Timmy here!
I will do my best to make this a good review, but Noelle took a lot of what I would say, so let's hope I can make this a somewhat decent review. It may turn out to be rather short.
Thoughts bloomed from her mind, if she could just get through this round she’d be on a clear road towards the final.
At best, these sentences are very loosely connected to each other, and the conjunction appears to be missing... or just isn't as apparent as it should. As it looks right now, I think you should either split it up into two different sentences, beginning at mind, or go and insert a neat conjunction in there to make it flow nicer.
he was an absolute wreck. His knees chattering, shoulders hunched, with a head as shiny as my mother’s china set.
This seemed like you almost changed genders with your character. Either that, or you threw in a character we knew nothing about. The first sentence of the paragraph talks about a she, and then the same paragraph switches over to a he - like it's the same person we're talking about, but a different gender. So perhaps it just go a little messed up there?
audience a flash if that endearing smile
technical: flash of
“Loyalty, spelt l-o-y-a-l-t-y”
Why never any periods or anything after these dialogue sentences? They have endings, too, ya know. You occasionally throw in a exclamation mark, but other than that, they are mostly empty of sentence endings.
As she walked off stage into the wings Rosie smiled,
As this sentence stands, you need a comma after wing to make the sentence flow correctly... but doing that would put two commas very close to each other, so my suggestion would be to do this: Rosie smiled as she walked off stage into the wings - eliminating the need for a comma, and making the sentence flow purdily through.
Just as she felt friendly hands on her back her heart dropped.
Comma after back.
Her heart pounded so hard it ripped out of her chest.
Not literally, right? O_o The way you word things makes it seem as though that is exactly what happened.
The biggest nitpick I think I would have to this story is that I was confused as to who the narrator, the main character of the story was until I reached about the middle, and I thought you were skipping around to different peoples POV the entire time, since you didn't really tell us who was the main character. You hinted in small ways, of course, but during the spelling bee, there was so many character skipping about, it was difficult to focus on Rosie and acknowledge that, hey! This is the girl I need to see this from! I think you need to give us a little bit more of her name in the beginning, so that we can see it from her. Especially in the beginning, I think. So look at the first few sentences, or rather, the first few paragraphs. You didn't state who the main character was, or who we could connect his character's voice to until we got to the part where she was called to the stage, and then we learn her name. So I think you should go and give her a name in the first sentence, and remind us about that in there by giving us a reminder to her name all the time. So just throw in her name occasionally during your narration of the story, and it will remind us more often who the character is. So the beginning. Tell us it's Rosie that is sitting there being nervous about being called to the stage, and then you will have that problem all smoothed out. Just introduce us to the character more, and let us know who she is, and then start off with the story. In short, make it more personal straight off.
All in all, I think you did a wonderful job on the writing prompt, and it was certainly an inventive and very brilliant story. I loved the change of the character, or rather the change of how we saw her, and everything just worked out just perfect. <3 I loved the way you narrated everything, and how you kept us coming back to her feelings and how she saw things was wonderful.
Amazing job, and as always, continue pecking away at the keyboard.
~Darth Timmyjake
Points: 13831
Reviews: 1007
Donate