Cogs that are turning too fast to keep up
A treacherous hand reaches long
The wider the void then the wider the grip
Here is where I finally belong
Caverns to protect from goblins and ghosts
Shying away from the song
Trigger the reflex and gag for your life
Much to everyone's despair
Destiny decays before it's too late
Heart muscles that bend and tear
The only memory of you
Combines blood stains with your hair
A river that flows on the edge of the street
Foundations that are set ablaze
Moments too intimate to even tell
I sit in my chair with a gaze
Staring at mirrors till the cows come home
I've gotten so miserable these days
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
ED here, sorry if this is terribly harsh (because I feel that it is). It is ten at night and I can't type to save my life.
Eh? Ao=blue ki=spirit gahara=I have no idea... Sekigahara? (That's what I thought of first.) Google said it meant "the belly"
"Blue spirit of the belly" ...okay. And how does that relate to the song? And why is it Japanese?
If your song had Japanese words or imagery in there, then I could understand the title. But right now it sticks out and is rather odd. Just like in other types of poetry, the title should perfectly encapsulate and evoke the mood of the poem itself. If the title doesn't fit, something is going to seem off and distracting to your reader.
That aside... (It was the first thing that caught my attention.)
So this speaks of a clock, yes? That second line is awkward... I obviously don't know the melody (if there is one) but do try and make things flow more smoothly. "A treacherous hand reaches down" or something. (Also, "treacherous" is vulgar in Japanese... I'm not sure why my mind is still stuck in that mode. But FYI in case there was ever the remote chance that you were going to translate this. heh. :p )
Also rather murky. The wider the grip of what? My advice here is don't try to be cryptic... because then it will be obvious that you are trying to be cryptic. Maybe "gap?" Perhaps you're trying to set up an expectation of how a phrase will end with the listener/reader, and then reverse that? (It's that one technique... I forget the name.) Well that's all well and good, but sometimes clarity is best. Try for that "crypticness" (if that's what you were going for) without being clunky.
So you didn’t rhyme up to this point and now we switch to limericks? Well, it works here, but is anachronistic. I think this would be better if you chose more vivid, original imagery here than going with a simplistic rhyme. My mind is brimming with ideas, I know you can make this 10x better. Right now, I can't help but feel that it lacks impact.
Probably my favorite line. I love this for some reason. Here is where the phrasal destruction of a reader's expectation actually works quite well. "trigger the reflex" sounds familiar, and yet not. "Gag... for your life" not something you usually do "for your life." I think this works great here.
Back to the rhymes. At first I thought that there are too many syllables for "combines bloodstains with your hair" to fit fluidly with "heart muscles that bend and tear" and "much to everyone's despair." Turns out they both have seven. Well... nice work. Obviously I can't count. heh. That being said, something doesn't fit here like it should. Something seems choppy, unnatural, out of place. Maybe it's the counted syllables. It seemed contrived to me. (Especially since you have a triplet here and couplets everywhere else.) It just stuck out.
I would recommend taking "that" out of both phrases. I think it would sound stronger. Turns them into verbs instead of recipients of a verb.
"intimate" and "cows," paired together, do not make a good image. And even tell what? And how do you sit with a gaze? Refer to my earlier notes on crypticness and betraying expectations. While you can certainly do both here, I don't really think it's working as is in this section here.
Noooo! Cliché! And you were doing so well! Well, I don't know.... it seemed like a rather bland and cliché to end this thing to me. Maybe it just wasn't what I expected. (heh.) I found it disappointing. A rapid dissipation of suspense and tension with no lasting impression.
Overall:
Well, I think that this could be made a lot better than it is right now. It's good right now, but it doesn't seem to stand on its own. It doesn't stand out. It seems a bit bland. How to solve that? Well, everyone tells me that it's imagery... but you have a ton of imagery in here, and hidden meaning. So I guess I would suggest making sure that you pick the RIGHT imagery, and that your hidden meanings aren't so hidden that the reader can't decipher them. Try to make this flow more, tie in the rhyming to the first part of this. Maybe making the tone "off-beat" was your intention. That's fine. I'm not personally in good when it comes to quirky stuff, but that doesn't mean nothing should be unusual. Just make sure the oddity of it all is still smooth and consistent, it needs to work contextually.
Hope that could help some,
~ED
Very emotional. An amazing piece. I enjoyed the occasional rhymes, that due to not being constant, created a very interesting effect. It had a good rhythm, which is important as you said that this was rather a lyrical than a poetic piece.
'Trigger the reflex and gag for your life
Much to everyone's despair
Destiny decays before it's too late
Heart muscles that bend and tear
The only memory of you
Combines blood stains with your hair'
This is definitely my favourite part of the piece. The last line really woke me up and brought my attention to the whole theme and brought the song to life.
The whole song conveys a lot of emotion, even though it would take longer to interpret. I enjoyed how it isn't ordinary lyrics that are boring and a bit too easy to relate to.
The only slight problem that I have with the song is that it ends so abruptly. It was unexpected, which in some cases can be a positive thing and in some cases a negative. In this case, for my style, it is negative. I would have liked for it to have been a bit longer and maybe end in a slightly different way. But that is just my opinion, and I suppose that you even have an instrumental pause or something that would initially change my whole opinion on what I mentioned.
Overall, the song was very emotional, and interesting. It is definitely no ordinary, monotonous, boring piece. Well Done!!! Keep on writing!!!
-K
I really like your words, they sound nice together, but thats as far as I can say, since I don't understand any of it XD
Asking for nitpicks is going to set grammar Nazi's alight. You don't have any punctuation and I think you know it.
Despite my lack of understanding, which is most likely the fault of my own brain's laziness to try to comprehend there are several lines I like and some I have a suggestion on. For example
when I read this line:
I first read it as "Combs bloodstains with your hair" And I thought it was really good imagery but then I noticed it was combined. I think it would be cooler if it was "Combs bloodstains into your hair" and it says the same thing while adding an extra hair metaphor and giving it a physical action rather than a less so specific action.
I like your rhyming because its subtle, not blatant like one of those fun and jumpy poems, which suits the image I get from your lone lines. If you could explain this whole poem to me I am sure I would enjoy it immensely.
Oh. I most definitely love to dissect. And nitpicking and carping is my job. Especially on your work.
)

Just kidding, you know I always love everything you write.
But- it is review day. I feel I owe you the honor of having your work dissected by me. Plus, now I have the title of Knight to add authority to all of my words. So, basically, what I say is law, right?
(The only problem with your poetry is that it's so hard to find things to critique.
That being said, after reading this three times, in the first stanza you wrote "here is where I finally belong" but then the poem ends with "I've gotten so miserable" So- if the narrator found somewhere to belong, why is he still miserable?
And this line: "Destiny decays before it's too late" it doesn't make sense to me. Wouldn't the decaying of destiny mean it's already too late? or wouldn't destiny decay once it was too late? not before? It seems like the two would come at the same time, not one and then the other. Does that make any sense?
yeah. I've always liked your poetry. Well, hopefully this wasn't just a bunch of words and will actually be at least a tiny bit helpful.
-Knight Cailey