It was a pretty good day in New York. The sun was shining and not a cloud was to be seen, but it was a whole different scene in the New York subway. The air was musty, graffiti on the walls and the artificial light hurts your eyes after working here all day. Working as a train officer was tough but it was a fun. We were going through the carriages, just my partner Jack and I, handing out fines to people who didn’t pay for a ticket or to anyone doing the wrong thing. I enjoyed my job and didn’t want to leave it. It was getting near to the end of the day and I was getting a little tired and less patient for people explaining there stories as to why they didn’t have a ticket. Last carriage of the day, the very end one, furthest away from the front. This was a boost to my not so great end to the day. This was because this carriage had become my favorite over the many years as every couple of days, anywhere from a week to two days, a man would come and sleep on the train. He called himself God. I asked him many times to prove it to me, but he always said, “next time”. Of course I didn’t believe him, so by law I had to ask him to leave the train. He always did so peacefully without any resentment. He always said “one day you will let me stay on this train” and I would always respond with “only when you prove your God” laughing as I watched the man in tattered clothes and long matted white hair and beard. Now that I think of it, he does resemble what I believe God to look like.
“Hello God, How are you today” I say walking up to him smiling and putting my hand out to shake.
“Hello Mr. Smith, I’m good today” he said, his voice raspy. He shakes my hand as he sat upright, rather then his normal slouched position in the corner, with his hat of many holes, pulled over his face.
“Is today the day you finally show me you’re God?” I ask smiling, expecting him to say “next time” like he always does.
“Why yes, yes it is,” he says, smiling and looking pleased with himself.
I cross my arms, grinning and seeing what the man that calls himself God has to show me “Ok, prove it. Show me your God.”
“Of course give me a moment” he says and reaches into his bag, pulling out a small branch, with a single brown withered leaf on it.
I stood there waiting for three seconds, confused, just about to open my mouth, but I was quickly cut off when all of a sudden, I was somewhere else. Where was my Jack? It was just God and I standing in the middle of nowhere. We were on a vast flat landscape with mountains in the distance, very far away. It was hot, very hot, my palms were sweating and I could smell the natural scents of the wild. The long grass was dry and brittle, scratching my legs as it waved in the arid wind. The air was drying out my mouth and it already tasted like the air I could smell, musty and strange. I turned around in a full 360, my mouth wide, unbelieving what just happened, as I spin, an elephant arises right in front of my eyes, Large grey and smelly. He stares at me for a second, his pupils staring straight at me. Poof. It disappears just as quickly as it appeared and in its place is a lion. I am too stunned, scared, and many other emotions that are swirling around my mind. I stay in place as it gets on its hunches ready to pounce. Its muscles bulge in its short for and its mane is large, just like an alpha lion would be. It leaps, its muscles rippling and its claws razor sharp about to slice at my neck and without a doubt killed me. But just before it reaches me, like the elephant it disappears and in its place is a meerkat, in mid air carrying the momentum of the lion, it lands on my shoulder and I turn around to face God, the meerkats claws digging into my shoulder as I spin around fast. And in the rush and confusion of emotions and thoughts and what I should do, all I can manage in a high pitched strangled gasp. “…How?”
“Well I'm God, like I said the last four months.” He said this, while seeming rather pleased with himself and clicking his fingers and the meerkat is not perched on my shoulder any more, my skin red for where its claws dug into me“do you need me to prove it further?”
I stand there stunned, hardly believing what is happening. Am I in a dream? Thinking that this was the only reasonable answer I reply to him. “Is that all? Show me your best”
God smiles wickedly and lifts his hand slowly, bringing his fingers into a position where he can click them. I stare at him, waiting what is about to happen. He clicks. Nothing happens, I just continue staring at him.
“Well turn around then” he says still grinning, and as I do I am struck, speechless and unable to comprehend what I am seeing. In the middle of what seems to be Africa, A large Lake, a very large lake, about 500 meters to the other side, is in front of me. The sand surrounding it is white and reflects the sun much like a tropical islands sand in the Bahamas would, The water is clear and blue. I can see the sand at the bottom, and in the sand is coral, and fish. Pinks and greens and blues flash in and out of the coral. Its so vibrant, it doesn’t seem like it belongs here in the middle of wherever I am. The air tastes salty, this is especially weird, I cant see any large bodies of water in any direction I look, it must be coming from the water, I kneel down and place my hands in the water and cup it into my mouth. I spit it out, yup, that’s salt water for sure. But the biggest surprise is the large island in the middle. I can hear exotic birds and bugs, making noise in the coconut and rainforest trees that cover the island. The waves gently lap at the sand and even from here I can see the crabs moving up and down the beach, in and out of there holes in the sand. The whole place looks so surreal and like it could have been here for hundreds of years, but, I just appeared here. I turn back around to face god, my mouth open, my mind scrambled. Again all I can manage.
“how?”
He doesn’t answer me, but instead twirls his finger to tell me to turn back around. I do. But the tropical island isn’t there anymore, it’s gone, replaced by musty dry air, and tall grass.
Behind me I hear “I told you I was God” and in the blink of an eye I'm back on the train, sitting where God had been sitting before he did, well whatever that was.
“Yo, Smithy, you all right there?” my partner asks, his face as confused as mine must look.
