This is a story I'm writing for a local short-story competition. Please criticize as much as possible!!
The Tears of Battle
I sprang into the fight, wildly swinging my sword with adrenaline before I regained control of myself. I reined myself under control and swung at a short man wearing the orange uniform of the Amerans. He turned and saw my sword coming at him, his surprised face told me he hadn’t been ready for my attack. Too bad for him. My sword went through of his chest. He looked down and watched blood seep out of him, and then he fell, dead.
I ran on, slicing and jabbing people, collecting wounds of my own.
Blood soaked through my sleeve from a deep cut on my arm as I looked around for another opponent and saw my friend, Jakob, lying face up on the ground about 200 meters away.
“Jakob!” I cried.
“Ellis,” he murmured, “can you help me?”
I rushed over to him and inspected his wounds, a gouge in his belly and left thigh. He wasn’t going to make it.
Jakob saw the look on my face, “Goodbye Ell- look out!”
I twisted, jumping up from my crouched position. A man brought his sword down where my head had been seconds earlier. I thrust and he parried. Soon we were fighting in a blur of gleaming silver. I felt like I knew his every move and he knew mine, a perfect match of skill.
A few strands of my black hair fell into my eyes and the balance was over. He swooped down on me, I fell to the ground and his sword was at my neck. There was no crazy gleam of anger in his eyes, just the sad, weariness of war.
“I’m sorry.” he whispered and started to press the sword against my neck.
I couldn’t believe it. I was going to die here, on the battlefield. Nobody would give me a proper burial, I’d just join my mother and father in heaven.
A sword shot out of his chest.
The man fell next to me, dead.
His sword was still resting lightly on my neck. I carefully pushed it off and saw Alex looking down at me.
“You ok?” He asked, his ice blue eyes radiating concern.
“Yes, you were just in time. Thanks.” I pushed my hair back under my cap.
“You’re welcome.”
He held out his hand and pulled me up from the ground, I winced as my arm wound throbbed.
“Be careful.” He said.
“I know. You too.”
He ran back into the fight.
I ran back over to Jakob’s body.
“Jakob?” I whispered his name, knowing he wouldn’t answer.
I closed his eyes, put his sword in his sheath, and lay the sheath over his chest.
I couldn’t believe he’d just died. He had been 16, only a year younger than me.
He had been my friend.
Anger powered me as I dashed back into the battle. It was still raging uncontrollably.
I plunged into the fight. Killing, slashing, no mercy from me. People died all around me and I loved it, it was feeding my anger, suddenly I stopped. I was enjoying this? I must be a monster!
A sword flashed past my head and another man and I were engaged in a duel. This time I cut him down, but not before at least ten minutes had passed. I looked into his terrified eyes, whispered sorry and cut off his head. Then I heard a scream, more familiar than the rest.
Alex.
There he was, writhing on the ground only a hundred meters away from me. An Ameran was running away, his sword covered in blood.
“Alex!” I shrieked my blood freezing with dread.
I sprinted to him. Not Alex, please not Alex. Let him live, please. I kneeled down to him, pushing his sandy blond hair out of his eyes.
He looked up at me, squinting in the cold sunlight, “’Bye Ellis.”
“No, Alex!”
I ripped off my cap, letting my long black hair flow over my face. Blood ran into my eyes from a cut, making them sting.
“I’m not Ellis, I’m Elizabeth.”
Alex’s eyes widened, “I knew you were different.”
“Please don’t leave me Alex, you’re my best friend, we’ve been through everything.” I leaned over him, hugging his body trying to keep him with me.
“You’re a pretty girl Elizabeth.”
“I love you.” I leaned down and gently pushed my lips against his.
He smiled slowly, forgetting his pain for a moment.
Then he was gone.
“No!” I cried up at the sky, “No.”
The cold sun stared down at me mercilessly, mocking me. I sobbed, but nobody noticed, they just kept fighting and left me. I wondered why.
I hugged his still warm body once more then I stood up, barely anyone was left standing. People had been slaughtered here and it made me feel sick.
I twirled my sword.
I wasn’t allowed in this battle because I was a girl, but that didn’t mean I wasn’t going to stop this unfair slaughter. I’ll learn how to stop it one day, but until then I will continue to show them all; girls can also fight!
Points:
Time spent:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Good Job!
I find this story very interesting. I like the use of bright language, you really painted a picture with your words. But you repeated the word "sword" too much, you can use other words like blade. It was a very intense story full of action. Keep writing it was great.
