Published March 25, 2009
...
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hi, 200397! Sorry for the wait, I hope it's okay.
I think it should be he (or him?), or then you should change 'laughing' to 'laughter' and so on – only that would come out as a little awkward, so I recommend the he/him thing instead.
I'm wondering a little whether a 'look of absolute triumph' can be cool and/or calm. It sounds slightly contradictory, don't you think? =)
I think this means that they *walked* away, not moved as in "My family moved to USA when I was three". If so, maybe just clear that out.
Hm, a little awkward. Maybe add 'to' before 'think'? Or then just rephrase.
The sudden tense change is a bit in-your-face – though not completely incorrect – so I suggest you reword as "Already back then, Melissa was pretty and popular..." or something similar.
I think it should be either "Would you dance with me?" or "Shall we dance?"
****
Well, there were the nit-picks! I really liked this story, and I wish you good luck in the contest (if it's not been judged yet). The Tommy guy was a little random there, I think you should've explained who he was and what his relationship with Ellen was (was he a childhood friend, a lab partner or whatever), because now he just... appeared out of the blue, just to ask her to the dance.
I like your style of writing – it's somewhat light and easy to read, not suffocating at all. Just as I like it. =) I don't think you need fancy sentence elements and big words to have a good piece. This was such a pleasant read. Thanks for letting me!
Demeter
xxx
I absolutely love the beginning two paragraphs!!
This seems a bit redundant to me. People usually are disappointed when they're let down... and it seems a bit strange for a casual narration to use "one".It should be "principal".
That's a great line.
There's a tense change here. There might be other places too, but I wasn't paying attention. Haha, sorry.
This is perfect. I love how you described it making it seem as if our eyes are travelling up him slowly.
Wow. I really loved this. It was so sweet! Poor Tom, though. Haha. Sorry this review isn't that helpful, but I really really enjoyed this. Gret job.
Hello! This was a spontaneous review; I hadn't been planning on reviewing anything. But I really enjoyed your story and felt that I should put in my two cents! I apologize beforehand if I begin to ramble incoherently. It's 12 o'clock and I'm tired. But anyhow, moving on, yes?
I don't think this was... the best way to describe chlorine. Sure, it clears your sinuses, but do we really need to know this? You may want to find another way to get at what you're saying.
Silly mistake, no?
'He' should be lowercase.
Before, she was "Susanne" with an S, and now it's a Z.
The dialogue right here was a little confusing. I had to read it a few times over just to make sure who was saying what.
This bothers me because it's too... cliched. It might help if you gave us more details. What is this taste of him? What is this intoxicating smell?
Anyway, that's all I had to point out. Now for the actual writing. I really liked the way you crafted the story, with the present and then the memories. There were points that were a little awkward, but it was still well done. I liked it versus just summarizing what had happened in Ellen's past without much detail. A problem I noticed throughout the story were the tenses in which the story was told. Sometimes it was past, sometimes it was present. I think you need to read through the story aloud and take out all the misplaced tenses.
As for the characters, I though you did a very good job of getting nicely defined characters in so little words. It's easy to tell how Ellen feels about things, or how Derick feels about the situation. Their moods and personalities came out strong. Merissa the little jerk!
So this is my two cents worth! Happy writing,
-Holly
Hello! I shall be your reviewer today.
You put me on tenterhooks wondering if Ellen and Derick would get together in the end. I'm very glad they did though, they're both likable characters!
The first thought on my mind is this: Oh wow! That was superb! You described everything amazingly well, and I could see it all. The plot was very good as well. I didn't notice anything grammar-wise that needed correcting.
You did very well with you characters, too. They seemed to jump off the page which is a good thing! You did a good job with the animosity between Ellen and Melissa. I really wanted to strangle Melissa a few times!
All in all, I can't find anything bad to say or anything that's worth criticizing. Sorry if this review's not much help, but I'm not very good at review romantic fiction.
Anyway, if you have any questions PM me! Keep up the [s]good[/s] great work!
~SOUL~
Firstly, WOW. I reeeaaalllyyy liked this. It told the story, had an awsome plot and was well described, all round it was very good. Just a few things i picked out.
This should be Moved
This is all I could find now. But I will say one thing. When you go back in time to teh cafeteria, It annoyed me how it read like a biography. I'm guessing you didn't mean this.
Anyway. Well Done.