“What, oh um yeah fine, how long was I gone?” I ask sweating
“A few seconds, you sort of sat down then blanked out” He said, laughing at me “What where you dreaming about buddy?” he asks me jokingly.
Through all the confusion I do believe that what I saw was real. “I think I saw God.”
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hi there! Noelle here for a Review Day review!
Okay, through my best efforts I will refrain from letting the religious side of me come into this review.
First of all, I noticed that half of the time you used the word you're when it was needed, but the other times when you needed to use the word you're, you used the word your. Make sense? That sentence looks a little confusing when I read it over again. Just be careful with using the right form of the word 'your'.
I think your story is great. I was very intrigued by the title and you definitely did not let me down. Characterization was great. Even in a short story, you did a good job making sure the characters were developed. I could really relate with the main character. Here he is, working at this subway every day, and then stumbles upon a man who claims he's God. And of course, the main character being a human, he doubts and needs proof. I feel like I really understand him and can relate to someone like that.
One thing I have to say is that I don't understand the reason you mentioned this man's partner Jake. Jake doesn't really seem to have much of a place in the story. He seems like just another name.
Your imagery is great as well. When you were describing the scenes that "God" created, I could see it all very vividly. Great job with that!
Keep writing!
**Noelle**
Writing a good short story is no mean feat; the length indicated in the name belies its true nature. In fact, for a short story to be considered "good", seven basic components must be taken into account: plot, structure, setting, character, point of view, style, theme and intention.
The introduction is satisfactory. Attention is paid to properly describing the setting in which the tale is to take place, and the characters are also properly introduced; whilst stereotypes are present, it is not without its function, and the protagonist is described in such a way that both he and his actions are believable and not too exaggerated, nor too generalised.
I can appreciate the use of the first person narration as this is indeed rather personal. The developement of the plot is logical and the structure coherent, though perhaps the paragraph length and structure should be revised, as they range from appropriately short to extremely long.
Most unfortunately, several inexcusable errors are present, such as the usage of the words "there", "your" and "its" when "their", "you're" and "it's" are meant. The reaction to mistakes such as these are harsh, but rightly so: they are the most common of errors and it is shameful to encounter them in anything but the most amateurish of works. If an author wishes to distinguish him or herself as a professional writer, this most basic understanding of grammar must first be reached, for the misuse of such terms is an indication of ignorance as to the true meaning of words, and therefore the true meaning of the English language.
Finally, the imagery used in the telling of this story is adequate, if a little bland. More attention should be paid to the detail of the descriptions, and the sentence structure also requires more variety. The title is fitting, as it is not immediately clear why it was chosen, but this is resolved in the conclusion.
I believe this short story has been successfully written, as its aim of making the readers contemplate the events therein has been achieved. "Homeless God" receives only one and a half stars however, because, as mentioned in one of the above paragraphs, the author lacks elementary knowledge considering contractions and possessive pronouns - a lack which may earn much contempt in literary circles. Some "brushing up" is therefore in order.
Hi,
The story was very interesting, and I love the ending.
But a few nitpicks.
Their needs to be a space between *me* and *"do* And I think *do* should be capitalized, because it is the beginning of a sentence.
In my opinion *A large Lake,* isn't needed there. And if you keep it there *A* it should not be capitalized.
Keep on writing.
Raven,
Thanks very much Raven. I really appreciate this. I knew I had to work on it re: spelling and syntax but thought if I didn't put it on, I'd never do it. Thanks again!
Hi

You go me hooked, this was interesting, also the work was not what I expected of it if that makes sense. It was weirkdly informative in a dreamlike sense. Especially this:
'I cross my arms, grinning and seeing what the man that calls himself God has to show me “Ok, prove it. Show me your God.”'
I have a big criticism to pick about your big paragraphs. They really are enormous, look:
'It was a pretty good day in New York. The sun was shining and not a cloud was to be seen, but it was a whole different scene in the New York subway. The air was musty, graffiti on the walls and the artificial light hurts your eyes after working here all day. Working as a train officer was tough but it was a fun. We were going through the carriages, just my partner Jack and I, handing out fines to people who didn’t pay for a ticket or to anyone doing the wrong thing. I enjoyed my job and didn’t want to leave it. It was getting near to the end of the day and I was getting a little tired and less patient for people explaining there stories as to why they didn’t have a ticket. Last carriage of the day, the very end one, furthest away from the front. This was a boost to my not so great end to the day. This was because this carriage had become my favorite over the many years as every couple of days, anywhere from a week to two days, a man would come and sleep on the train. He called himself God. I asked him many times to prove it to me, but he always said, “next time”. Of course I didn’t believe him, so by law I had to ask him to leave the train. He always did so peacefully without any resentment. He always said “one day you will let me stay on this train” and I would always respond with “only when you prove your God” laughing as I watched the man in tattered clothes and long matted white hair and beard. Now that I think of it, he does resemble what I believe God to look like.'
LOL. Huge right? This seriously needs to be broken down. So get on that. Otherwise...
'“how?”' Little nitpick: that should be a capital 'h'
But ya know.
I really like this and you seem like a really intelligent writer.
Thanks Emeraldeyes. Very appreciated.
Anytime
Anytime
Anytime