I like the use of language here, although you could change some words around
It was really good, i read it to my little brother. I love the way it's a girl fighting, and not a boy
But i don't know i've heard something like it 
The Tears of Battle

I sprang into the fight, wildly swinging my sword with adrenaline #FF4000 ">before I regained control of myself. I reined myself under control (Repetition, probably try to compress.)and swung at a short man wearing the orange uniform of the Amerans. #FF4000 ">He turned and saw my sword coming at him, his surprised face told me he hadn’t been ready for my attack (change of tense, from present to past). Too bad for him. My sword went through of his chest.#FF4000 "> He looked down and watched blood seep out of him, and then he fell, dead. (Edit: He gasped in horror as his eyes fastened on the gaping, bubbling hole in his chest, out of which his blood was spurting. [Unless that is too much detail])
#FF4040 ">I ran on, slicing and jabbing people, collecting wounds of my own.
(She runs on while slicing and jabbing? Where is she going, and why are these people easier to take out?)
Blood soaked through my sleeve from a #40BF00 ">deep cut (a deep cut, and she only looks for another opponent? Usually, they would try to bandage it first.)on my arm as I looked around for another opponent and saw my friend, Jakob, lying face up on the ground about 200 meters away.
“Jakob!” I cried.
“Ellis,” he murmured, “can you help me?”
#FF4040 ">I rushed over to him (she rushes over to him in the middle of a battle, when there are obviously more enemies on the field?) and inspected his wounds, a gouge in his belly and left thigh. He wasn’t going to make it.
Jakob saw the look on my face, “Goodbye Ell- look out!”
I twisted, jumping up from my crouched position. A man brought his sword down where my head had been seconds earlier. I thrust and he parried. Soon we were fighting in a blur of gleaming silver. I felt like I knew his every move and he knew mine, a perfect match of skill.
A few strands of my black hair fell into my eyes and the balance was over. He swooped down on me, I fell to the ground and his sword was at my neck. There was no crazy gleam of anger in his eyes, just the sad, weariness of war.
“I’m sorry.” he whispered and started to press the sword against my neck.
I couldn’t believe it. I was going to die here, on the battlefield. Nobody would give me a proper burial, I’d just join my mother and father in heaven.
A sword shot out of his chest.
The man fell next to me, dead.
His sword was still resting lightly on my neck. I carefully pushed it off and saw Alex looking down at me.
“You ok?” He asked, his ice blue eyes radiating concern.
“Yes, you were just in time. Thanks.” I pushed my hair back under my cap.
“You’re welcome.”
He held out his hand and pulled me up from the ground, I winced as my arm wound throbbed.
“Be careful.” He said.
“I know. You too.”
He ran back into the fight.
I ran back over to Jakob’s body.
“Jakob?” I whispered his name, knowing he wouldn’t answer.
#FF4000 ">I closed his eyes, put his sword in his sheath, and lay the sheath over his chest. (she has enough time to do all that without being attacked?)
I couldn’t believe he’d just died. He had been 16, only a year younger than me.
He had been my friend.
Anger powered me as #FF4000 ">I dashed back into the battle (I thought she was already in the middle of the battlefield, so why would she need to DASH back into the battle?). #FF4040 ">It (what was, her anger or the battle?) was still raging uncontrollably.
I plunged into the fight. Killing, slashing, no mercy from me. People died all around me and I loved it, it was feeding my anger, suddenly I stopped. I was enjoying this? I must be a monster!
A sword flashed past my head and another man and I were engaged in a duel. This time I cut him down, but not before at least ten minutes had passed. I looked into his terrified eyes, whispered sorry and cut off his head. Then I heard a scream, more familiar than the rest.
Alex.
There he was, writhing on the ground only a hundred meters away from me. An Ameran was running away, his sword covered in blood.
“Alex!” I shrieked my blood freezing with dread.
I sprinted to him. Not Alex, please not Alex. Let him live, please. #FF4000 ">I kneeled down to him, pushing his sandy blond hair out of his eyes.
He looked up at me, squinting in the cold sunlight, “’Bye Ellis.”
“No, Alex!”
I ripped off my cap, letting my long black hair flow over my face. Blood ran into my eyes from a cut, making them sting.
“I’m not Ellis, I’m Elizabeth.”
Alex’s eyes widened, “I knew you were different.”
“Please don’t leave me Alex, you’re my best friend, we’ve been through everything.” I leaned over him, hugging his body trying to keep him with me.
“You’re a pretty girl Elizabeth.”
“I love you.” I leaned down and gently pushed my lips against his.
