than most kids my age. Actually, that vocabulary comes from reading a lot, and when I didn't know what words meant I would look them up (or guess from context clues). "Neophyte" I believe I first saw in "A Series of Unfortunate Events", and is basically a fancy way of saying "noob". Which would be appropriate for a junior scientist like Dirinel. Sorry if there was any confusion, but I'm not changing the word.


Oh, I knew what it met (my user-name is ancient Greek, afterall) but I know most people don't. Keep it if you want, but I think it's a bad idea.

And please elaborate more on what bothered you about the girl's dialogue because I don't know, I wanted to portray her as rebellious, not afraid....and give her a unique voice that'd definitely indicate she came from another world. I was kind of using Lyra from His Dark Materials as an influence... >_> Another reviewer's commented on being bothered by her dialogue too, so I suppose I failed in that endeavor, then.


I suppose because her dialogue is completely unbelievable. You say she's thirteen, but that isn't what she sounds like. I've read His Dark Materials -- she doesn't sound like Lyra. She's annoying. She speaks like a five-year old. All she talks about is how they're "freaks". Not only is that much too mild of an insult, I don't thin that would be her reaction.
Have her rocking in a corner and refusing to speak.
Have her cursing them and refusing to cooperate.
Something like that. XD

Thanks for the in-depth review again, and seriously...I'm blushing a bit. Is this seriously the most entertaining piece you've read on this site? O_o I...I don't know what to say. Maybe elaborate a bit on what made it so "entertaining", because I'd like to know what I'm doing right as well as wrong so I can keep doing the right things and stop doing the wrong things...?


This is just one of the only pieces that I thought had a good solid plot. After reviewing thousands of Twilight-copies, this was fresh and original. It was entertaining enough that I actually wanted to read it.

Your grammar was good so it was an easy review.

Honestly? This is the kind of book I would read if I saw it at the library. :D

What are you doing right and wrong?

This is how I would review your first chapter if I was on Amazon XD:

A good, solid plot -- very original. Very entertaining, however the author seemed to feel the need to describe everything with at least seven adjectives. The main girl character is unbelievable and I found myself skimming through her annoying dialogue. I found the main professor to be very overdramatic. His dialogue too was unbelievable. All that put aside, this was a good read.

User avatar
Tatra
Review
Tatra wrote a review · Mon May 04, 2009 1:29 am

It's an interesting concept, really original. People with wings have always fascinated us and your feathered characters certainly are fascinating. Dr. Irvin sure is a character, though he is slightly wordy and creepy. Previous reviewers have already covered the wordiness and his frequent, unexplained mentions of mating.

So, now's the time I point out the stuff that I noticed, my two cents as it were.

Irvin felt confident about his prospects with this neophyte. According to conventional folk wisdom, the courtship period between a white-wing and a black-wing might be a little rough, but they would soon settle into a long-lived, happy relationship.

Okay, even though I said that people have already covered this, it is still rather creepy to just start this whole thing off with him obsessing over the guy's wings. Plus, he seems really arrogant here, as though it were predestined for him and Dr. Dirinel to get together simply because of their wing color. Plus, the whole sentence just screams of cliche as well as a sort of slimy sappiness. I mean, the whole sentence is basically your world's equivalent of someone courting a 'red head with a quick temper.' I do think that this whole thing will be better once you follow the previous reviewer's advice, but I'm just mentioning this because of the impression it makes for your novel.

Instead of this sounding about the whole 'parallel worlds,' 'alternate universes,' it sort of reeks of a romance story between these two guys.

"Does what stop?" said Irvin, though he knew quite well what Dirinel was talking about. It was the question that all neophytes, having grown up in their insulated city Universities, asked.

"Does what stop" flows better than 'What stop?" Also, think about it, do people really answer "What ___." when asked "Does This ever ___." Tis the same formatting. I also added a 'that' to make things flow better.

Irvin instead decided to completely, and cruelly, break down everything Dirinel had believed about parallel universes...oh, how cruel he was.

You repeat Cruel twice here. Plus, aren't scientist supposed to be learning new things? Wouldn't Dr. Dirinel be interested to learn that he didn't know everything?

A rough courtship period, indeed!

*cough, you still have no idea if he's single or interested, cough* That stuff is about character, though...

"Why don't they make this bigger?"

Why would Dr. Irvin be asking this? I mean, he's spent years at this facility, using this elevator, wouldn't he have already gotten over the use of the elevator? Maybe he simply says, "I've always wondered why they didn't make these bigger." Though, that begs the question why a race of winged people wouldn't make their elevators bigger to accommodate them. Keep in mind that these winged people made this world, they shouldn't have to adapt to our universe (until you get to an actual part of a story where they are in our universe).

