Published October 9, 2010
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hi Babz, here to review like I promised. I hope I help, and if you've got any questions contact me through PM or the chatroom. I will be more than willing to answer.
I would put a comma in here, otherwise the line seems long and rushed. Also, to give more affect to your opening line, I would seperate this from the subsequent sentences. It's quite a good hook, but it loses its purpose if you squeeze it into a large, overbearing paragraph.
I quite liked this line, the comparison is interesting. However, I'm sure you could find a better synonym for 'freakish.' It made the line seem somewhat childish. Also... a snake and an octupus aren't very visually alike, so the comparison doesn't seem to fit.
The sentence was a little choppy. These corrections should fix it. Also, what daily vigils? Elaborate. I'm assuming it's his habitual hiding in the darkness, but this is not made clear until much later on.
'Twilight' seems redundant here. When I read it, I was left wondering why the word was there. How about 'drifted in and out of a waking, fitful sleep'?
Either seperate this line as a new sentence, or cut it our altogether. It's a fairly bland description of his surroundings, so at best you could improve and ellaborate. What ever you do, make it seperate after the 'often.' The first half of the sentence is unrelated to the next, and read like broken, incomplete thoughts.
Also, the punctuation around uncle should be inverted commas ('') and not speech marks (" ") . As uncle is a quote, inverted commas should be used.
Same thing about the inverted commas as well. Also, I adored this line. Very nice.
Ramble alert. This sentence lasts far too long. I know you were probably trying to create suspense, but long sentences created exactly the opposite effect. Short, staccato sentencing is more what you're looking for.
Overall Impression: Well, it took a few reads to fully understand, and I'm not exactly a fan of reading cannibalism. However, you had some very cleverly written sentences and I'll praise you for that. No spelling or grammar mistakes either, which is very good.
Things to Improve On: Your use of commas. Be careful of when and where to put them in. If it helps, read the sentence out loud and insert a comma where you take a natural pause. Also, try not to make sentences so long. This encourages readers to skim, and they may miss something important and not comprehend what is going on.
We also got a very minimalist description of our MC's surroundings. Don't allow your story to float in an empty space of nothingness, get some description in there! I know you're perfectly capable, because some of the description we got was very nice.
Okay Babz, hope this helped, keep writing!
-Moo