Heya Kyllorac, pretzelsing here for another review of your work. I got to say that I am lovin and adoring every next chapter more and more <33
Let's begin,shall we?
The stream was smaller than John had been expecting, and it was a lot muddier too.
I was just wondering, out of curiosity, was the stream smaller in length or in width? I just wanted to know to imagine which one of the two. Also, shouldn't a stream be muddy?? I mean isn't that pretty normal?
Once he had a large enough pile, John gathered grasses, pulling clumps out by the roots, and made a sling from them.
Let's be realistic here, how in the world do you make a sling out of dry grass? Wouldn't the mud just fall right through? I mean, I really don't understand how that can hold and work for John.
Mud was surprisingly heavy.
Isn't it normal and doesn't everyone know that mud is heavy I mean I think John should have realized that maybe before he took on the job of doing this...
“You cannot expect everyone to tell you everything.”
This story was kind of off with the story because if the first place the only one who told him this was the thoughtful face. So not "everyone was telling John everything" that just isn't true. If I recall correctly,then only one of the faces told this to John.
Okay so now this is a more general thing, but I counted that the faces said "sorry" five different times(and I think even five different faces) and that was getting repetitive and boring. In fact I kind of skimmed/skipped over it. What you could do it just get one "spokesman" of the group and just that one "rock face" tell John that they are very very sorry. There is no need for that much emphasis and repetition, because every reader gets your point.
“Yes. Ahem. I do apologize for not explaining the situation in full. I assumed that, as you were an intelligent young man, you would be aware of such a basic property of streambeds—”
Umm, did you notice what one of the rocks here is doing: still insulting John. Is that why the excited rock face had to interrupt? Because honestly John could have taken that quote as an offensive. I assumed that you were an intelligent young man, you would be aware..."
Spelling it out, that is practically the same thing as saying. "Oh yeah, I thought that you were smart,but if you were than you should have know this or that."
If someone said that to me or you how would me/you feel?
“Attheleast, child, you are more considerate than most.”
One minor comment is that I would strikeout "the" before least to make this sentence flow better and more smoothly.
Oh I got to say that the last sentence is great! It's like get-down-to-business and do your part,John. I wonder how organized the stones will go for him (I guess that I will just have to find out). Also I personally think that before John agrees to actually help these rocks then he must have at least a moment of hesitation or a moment of thinking. This is a decision that could prolong his stay and make him work hard you know. But at least he had the promise of the rocks to never be mean to him again. I wouldn't be so quick as to trust them though, since they insulted him at least five plus times(even after they said sorry >.<)
Why does John care about he mud and his shoes? Isn't he just a little kid? And from my experience little kids love playing and rolling around in mud, swimming in streams, and throwing grass. Also his worry about his father's reaction shows that he is actually pretty mature and thinks about the consequences of his actions(even if it was very accidental)c:
I am loving this kid John more and more with every chapter <3
I am still having trouble with the dialogue thing, which rock is talking when? Now I know that isn't really important, but it does kind of express who they are in a sense. I'm not telling you to put who said what by every quotation,but maybe just make it a little bit more clear and easier to follow by tagging them.
Anyways, that's it from me. If you have any questions/comments, you can reply below.I hope that this review truly helped improve your writing.
KEEP ON WRITING!
Points: 37216
Reviews: 346
Donate