They spent the rest of the long journey in silence, Irvin disliking the closed, cramped space and wishing heartily that he could simply just fly down to the below levels, though of course that was impossible.

Why don't they build a port way down to the underground levels? Maybe you want to explain exactly why there aren't any port ways, even though we get the impression that it is for security's sake.

A girl, completely naked and hairless, even on her head, looking no older than twelve or thirteen...and...

A question that you don't really have to answer in this line, but you do need to think about, though I suppose you must have already. Did they shave her head, or are the humans in that 'verse all bald?

"Tch, you winged freaks," grumbled the girl, before turning around slowly--to reveal a smooth back, free of the terrible heavy scars that, [s]along with their cut-off wings,[/s] were the signs of an exile.

First, why on earth would she do this? I mean, from the way that she's cursing, she really wouldn't be the type to just cooperate like that. Wouldn't it be easier to just circle around her? Secondly, I don't think that the cut off wings part is necessary. I mean, wouldn't the heavy scars equal that she didn't have any wings? Plus, you already did mention the wing thing several times.

"Come now, Arram's Razor, Dirinel--the simplest explanation--"

Now, this part is the part that really got to me. One question, is "Arram" the name of the guy in your winged people universe? If so, it might just be best to go with our universe's name. Cause, I mean, unless this Arram guy is going to be actually joining the cast, most people only have a passing knowledge of Occam's Razor. Though, maybe you keep the strange name and have the Wingless girl protest it. This way only makes us protest it, and that really doesn't say good things about you.

Dirinel's argument was fading, fast, and the neophyte seemed to know this. He gave a trouble glance over to the still furious wingless girl, and then looked back at Irvin.

And this would be the point where a true scientist would be demanding to see the actual data and to do tests of his own. Of course, most of my knowledge of scientists comes from Stargate SG1 and Stargate Atlantis, so it's not perfect, :D

She claims to come from these 'Bloodstone Falls', but that's completely preposterous.

Why is it preposterous? Shouldn't they be out looking for this 'Bloodstone Falls?' Do they believe that it doesn't exist, or do they know that it exists and can't believe that she couldn't have gotten to their world from there? You have to keep in mind that we don't know about your world.

"People without wings..." he said, in almost a whisper, sounding both troubled and marveled. "It's hard to imagine...an entire world...where nobody has wings...how do they get places?"

I don't think that the ellipses are really necessary, though maybe the last set could be left in.

All in all, it's an interesting idea. I really do love Alternate Universe stories, especially when one reality is crossing into another. You just seem to need to clarify a few things in order to make your story flow better. But, it really is a great start to a novel and I can't wait to see how it goes and what the plot is.

- Tatra

Geez... it took me a long time to get to this. :oops:

As I explained to you, my computer decided to erase your review.

So let's try again, shall we?

Round Two

Dr. Irvin quite liked the neophyte's wings.


Neophyte? Having your reader run to the dictionary after the first line = bad idea.

They were sleek and streamlined and shiny black, like a raven's, and stood in stark contrast to Irvin's own massive, snow-white, powerful ones.


Whoa, whoa, whoa. :shock: Description overload.

I noticed this in the rest of your writing, so I'll address it now:

Description is like butter. When spread thinly on toast, it is quite enjoyable. However, if you were to eat globules of butter, it would be... not so enjoyable.

Try to thinly spread your description throughout the story. The sentence above is a glob of butter. Look how many adjectives you have there:

--sleek
--streamlined
--shiny
--black
--raven-like
--massive
--snow-white
--powerful

Eight adjectives in one sentence? Blech. Spread them out a bit.

You also use the word "and" far too much.

So let's remove some "ands", as well as cutting down on the description:

There were dark and sleek like a raven's, in contrast to Irvin's white ones.

Then, you can spread the description throughout the story!

For example, several sentences later, you can add some more:

As the neophyte sat down, Irvin observed that his wings were built for speed.

Then the reader isn't overwhelmed by so much butter.

He was thin and pale and bore a shock of dark hair and serious dark eyes.


Meh. Too much description again.

He was obviously a recent graduate from one of the Universities, but which one Irvin didn't know.


Is it obvious? Not to me. Perhaps Irvin knows, but your readers are new to this world. Explain.

Here I would like to add the Irvin's gender remains ambiguous for far too long. You simply say "Irvin" this or "Irvin" that. The whole time I was wondering whether he was male or female.

According to conventional folk wisdom, the courtship period between a white-wing and a black-wing might be a little rough, but they would soon settle into a long-lived, happy relationship.


