(Please critique! If anything doesn't make sense, or needs more detail, just say so.)
The Writer
By Corax Corvus
Part 1: The Poet
And he jumped
He leapt
Straight off the edge
Just to feel what it meant to fear death
And as he fell down
And came close to the ground
It felt like…
"It felt like…” The girl covered her eyes with her hand and sighed. “What did it feel like? Is there a word? I don’t know the word. I need a word. Someone give me a word.” I looked up at the girl. She sat with her legs crossed in a low branch of the tree that my friends and I ate lunch under every day. Dark hair hung in front of her face as she sat in her concentrating position, hands covering her eyes. It was the middle of the school year, and she had never sat here before. I didn’t even think she had even talked to us before.
“Uh, sorry,” I said to her uncomfortably. “What is your name again?”
“Valerie,” she told me without looking up from her notebook. “Does anyone have a word?”
Kim, one of my friends, looked up at her with a puzzled expression. “I thought your name was Jane.”
The girl took her hand off her eyes, but her head remained rested on her palm. “I’m trying Valerie today,” she said casually, as if she was telling us she was trying out a new hairstyle.
“Wait, so you name is not Jane?” Kim asked, obviously still confused.
“Jane was my name three days ago. Today it’s Valerie,” she said as she flipped through her notebook. “Really, does anyone have a good word for this? Has anyone fallen from a great height? What did it feel like?” She continued to search through her notebook.
“Okay, so you’re real name isn’t Valerie either?” Kim continued to question.
“Her name is Elizabeth,” my other friend, Wendy, interrupted loudly. “I heard the teacher call her that.”
The girl stopped flipping through her notebook, but her hand remained frozen in the air. For a second she sat completely still. Then her eyes drifted over to my friend, followed by only the slightest rotation of her head. “Well that was quite rude,” she said softly. “Introducing someone who isn’t ready to be introduced.”
“I’m being rude? All I did was tell them your name!” Wendy said defensively.
The girl’s deep green eyes fixed on Wendy, but it was a blank stare, almost like she was looking past her. “Maybe that’s what you though you did, but Elizabeth is my middle name. Teachers have a hard time remembering one name, let alone many. I let they believe my name is Elizabeth for simplicity reasons.” Wendy stared at the girl poisonously. After a moment of silence that felt too long, the girl blinked. Her eyes became softer, uninterested. “But you may call me Elizabeth.” She looked away, and the strange tension in the air immediately dispersed. I looked around at my friends, they were sharing a look that said: What’s with this girl?
Then suddenly, the girl, whose name was obviously not Elizabeth, looked straight at me. “Mirabelle,” she said.
I was surprised. I didn’t think she knew my name. “Most people call me Miri…” I replied awkwardly.
“That’s nice,” she said quickly, then went on, “Do you have a word for me?”
“A…a word?” She stared at me impatiently. “Oh!” I remembered, “For your poem.” I thought blankly for a few seconds. “No, no I don’t think I’ve ever fallen from anything tall before,” I told her. She sighed, disappointed. I felt bad. “Sorry,” I said guiltily.
“No, it’s fine. I didn’t expect you to,” she said, hopelessly. “So no one has ever fallen from anything high up?” We shook our heads. She sighed again. “I still need a word,”
“Maybe you can ask someone else?” Kim suggested, probably hinting for her to leave.
“No, I’ll just find one myself,” She said, totally dismissing the idea. “You should continue with your lunch.” The girl climbed to the other side of the tree, away from us. My friends took her advice. Turning away from her, they huddled together, and started whispering about what just happened.
“Oh my god, what is her problem?” Wendy asked me, still bewildered.
“I don’t…I don’t know,” I murmured, not really focused the conversation. I was watching the girl climb the tree. It looked like she was climbing to the top. She was halfway there, and almost ten feet off the ground. Wendy followed my gaze.
“You know, you can get a detention for that!” Wendy shouted up at her.
“It’s fine, I’ll only be up here for a moment,” she yelled back. The girl was now near the top of the tree, twenty feet off the ground. She climbed to the edge of the branch, and let go. Just like that.
My stomach dropped, and I instinctively ran towards her as she fell. By the time I got to the other side of the tree, she had already landed. I stood above her, eyes wide with shock. She had landed on her back, which was better than her stomach, but it was still a long drop. What worried me most was that her eyes were closed. My hands and legs were shaking. I looked behind me, at my friends. None of them had moved. They just watched. We just stared at each other, my mouth agape. I was frozen for what seemed like an hour. I didn’t want to turn around for fear I would be looking at a broken body, or worse, a corpse.
“Mirabelle,” she coughed. My head whipped around towards her. Thank god, she was alive. I mentally scolded myself for being so scared. Of course she’s alive, it wasn’t that far of a drop. The question is, is she hurt? Her eyes remained closed as she spoke. “Would you be kind enough to pick up my notebook, please?” she asked.
“S…sure,” I said still a bit shaky. “Are you okay?” I asked as I picked up her notebook from the grass.
“Oh, I’m splendid,” Her eyes were still closed, but now she was smiling, a broad, white smile. “Now would you please please open to the page marked with a pencil,” I followed her orders, almost mindlessly. I didn’t really know what was happening. “Erase ‘to fear death’ and replace it with ‘to be dropped’.”
I did this, and asked, “Are you sure you’re okay? Do you want to sit up?”
