Hello again! Sorry for the wait but here is the final review, as requested
After reading this the first time I'm little confused about the time gap from the last chapter. So far, none of these chapters connect very well. It's like one exciting scene immediately to the next exciting scene with no transition connecting them. I want to know how we moved from the last chapter to this chapter. Where are we?
Here are my nitpicks:
Miles had once asked me why this was the only place I drew, it was the same picture always; with the religious edifice, the fence, the park and it's one resting place.
This sentence doesn't flow very well. Read it out loud once, do you hear it? "It was the same picture always" is what is throwing me I think and I don't think you need that part in there. You can replace the semi colon with a comma then too.
It was the scene that reminded me why I was with Miles in the first place; why his kidnapping and theft, with me as an accomplice didn't scare me.
I think where you have the semi colon you could just have a period and make this two sentences. Also, you need another comma after accomplice. I don't remember the word is for that type of phrase, but basically "with me as an accomplice" is like an addition to the sentence. You don't have to have it in there for the sentence to make sense so you have to put commas around it.
Which brought me back to here. The second theater in our old beaten school, Miles had told me to wait here. The second reason why I was sketching the old church again was it felt safe when I didn't. It seemed to calm me, at least temporarily. I had a lot a lot to feel worried about, last nights heist nearly got us both caught.
I would put the second reason immediately after the first for clarity and flow. Maybe mention where she is at the very start of this chapter when you're describing the setting.
Miles injections were supposed to work. They weren't supposed to remember three minutes before it entered there (their) blood stream. But for some reason, last nights victim had.
This is very confusing. The last thing you're talking about is the injections so the reader is going to assume that "they" is the injections, but it's the people taking the injections, right? I would clear that up.
"Quiet!" He glanced around the empty auditorium then shrugged, "You're overreacting. He saw a girl and the schools logo, the police can't hold down the whole student body. They will investigate an absent or truant girl." I folded the paper in my hand nervously.
This confused me too because I thought we were still talking about what happened last night but now we're talking about the plan today?
"Renee." He looked at me, his green eyes bore into mine. "No one will find us out. Then, after this all settles we can keep it up. Think of what we could gain. Just trust me." I looked down again as I began folding the picture into a paper airplane. This was another fear; Miles schemes. This was the first time we had cut it this close but I was bending under the guilt. The knowledge that my assistance helped in stealing, which hardly bothered me, but yesterday and Holly....
1. You need a comma after "then" because it's a preposition.
2. Keep what up?
3. New paragraph at "I looked down"
4. No semi colon in the 2nd underlined portion. You don't have two independent clauses there so use a comma.
5. Read the last sentence out loud. I'm confused. You need a conclusion to the first part of the sentence. "The knowledge that my assistance helped in stealing" what? makes her feel what?
"It's new, I couldn't sleep all last night so I stayed up working on it."
Period instead of a comma.
"if they die it will be there (their) own fault.
"Look on the bright side, if we survive the day I have something else for you." I glared and stood up, "Better than this?" I lifted up the case.
Are both Miles and Renee talking in this paragraph? If so, you know what to do
"I don't know what could be better than that." He said in a way that seemed sarcastic but I wasn't sure. "I think the right question to ask is, will you think it's better?" He paused as I touched the auditorium doors. "The answer to that question would be, yes" He finished, I pivoted on my heels.
This confused me too. Is he talking to himself or are they going back and forth? If it's the latter, you know what to do
1. The Characters - Lots of personality
I'm beginning to like these two characters more simply because I'm getting a better sense of their personality. You don't always need a lot of action in a scene like what you've been having, sometimes it's good to step back and have a scene that helps us get to know characters like this one. (As long as the scene continues to drive the plot forward).
I really like the contrast in personalities between them although I'm a little confused about why Renee joined up if she has such a weak stomach. She had to know what she was going to be getting into when she decided to do this at the beginning of the novel right? If she wasn't up for it, why did she join?
2. The Plot - Still a little confused
The plot is intriguing but I'm still confused about exactly what is going on. Don't info dump it all on me because that's boring to read so try to find some ways to insert important world-building information into the story so the reader knows more of what's happening. Do the characters have powers? How do they disguise themselves so well? What is their mission?
I think it might be interesting to see some of Renee's life outside of these missions like when she goes to school as cover. It could be a great way to get to know the characters better and leave the reader wondering when something else is going to happen, otherwise the story gets predictable.
Also, I'm not sure if all of the little plot points (like this drawing of hers) is important to the story and if I need to be remembering it. If it's not going to be important to the plot, I wouldn't spend as much time talking about it and making it seem like a big deal so you don't confuse anyone.
3. Spelling/Grammar - Getting better
There were some similar grammar errors to what I've already been seeing. Again, reading out loud really helps the editing process. But I didn't notice any spelling errors in this installment so kudos there!
I think you have a very intriguing idea here and you've got a great start, you just need a little more polish going ahead.
Please let me know if you have any questions or if something didn't make sense!
-Carly
Points: 32055
Reviews: 1162
Donate