Hey Mora! I've FINALLY got my butt over here to give you a review!
First of all I like this interesting Robin Hood-esque story. Especially because it feels like you're writing a fantasy style Robin Hood type tale and that is very exciting, because think of ALL the wonderful things Robin Hood could have done with MAGIC. But I don't know where exactly you're taking this, so we'll just have to see! ^_^
half carrying my brother's corpse as if he had merely been drinking too much ale.
A limp body is incredibly difficult to move, let alone lift and walk with- AKA carry. It doesn't matter how strong your character is- unless she's got like super-human strength, but if that were the case it might have been good to mention that.
So far I had felt nothing about my brother's inevitable death.
I agree with the reviewer before me; it's not very realistic that she has basically zero reaction to her brother dying. I mean, yes, she could be in shock, but to be in shock you tend to be in a bit more of a denial state and she's totally accepted the fact that her brother's dead- even before he was dead and was about to jump she was like "Welp, better go retrieve his body."- and not in a dry-humour kind of way. It's true, different people have different reactions to death, but there's generally some reaction upon seeing someone you love dead in such a brutal kind of way.
“The Crow thanks you, her feathers are her mourning clothes, and she refuses to leave her roost until the Raven rises once more.”
I like this ending, but I feel like it would have a stronger punch if there were a little less words. Or maybe it's just that it's confusing because the ending gives this kind of promise that the Raven will rise again, because of what the MC said- but we have no idea how that could even be possible as we have no idea what the laws of this universe are and if there's anything strong enough to bring someone back from the dead. I think we need a little more background into this world and what exactly it's all about. A way that you might be able to add a bit of that in is instead of starting out with the MC running, if you start off towards the beginning of the Crow and Raven's "rounds". If you have the two of them walking and talking I think there'd be a lot more opportunity to shed a little light on things- and there doesn't need to be much info at all, just enough to hint at stuff. If there is indeed stuff to hint at. Starting off with the MC and her brother together could also help us sympathise with the MC a little more, because we would have seen a glimpse into his personality and their relationship. As it is we know nothing about him and so, like the MC, we weren't at all remorseful when he died. Also it might give more potential emotions for your character to use when her brother dies. But that's just my thoughts! c:
The other thing I wanted to bring up is: how exactly do these two (teenagers?- I'm guessing perhaps) fight the law? We heard that they do fight the law, and somehow are successful, but how? Again, is magic on their side? If they're so good at fighting the law, how was one guy in a uniform able to stop the Raven? It doesn't quite make sense.
Anyway, I thought this was really interesting and I'm looking forward to seeing what you do next with it! Keep it up! C:
-Socks
Points: 0
Reviews: 494
Donate