He smiled slowly, forgetting his pain for a moment.
Then he was gone.
“No!” I cried up at the sky, “No.”
The cold sun stared down at me mercilessly, mocking me. I sobbed, but nobody noticed, they just kept fighting and left me. I wondered why.
I hugged his still warm body once more then I stood up, barely anyone was left standing. People had been slaughtered here and it made me feel sick. (She has the time to do all this, when she barely talked to Jakob before she was attacked?)
I twirled my sword.
I wasn’t allowed in this battle because I was a girl, but that didn’t mean I wasn’t going to stop this unfair slaughter. I’ll learn how to stop it one day, but until then I will continue to show them all; girls can also fight!
Good idea, but I can see this is probably your first or second draft. Just keep editing and revising.
Watch the tenses. They're slippery characters, always trying to switch themselves around.
Grammar, plot and characterization are all good.
Hey, I'm rushed on time, but I really loved this story. You really know how to build suspense. Keep writing!
Ok, this was a good piece. A couple of things I want to say is that throughout the entire story you only described four things about your character. Gender, hair color, and her name. You didn't tell the reader what her personality is, why she's fighting, where she's fighting, etc. You just started writing assuming that the reader would know a lot of these things. Also I couldn't really feel the emotion behind the character because in many cases you told me not showed me for example when you said
You're telling me when you could show me and saying my eyes were on fire as the blood from one of my wounds trickled into them. I guess the main thing I'm trying to say is add more description, and show not tell. Other than that you used some great word choice and this was a good piece. I hoped this review helped
-lilgreendots
#FF0000 ">I stopped editing after a while, It was really good with a few minor ajustments, sorry I over edited at the start, as I read on it got better. I hope I helped, sorry for any of my own spelling mistakes
I’ve actually read another story on YWS about this. True the story was set in WWII and the girl dies in the end, but the resemblance is too much for my cliché-trained eyes.
Analyze what you’re trying to do here. Promote feminism? Good, work along that line. She should meet opposition to fighting in the army, but that would require some explanation before the battle-scene, maybe as part of her reminiscence.
I really don’t have much to say, since you’ve done an okay job on a terribly bad subject. Cheer up, though, since you’ve got some amount of talent…you just need to channel it towards a better subject.
Hey there!
I like this, especially the way you fitted so much drama and excitement into a fairly short story. A few small nitpicky things to polish up:
Towards the beginning the paragraphs are good, but as it goes on there's a new paragraph almost every line, even when there's no speech, which breaks up the story and really isn't necessary. For example,
This would be much better if it was all combined into one paragraph.
This should be 'would' and 'could' because you're writing in the past tense. Also, her reasoning doesn't make much sense to me. If nobody knows that she's a girl then who is she proving anything to except herself?
This should be, "Be careful," he said. For an explanation of dialogue punctuation, see this handy article.
Great paragraph! I love the description of the fight here.
Overall it was good, but I agree with the points that ultraviolet made. At the end the main character says that she wants to put an end to the fighting, but meanwhile she's willing to go around slaughtering just to prove that girls are just as good as boys? At the moment her attitude to the battle doesn't really seem add up: she wavers between being outraged at the battle and the death and enjoying the thrill of the battle. I think perhaps this would be more realistic, and more interesting as well, if you focused more on these two sides of her, and the conflict between them. That way she would come across as a more rounded character. It would me nice to see more of her feelings generally, actually. There's all this tragic death but not really much description of her emotion.
PM me if you have any questions or anything, and good luck with the contest!
Heya, Alzora!!! I've already torn this apart, and i like it how it is now, so yeah . . . Keep writing!
~Sar-sar~
I colored those words because you repeat them. This is just the first paragraph. Vary your words or we'll assume the rest is the same and will stop reading.
I'm not really in a nitpicky mood, so I won't tear this apart, but there are a few things you have problems with. For one, commas vs. semicolons. Here's an article that should help with that.
Another thing you need to work on is realism. First, we have a girl in battle but no one knows she's a girl. This might work, except that we have next to no backstory and the only bit of motivation we see is that she wants to prove that girls can fight too.
Next; you say she gets wounds. But not once does it seem like she's hurt; she just keeps slashing and bouncing around with her sword. She never once speaks of physical pain.
Finally, fighting. So, she has no problem going around killing people willy nilly but one or two people on her side get hurt and the world stops? She seems like an emotional hurricane, in that sense, but in all other senses she seems to be lacking.
Work on making this more realistic. Sorry if this is harsh.
loveness, ultraviolet <3