Working on a new draft.
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Looove it!
It is so imaginative, very unique, and I love the characters. I've got a couple nitpicks that haven't been covered yet, and then I will do an overview on things like characters, setting, plot, and the like. Corrections will be in red.
I really like this description.I thought this part very imaginative.
This has already been corrected by one of the other reviewers, but I just felt like putting in my two cents. First of all, this is an info dump, which is very naughty. I also find it interesting that you gave such a detailed description of the ringleader but kind of skimmed over the other characters. Please, get rid of the exclamation points.
While your dialouge does flow beautifully, if you don't start a new paragraph everytime someone new begins to speak, it becomes very confusing.
For the most part just a few spelling and grammatical errors in this paragraph. Don't worry, I struggle with where to put the proper commas too. The easiest way to figure out where a comma is needed is to read your piece out loud. Wherever you naturally pause, that is where you should put a comma. Also, you have all of the characters names capitalized, but you don't need the the before their name to be capitalized.
I love the part about her fingernails, great visual. You don't need the apostrophe at the end of the sentence.
I'm not sure far is the proper word to use here. Perhaps great?
I think the last sentence would sound better if it were reworded to say something like: They hastily began to whistle, as if they had not been spying.
I am wondering if you really need this many Imagineers? It seems to me that the Ringleader, the Doll, and the Pirate all play important roles. The other characters feel like they are just there to be filler. Sure, you need some background characters to balance out the personalities of the other three. But don't overwhelm us. Perhaps you could keep two or three of the other characters and cut the rest?
This confused me since the Ringleader had just asked for suggestions for prizes, not for another suggestion for a competition. If you still want to keep this part, move it up in the story.
I think you meant scribbled. Even if you didn't, this word works much better.
While your commas are in the proper place, or at least I think they are, this is a horribly awkward sentence when you read it out loud. It might do better if your reworded it to say something like: The Pirate winked and somersaulted backwards, over the balcony, landing safely on her high heeled boots.
So the sentence where the moon is talking to the Imagineers was worded rather oddly. Perhaps you could have it say: The Moon was talking to the Sun, but then greeted the Harlequins, saying... Also, the last sentence I'd reword it to say: who was crying glitter tears.
Characters: I've already covered this. Pretty much you have three characters who are wonderfully developed and then you have eight or so background characters, who seem to add nothing to the story. Like I said, I'd cut it down a bit. Also, and this is just me, but I kind of wish you'd give your characters actual names instead of titles. But, that is completely up to you.
Setting: You do a great job of describing the setting in the beginning, but then when the Imagineers are holding their meeting, you do very little description of their meeting place. I'd imagine it being someplace as fantastic as the people residing there. However, you didn't show us this. Remember that when you describe a setting to use as many of the senses as you can. Besides what the room looks like, what does it smell like? What textures are there to feel or what temperature is the setting? What can one hear in this place? Just make sure that you work these descriptions of the setting in with the dialouge so that there isn't another info dump.
Plot: Currently the plot is about a competition to be held by the Harlequin Imagineers? It seems weak, to be honest, but I'm sure you've got some interesting plot twists up your sleeve. So far you've been able to draw me into your whimsical world and I am curious as to what the Pirate wrote down on that piece of paper. I'm very excited to see where you go with this.
Feel free to PM me if you have any questions and I'd love it if you'd PM me when you post the next chapter.
Thus far, I'm hooked! I love it! It's unique, WAY original, and totally captivating. I love your characters, and I think my favorite is The Pirate!
There are only a few things wrong that I can see. One, is that each character should get his/her own paragraph whenever they speak. You jumble several up together, which makes things slightly confusing. I'll admit that I did that at first, but it was the first thing I learned to correct, so it's turned into a big deal for me. Plus, it makes things less confusing.
Also, while you can use single quotes (') for dialogue, the double quotes (") are more common and easier to understand. So it's not vital you change that, it's merely a suggestion.
One last thing, I find I can barely picture your characters. For some reason, I kept picturing the Doll as a bunny, and your Pirate as sort of a female version of Jack Sparrow, but meaner and less quirky. Plus, your wide array of characters may prove difficult to use, and I wonder the significance of The Red Fox, The Husky, and a few others. Give us details and everything should work better!
I'm glad you didn't give away the Pirate's idea, because that was definately a huge hook. Also, I must say, I love how you made the Sun and Moon talk. It's like a little kid's fantasy land! I love it! Keep writing! And maybe PM me when you post chapter two? Thanks for the awesome read!
~Addict
Hi! I’m Narniafreak! Interesting beginning. It definitely caught my attention, and left me with questions of what Harlequin Park is all about. Good Job!
Okay first instead of using apostrophes when someone talks use quotations. Also, every time a different person talks make a new paragraph so readers don’t get confused [[like I did a few times]] on who is talking.
There’s a small bit of an info dump at the beginning that could be changed, but I think it’d be alright if you left it how it is.
You use conjunctions [and, but, or, yet etc.] at the beginning of a lot of your sentences. Technically, those are incorrect, so you might want to change a few.
Here’s a few things I found that might need changed.
You use the word “thing[s]” twice in a row and can get repetitive so you might want to change that.
Again, you use the word “holidays” a lot.
I’m pretty sure you don’t need all the exclamation points after each sentence of description. Also, when describing characters don’t give us readers a big info dump about them, slip descriptions throughout the story, with actions and what others think, etc.
None of the other characters were startled?
This isn’t a mistake, but I really like the fingernail color changing. That’s pretty cool.
I think the “to” after risk should be a “too”
Since “The Handsome Women” is a ship, it’s should be in italics.
Anyways, this is a good start on a great fantasy. The different things like the fingernails, the doll crying glitter, those are pretty cool. Hope I helped! =]
-Narniafreak!