I know Irvin to be male, so why is he thinking about marriage/mating? It seems a bit random. I'd take this out.

Nevertheless, the low roar of the waves could be heard even in Irvin's office, thirty stories above the sea.


You said the exact same thing several sentences above. Nix one of them.

They were getting their PhDs younger and younger nowadays, these neophytes...


I would put this in italics and have Irvin think it since it is in the present tense.

I've become quite used to it. In fact, when I visit land, I feel almost...lonely...for the beast is not serenading me."


I adore that metaphor, but would anyone say that outloud?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

Wow! I actually couldn't find any more nit-picks! Thanks for having good grammar. XD

Onto the...

Overall

Honestly? I. Loved. This. It was extremely good, and I'll definitely read more. I'm captivated by the story.

Of course, like any writing, it isn't perfect yet...

Irvin

Not much is known about him yet. He seems like your average witty professor kind of guy.

My only problem with him is his weird analogy of courting the young man. It implies he's homosexual, and I don't think that's what you were going for...

The Girl

She doesn't have much of a part in this chapter, but her dialogue really bothered me. It seemed a bit corny, like a movie from the fifty's you see on TV Land. Would she really talk like that?

Think how you would feel. Would you swear, cry, be frightened? I didn't find her reactions realistic.

And where do they keep her? Enclosed somewhere? Elaborate on that.

Repetition

A little too much. You repeated the same things over and over again. I get it -- Irvin has massive wings!

Vary your vocabulary some. You use some words a lot -- like port-way.

Neophytes

Uhm... what are they?

I find it annoying to have a word repeated that I don't understand.

Plot

Good, solid. Thoroughly enjoyable.

Kudos! This is the most entertaining piece I've seen on YWS.

Loved it,

Tiggy

User avatar
Dreamwalker
Review

Hey there :D. It's Dreamwalker here as asked, with a wonderful review that will hopefully help you out. Boy this piece is long! More fun for me :D.

As I do with most of my critiques, I start with the critique, then I go into different parts of the story like plot, grammer/punctuation, character developement, setting, and then overall. Hopefully this will help you out.

Critique

They were sleek and streamlined and shiny black, like a raven's, and stood in stark contrast to Irvin's own massive, snow-white, powerful ones.


This is a really long and descriptive way of saying, 'The raven-like wings were so beautiful, black a sleek, completely constasting from Irvin's own which just so happened to be snow-white and powerful."

This area feels cramped, like it's being overdescribed. Spread it out a bit over a series of sentences as I showed above, or cut back on the descritive words :D.

According to conventional folk wisdom, the courtship period between a white-wing and a black-wing might be a little rough, but they would soon settle into a long-lived, happy relationship.


From what I read, I wasnt sure at this point if Dr. Irvin was a male or female. This part points in the female direction, but I'm still disclosed on the idea till I get a 'she' said or something.

"How are you liking the Fortress, Dr. Dirinel?" said Dr. Irvin politely.


Asked instead of said would have been a better word choice.

All that was visible outside the port-way was the bleak white sky,


Write 'it' instead of the port-way, because port-way was starting to sound overly redundant.

"What stop?" said Irvin, though he knew quite well what Dirinel was talking about.


Asked again would have been a better word choice then said.

I've spent the better part of twenty years here, I've become quite used to it.


This sentence would make more sense if it was 'Over the better part of the last twenty years here, I've become quite used to it.'

oh, how cruel he was.

Sounds redundant. Dont use the word cruel in here but maybe... menacing? Or scheming?

A single mousy female technician with dull-brown sparrow wings was working on the machines--when the two scientists entered, she gave a polite nod in their direction.


I would find this more appealing if it were two sentences not separated by dashes.

shouted the girl, and finished with a stream of curses.


Instead of and, use who.

Suddenly, he glanced up, at the low roof of the lab (which Irvin's head almost scraped),


Second comma isnt needed and I'm not huge on the brackets in any literature. I'm sure you can find away around them.

He had instead wrapped his wings around his person and was gently running his hands up and down the pinions, stroking the feathers...


instead of person, I would have written, 'himself' for it would have flowed a little better.

Grammar/Punctuation

Both your grammar and punctuation in flawless. Very descriptive in how you tell things and all in all just completely wonderful vocabulary and way of telling things. I saw now fault in your punctuation whatsoever and your grammar was fantastic. Very good.

Character developement

There was a little bit on Dirinel being sort of thick-headed but curious. I would have liked to know a little more on the character or Dr. Irvin a little more for he seemed to be quite the broding type with his larger body mass and his infinite wisdom. Truly interesting, and I'm excited to learn more about your characters.