“I would,” she sighed in a strangely tranquil way, “but I’m a bit dull and forgot to breathe out when I hit the ground, so as a result I’m going to lay here incapacitated for a few minutes and catch my breath. Do you see the last line where I left off?”
I nodded, but remembered her eyes were still closed. “Yeah,” I said.
“Write in ‘the world had stopped’.”
“Okay,” I murmured when I finished. I realized my friends were standing behind me. For how long, I had no idea.
“If you would please read the last stanza…” she requested in almost a business-like tone.
So I did:
“‘And he jumped
He leapt
Straight off the edge
Just to feel what it meant to be dropped
And as he fell down
And came close to the ground
It felt like the world had stopped.’”
“Brilliant,” she said. “I’ll add a few more stanzas, then it will be complete.” Her eyes had opened, and she was attempting to get up.
“Here, I’ll help,” I offered, moving in to support her.
“Do NOT,” she snapped. I backed off. She shook her head, as if shaking something off, and her voice softened, “Thank you for the offer, but I know how to sit up.” She got to her feet in a painfully slow fashion. I handed the notebook to her. “What is your last name, Mirabelle?”
“Um, Evans?” I told her uncertainly. She stared at me blankly for a moment, like she didn’t hear me. “Evans,” I said more confidently. “Mirabelle Evans.”
She held out her hand. I shook it. “Mirabelle Evans, my name is Fantyss Elizabeth Eidolon. Pleasure to meet you.” Fantyss let go of my hand, turned to my friends, and nodded slightly in their direction. Then she turned and walked away, twirling a pencil between her fingers. I had a feeling that would not be my last encounter with the girl whose name was Fantyss.
Points:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
Hello Corax, Wolf here for a review.
I think in total I noticed two or three little tiny grammatical errors, but they are quite small and can easily be found by a quick reread. So I would recommend you to do that. Though, I really, really loved this. This basically sums up exactly how I feel when I'm writing (I wouldn't actually fall off a tree for my writing, but I do get curious about how my characters feel while experiencing things.)
This girl, Fantyss, is extremely interesting. She really takes her writing to the extreme and has a huge passion for it. I love that about her! She's bugging these people who she hardly knows about a word for a poem that they hardly care about, and when she doesn't get her answer, she just takes matters into her own hands, love it!
I like how you really use the narrator's focus on the strange girl, Fantyss (pretty name), to kind of shower eccentric personality and you added in a really nice balance of everything, ranging from descriptions to action to dialogue. Oh, so great!
Your character interactions are especially phenomenal. Just through the dialogue alone, I can really see how this crowd isn't really friends with this random girl who just showed up to lunch one day, but (most of them) are too nice to say anything to her like "Scram, Werido!" Your character development too is amazing and I wasn't really lost on who was saying what.
Sorry this wasn't much criticism, but I really connected with this. Very fun read for me. Happy Review Day and Keep Writing,
~Wolfare
If I ever become something like Fantyss, shoot me! :p But, seriously, I really enjoyed this.
What I love about Fantyss is that she seems to be the embodyment of everything an author is, to an extreme. While she's a humorous character, for sure, you've made her believable, right down to the strange, memorable name; Fantyss seems like someone I could meet in real life-most likely through a writer's group of some kind.
That last sentence bothers me a bit, though. "... the girl whose name was Fantyss." I can't quite figure out what bothers me so much about it, though. Maybe it's just that it seems to me that "the girl whose name was" is unnecessary. I'll read the next part and see if it makes more sense to me then. Expect a review there in about five or ten minutes.
Wow! I loved reading this! The use of dialogue in the story really helped to portray the characters' personalities. The poet has more eloquence, and the other students don't have that as much. Keep writing onto the story.
Ah, being a writer. Such a blessing and a curse. Blessed with such a passion that is there whenever you need it most. Being able to convert large concepts and simple pleasures into works of art. Cursed by the rest of the world that condemns such creativity when it isn't what they want or how the expect.
I feel like that is something that everyone can take from this work of art which you have presented! It is very relatable. Also, i can also relate to asking people for words, when they just look at me like i am mad before actually trying to help. I also love how realistic the characters were, especially Wendy. She was just so closed minded and slightly ignorant. Although, she didn't see to have purely wicked intentions, and she was very real.
One of the best ways, i feel, to find inspiration is to feel what you are writing about. That is one of the reasons that i love the scene where Fantyss jumps from the tree. Also, it was such a bold thing to do. She also felt very real to me, and in the best way possible. I could relate to her.
I also love how Mirabelle didn't remember her name. It was just that tiny thing that let us know that she wasn't very popular and usually wasn't noticed, or at least, was noticed in a negative way. It was just this small clue that allows readers to pick up that message from the very beginning.
You used sensory language very well in this story. It was very visual, which i personally enjoy. It flowed well, especially the parts that used a lot of sensory language.
"She got to her feet painfully slowly."
I personally think that you should say something a bit more along the lines of:
"She got to her feet in a manner that was painfully slow."
I'm not sure how i like the two adverbs back to back like that. It's just a suggestion, so if you feel that it is better how it is, then keep it the way that it is.
"Please read the last stanza...." she requested.
This is merely a suggestion. I personally think that you should put an adverb after the word "requested." I noticed that you did that in some of your other verbs expressing the action of speaking.
I personally do not think that any major revisions should be made. This story is amazing, and i do wish to read more of it, and more of your work in general.