Setting

There wasnt a lot of descriptions of the setting and I would have liked a lot more then was given. Tell me about his office. Was it perfect? Organised to a tee? or maybe it was dehevelled cause his wings knock things over.. something like that. Give us intricate details so we can see exactly what you want us to see.

Plot

Your plot is beyond anything I have ever read before. These strange ideas that you came up with are both exciting and thrillingly quick-paced. There is no waiting to get right into the storyline. Very fun and exciting truly.

Overall

I loved it. I truly did. From the start to the finish it was quick-paced and interesting. The characters were lovable and yet not too perfect and the storyline is beyond anything I have ever heard of. I love the use of such things being bad like apparently 'preening' in public is bad and stuff. Very neat. I like how this strange culture is coming out in your work already and it leaves me wanting more. I was glad this was long because it kept me wanting to read more from start to finish. Very, very good.

When you have anymore posted up, please PM me cause I would love to read more :D

From Dreams to Reality
~The.Dreamwalker

Hi!! Okay, this review might be a little rushed, because our internet is going to go down in about 15 minutes, so if I don’t get this done on time, I’ll come back and edit in more detail later. XD

Okay, wow. XD Why do you keep awing me? This is an awesome start, I can see how this would make a great first novel.

I think the depth of your world that you’ve built up, even in only a few pages worth of writing, it incredible. With just this first part of the first chapter, we already know about the science and technology of the world, about its social customs, about its greatest fears. And yet you managed to do it all without any infodumping—just slipping it in, perfectly neat, into dialogue and description. That’s… that’s really well done. I was impressed with how smoothly this chapter seemed to flow, it was a brilliant introduction—not too slow, but not forcing too much information on us at once.

I also already really like the developments you’ve done between the characters. Irvin and Dirinel have an interesting dynamic, and I really want to know more about both of them. I think your characterization technique—the letting two character’s personalities bounce off each other, and such—works amazingly well in your stories.

For critique, I really only have a few small prose-y things to say:

"Turns out a great number of excellent scientists, almost all who head for the Fortress...


I think “almost all of whom” would read more clearly.

free of the terrible heavy scars that, along with their cut-off wings


I don’t really think this line needs the “their” in it.

Alright! That was, basically, the fastest review I’ve ever written, so let me know if you want me to go back and put some more detail into it. XD This is a great beginning, I’ll go on to part 2 as soon as possible!

User avatar
Syte
Review
Syte wrote a review · Sat Apr 25, 2009 2:40 am

I really enjoyed this, and I'll be looking for the next chapter. I believe that you did a lot of things right, and as they, we're all our worst critic. If you think you can make it better, than go ahead and do so. I thinkk I'm gonna read the other chapters if I don't inadvertently decide to stop attending this site.

This is just a small thing, but I like the fact that people have opinions about "preening in public". You made the world a bit more real with that small detail.

Also, the dialogue is vivid, which I just love.

User avatar
afeefah
Comment

Hi. This was really interesting and it pulled me into it straight away. i agree with what you said about Dr. Irvin being...slightly weird but it does catch your attention. i can't wait for more!

User avatar
Cotton
Review
Cotton wrote a review · Thu Apr 23, 2009 7:52 pm

Hi! I really enjoyed reading this. I think the idea is really fantastic - and even though the idea of people with wings is not entirely original on its own, the way you've used it is fantastic and makes the story unique. I love the touch with the human (as we know it) girl being the oddball - really liked that. The idea of the Fortress could be important later on, especially as that is where they are keeping this specimen, on a lonesome island surrounded by rough seas? Wow. I'd love to visit that place!
I agree with what has been said about Dr. Irvin - he seems a bit forward and focused on this new character, but I guess that's understandable - he's nearly all alone in this watchtower/fortress place, so some good-looking company must be tempting! Even so, it is a little weird.
A couple of grammary, spellingy points:

Suppressing a mirthful chuckle over the ignorance of the University scientists, Irvin instead decided to completely, and cruelly, break down everything Dirinel had believed about parallel universes...oh, how cruel he was.

You split your infinitive there: "to" and "break down" should be together... think on that.

There was another one, but I can't remember where it was! Sorry to be so unhelpful, but there was a verb ending that didn't correspond with the subject. Sorry.
Other than that, I thought this was fantastic! Definitely worth pursuing!

Wow this was really good. Please keep writing more, because I really want to know what happens next! I couldn't find anything wrong so far as spelling and grammar and all that, so yay! And I would have to agree about making Dr. Irvin a little less creepy. As I was reading it I was kind of like, "Um, okayyyyyy, what's his problem?" But other than that amazing job! Gold star for you!



Life is a banana peel and I am the fool who dared to tread on it.
— looseleaf